RPCGamer
Neophyte
Don't know why this game is not on GOG. I replayed it last year on X360.
It has awesome atmosphere. Combat is simple, it motivates the player to use bullets wisely and the investigation side is cool.
I thought the levels were a little monotonous to be honest, especially when you are underground. The story is confusing and ambiguous but at the same time is interesting.
Anyway the game is fantastic! As for Condemned 2, i think the changes made it tedious to play.
I kinda wonder if a reboot with some fixes and tweaks would see it do well. It doesn't need to be a high budget title (kinda think the less detail can be effective in itself), but there's a potential there.