• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary Army (read this book)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Funky Papa

FUNK-Y-PPA-4
So some days ago I decided that I needed a break from my usual late night fiction romps. In need of something more serious, I picked Jeremy Scahill's Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary Army, which as its name explains, it chronicles the rise of what it was known as the world's top tier private military contractor.

UB2vHlm.jpg

The book itself pretty opens with the infamous 2004 Fallujah ambush, when a number of Blackwater mercenaries ended with their charred and mutilated corpses being put on display. This incident brought Blackwater into the spotlight; what the media didn't quite tell is that entire armies of military contractors were roaming the streets without any authority to restrain them, nor how that situation came to be.

With no laws to oversee their activity in Iraq (as a matter of fact, the Bush administration did its best to ensure that the new Iraqi government couldn't punish them, nor they were obliged to comply with military regulations for a very long time), Blackwater mercenaries were involved in the murder of civilians, evidence tampering, smuggling operations, the works. At the height of its power, Blackwater even afforded itself the luxury of making death threats to a US State Department investigator. For the most part, Blackwater's crimes remain unpunished.

The book is not just about Blackwater, though, as it also covers the privatization policies enacted by Donald Rumsfeld and Dick Cheney, which helped to chop a large part of the American armed apparatus' under the notion of improving its efficiency (a well calibrated farce, as Halliburton and others made out like bandits overcharging exorbitant amounts of money for the most basic services), making it so dependant of contractors that America's force projection during an invasion scenario would be effectively crippled.

A great example is provided by the PMCs working on Iraq at behest of the US government, which in order to accomplish their missions had to be supplied with intelligence provided by PMC Aegis Defence at the princely sum of half a billion dollars. The situation was patently ridiculous, if not absurd. Military intelligence was so strategically starved of resources that it had to resort to outsource its activities in order to make sure that high ranking American officials and all kinds of companies working in Iraq were safe from insurgent and Islamist groups. It really says something that America had to resort to veritable pond-scum like Tim Spicer to get shit done as if it were some disfunctional African fiefdom.

Scahill also devotes a great deal of the book to shine some light on Blackwater's founder Erik Prince's origins. Typically depicted as a former SEAL and rugged capitalist, Prince comes from old money and seemingly funded Blackwater upon the idea of one of his former superiors. Already worth close to a billion dollars by the time he formed Blackwater, he's closely tied by blood and politics to both the craziest fringes of the Catholic and Evangelical churches (which would later became the Tea Party), but also to some of the most powerful members of corporate America, which provided him with high level contacts, some significant media clout and massive lobbying power, which were put to use to reinvent what amounted to a training facility for the FBI and local police departments in a Virginia swamp into a veritable army with its own navy and air force.

These days the Blackwater of yore no longer exists. After a number of fallouts and Erik Prince's exit (who now earns his bread "advising" Chinese companies to exploit Africa's natural resources, ever the capitalist patriot) Blackwater was renamed a number of times and finally bought by the rather nebulous Constellis Group, which also owns PMC Triple Canopy, which in turn picked up Blackwater's business in Iraq after Washington found the situation in Iraq untenable and reassigned contracts. How quaint. Now called Academi, Blackwater is steered by moral luminaries such as John Ashcroft, Jack Quinn and Bobby Ray Inman. The company is no longer in the spotlight, but the environment that allowed it thrive remains and America's military is still profoundly (and venomously) dependent of PMCs, which are still making bank at the expenses of America's sovereignty. You just don't know about their names.

While well researched, the book itself can be a bit ponderous and falls prey to the author's penchant to repeat the same points over and over again, which makes for a bit of an unpalatable read. There's also an evident anti-privatization bias on his part, although given the consequences of outsourcing even the most basic functions of the army that is hardly something that can be used against him.

Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary Army is a troubling and important piece of muckraking journalism that should be an obligatory read for anybody interested in the workings of the military industrial complex and how it's quickly eroding the sovereignty of America in new and extremely toxic ways for the profit of a few powerful men. Go read it, GAF.
 

demon

I don't mean to alarm you but you have dogs on your face
This has sat in my amazon wishlist for a long time and I've been meaning to get it. Looks interesting and I usually enjoy his appearances on Real Time.
 

Fury451

Banned
Black water is just the precursor to Atlas

No Spacey swag though. And still more comically villainous than Atlas somehow.

Thanks for the heads up OP, never heard of this. Just finished a book and looking for another, and this sounds right up my alley.
 

Icefire1424

Member
Funky, I think you missed your calling as a professional literary critic. That was an exceptionally thought out and well written review. Anyways, I'm definitely intrigued, even though I do have a particular penchant for WW2 military history, especially anything written by Stephen Ambrose.
 

Brickhunt

Member
I actually have it in my bookshelf. Was contemplating reading it some days ago. I guess I know what i'm reading tonight.
 

Parakeetman

No one wants a throne you've been sitting on!
Not that great of a book really. Talked with folks in the industry about it and those who have written on the subject.

Far better materials exist.

http://www.amazon.com/dp/0801474361/?tag=neogaf0e-20
(very info heavy, may cause those with low attention spans eyes to glaze over)

http://www.amazon.com/dp/1400097819/?tag=neogaf0e-20

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_pD32oqOiS4
If you can find a copy of this documentary for purchase also well done. As it has interviews with folks in the industry itself which also includes both Peter Singer and Robert Young Pelton both authors who are included in the links above.

Though to be fair you are all better off reading as much info on the issue itself rather than just taking the word of a single writer as gospel. Even after that I still dont like the book that Mr. Scahill wrote.
 

Funky Papa

FUNK-Y-PPA-4
Not that great of a book really. Talked with folks in the industry about it and those who have written on the subject.

Far better materials exist.

http://www.amazon.com/dp/0801474361/?tag=neogaf0e-20
(very info heavy, may cause those with low attention spans eyes to glaze over)

http://www.amazon.com/dp/1400097819/?tag=neogaf0e-20

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_pD32oqOiS4
If you can find a copy of this documentary for purchase also well done. As it has interviews with folks in the industry itself which also includes both Peter Singer and Robert Young Pelton both authors who are included in the links above.

Though to be fair you are all better off reading as much info on the issue itself rather than just taking the word of a single writer as gospel. Even after that I still dont like the book that Mr. Scahill wrote.

Corporate Warriors is probably a better book (it's definitely much better written; Scahill could have cut a good 50 pages from his book and nobody would ever notice), but it's also much more academic and may not be as approachable. It also covers the entire industry instead of focusing in Blackwater, which may be a pro or a con depending on how much do you want to soak in. I'm also totally unsurprised about people in the industry being miffed by Scahill for all the obvious reasons.

Yay for corporate loopholes!
It is less of a loophole than a carefully orchestrated and extremely well thought strategy. The political and corporate forces behind the privatization efforts did a real number on America's army.
 

Parakeetman

No one wants a throne you've been sitting on!
Corporate Warriors is probably a better book (it's definitely much better written; Scahill could have cut a good 50 pages from his book and nobody would ever notice), but it's also much more academic and may not be as approachable. It also covers the entire industry instead of focusing in Blackwater, which may be a pro or a con depending on how much do you want to soak in. I'm also totally unsurprised about people in the industry being miffed by Scahill for all the obvious reasons.


It is less of a loophole than a carefully orchestrated and extremely well thought strategy. The political and corporate forces behind the privatization efforts did a real number on America's army.

It also includes people that are writers who think Scahill is a hack. One that actually stood up in front of congress ripping apart the stuff Scahill said. Which is why the two of them do not get along well. The way he went about things was more due to his personality which shows in the book that he got locked out of a lot of stuff he hes basically the guy standing outside the wall trying to peek inside and fill in the blanks. Rather than having actual experience with the subject. Its like people who soapbox on things half cocked is how he came across to me. Way too personal and came across more as ranting than actually presenting information / facts. While there may be some good info in there, dude basically sabotages his own book with his personality.

Agree with you 100% about the Singer stuff, but for serious research & knowledge it most def is a worthwhile read for those who are genuinely interested in the subject. But just as you said it is very heavy with the info and comes off more like reading an actual report than a standard book itself. The other book that he put out about drones and such was interesting too, though I have unfortunately still not finished it.
 

Parakeetman

No one wants a throne you've been sitting on!
Blackwater hasn't gone away either, IIRC. They changed their name to XS or something.

They are now know as Academi, formerly Xe.

There really isnt much to do on the circuit currently, so a lot of those companies in general have gone back to what they were doing originally or more focused training for overseas clients. But manpower in general is most def cut.

This is word from folks who are still running the circuit at the moment and why lots of guys for the most part are on downtime looking for other things to do or returning to work they used to have before the goldrush.

Others have taken up jobs with maritime security. But one thing for sure is the industry is not like what it used to be during the Iraq / Afghanistan gold rush days. Which is a good thing, since that was a huge clusterfuck if you read about all the history involved with contracts and money flying all over the place with little to no checks on what was going to who.

Its why for a while for example the US Govt was actually $$$ to a sub company Viktor Bout owned at the start of the Iraq war, they couldnt cut connections due to they needed the equipment to be transported and in fast and that was one of the companies who could do it. Lots of other messed up examples and such. But you gotta go through a lot of different resources to see a better idea of the picture when you start piecing things together.

Im not really on either side of the issue as its been something that has been going on for a long time in history in general. At least these days with how connected the world is in general for information it is easier for things to be monitored and controlled if necessary.
 

Bloodrage

Banned
I've been meaning to check this out. I like Jeremy Scahill's stuff.

Edit: Why does the paperback cost more than the hardcover?
 

Parakeetman

No one wants a throne you've been sitting on!
I've been meaning to check this out. I like Jeremy Scahill's stuff.

Edit: Why does the paperback cost more than the hardcover?

Could be stock related, such as lots of places are stuck with a ton of hardcovers but low stock on paperback and want to "nudge" the buyer to pick up the hardcovers instead.

Kinda odd, since its generally the other way around.

If I do recall correctly the book originally came out as a hardcover I think. At least I do not remember paperback being available when I did my order, which I would have as shipping overseas is killer when it comes to weight.
 

Bloodrage

Banned
Could be stock related, such as lots of places are stuck with a ton of hardcovers but low stock on paperback and want to "nudge" the buyer to pick up the hardcovers instead.

Kinda odd, since its generally the other way around.

If I do recall correctly the book originally came out as a hardcover I think. At least I do not remember paperback being available when I did my order, which I would have as shipping overseas is killer when it comes to weight.
Ordered the hardcover. Thanks for the info.
 

Parakeetman

No one wants a throne you've been sitting on!
oh man i forgot all about that abomination of a game.

check out the king of all cheese trailers for it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HDWB_4eEnCk

More cheesy than Wisconsin. Vermont Aged White Cheddar status. Wow.

The only reason I know it exists is because I saw it in the bargain bin at GameStop. I was like "Who? When? Why?!" Do you actually move your finger to pull the trigger? Yeah, I'm sure that worked well...
 
Jeremy Scahill is easily one of my favorite journalist.

If you like this make sure to read Dirty Wars: The World is a Battlefield and watch the documentary that's on Netflix.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom