From that 2014 list, here are the 4* and 5* pro style QBs:
1. Kyle Allen -- Mixed bag of a career. Probably will transfer to Texas and you can expect he'll start if he does.
2. Will Grier -- Stuck with a dumpster fire offense as a FR, transferred to WVU. Probably starter since their Senior QB graduated.
3. Keller Chryst -- Starter at Stanford now.
4. David Cornwell -- Never heard of him. Who knows what happens next but I see he's leaving Bama.
5. Jacob Park -- Now the starter at Iowa State. Had a decent season it looks like, will be a JR next year.
6. Drew Barker -- Began as the starter, back injury ended his season.
7. Brad Kaaya -- Will be drafted into the NFL after a solid career at Miami.
8. Sean White -- Not very good but Auburn won some games with him when he was healthy. Maybe he can develop further but doesn't look like he'll amount to much.
9. Clayton Thorson -- 3200 yards, 22/9 ratio for Northwestern this season. Can't ask for much more than that.
10. Caleb Henderson -- Transferred to Maryland. TBD next season.
11. K.J. Carta-Samuels -- Lost job to Browning.
12. DeShone Kizer -- Expected to be a 1st round draft pick (top 5-10 mentioned)
13. JJ Cosentino -- Garbage. He'd be crazy not to transfer out from FSU.
14. Michael O'Connor -- Transferred to University of British Columbia and threw for 3600 yards and 22 TDs this season. Interesting.
15. Jalan McClendon -- Backup QB.
16. Mason Rudolph -- Looks like a future Heisman hopeful. Unbelievably talented. Future 1st rounder for sure.
Its being selective in your criteria, when people talk about 5* its always composite, there would be way to many 5*'s if you counted each service's 5*.
Either way, it doesn't change the fact that QB recruits(especially pro-style) are a crap shoot.
No it's not. If someone is an All-American from one of the organizations who select them, then they're an All-American in general. A 5* recruit is a 5* recruit. There are about 35-40 kids who are 5*s regardless of whether or not you use the composite rankings from some "proprietary algorithm" or not. There's 4 recruiting sites and they more or less all have the same players in the top 30-35. The numbers might shift but the players are largely the same.