• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Eternal Sunshine of a Spotless Mind / lost love discussion

Status
Not open for further replies.

J2 Cool

Member
The 1-10 happiness thread made me want to talk about Eternal Sunshine once I got started. Just seen it last week for the first time myself so late to the party. Comment from other thread

"yeah, that movie, better than any other ever, hits you like that. The good and bad of the relationship. Not even remembering why it got so screwed up and also remebering the weird child-like fun you guys had together. But in the end it's uplifting knowing you had those memories and they're so cherished. Just wish you could start over again though, that parts sad :( Damn that's a great movie. My next buy on dvd"

What also hit very home was that last scene on the beach. Where Jim Carrey's gonna leave and she asks him to just stay this time. She asks if he could at least say goodbye. My similar story about my ex was through our whole relationship we knew I would eventually move from next door. I moved in, fell in love, and moved out within 7 months. Didnt really know each other the first month. She made a point to meet me first. Then I wasnt sure what she thought but she kept coming back every week or two to say Hi. So eventually we exchanged IM's and then road the same bus, etc, etc.

Have those akward but memorable scenes like her throwing rocks at my window over winter break at like midnight, us standing in the snow close while I try to block the wind, Her watching me play Shenmue 2 on New Year's Eve and meeting my friends, talking to 5am in the morning all winter break, hanging out till 3am "watching movies" on my b-day.. This all in the month we became close. Then over the 6 months I couldnt name enough other moments. We were still crazy about each other the last day I moved. Made it a note to say "let's enjoy this" the last week and last day which hit me hard in the movie. Hung out the entire day running around an empty house, having her try to wrestle with me in my front lawn, finding secluded areas to make out in my empty house, carrying each other on the moving roller. Never stopping to catch our breath the whole day. It ended though when we seen dark come and the movers were getting the last heavy things. She asked if I wanted one more run through of the house and I said no. I told her to "come here" and we sat on my porch's swing which oddly we never sat on once. We just layed together choked up crying, as we watched the mover's loading the last stuff, while we whispered stuff to each other and held each other until they were done and I had to leave.

And that's the last memory I have of the way things were. It got ugly and different after I moved and I don't even know how. There's no contact now. But the movie did make me happy to know I'm able to hold on to these memories. Oh, and Jim Carrey's easily one of my favorite actors ever. He's amazing. He plays comedy, quirky, real, dramatic, anything. Never seen such control in an actor to pick and choose just exactly what he wants to hit. I put him right up there at the top with the best actors in the business today. Anyway, got the words out I was going for.. Hand the thread over now
 

demon

I don't mean to alarm you but you have dogs on your face
Have those akward but memorable scenes like her throwing rocks at my window over winter break at like midnight, us standing in the snow close while I try to block the wind, Her watching me play Shenmue 2 on New Year's Eve and meeting my friends, talking to 5am in the morning all winter break, hanging out till 3am "watching movies" on my b-day.. This all in the month we became close. Then over the 6 months I couldnt name enough other moments. We were still crazy about each other the last day I moved. Made it a note to say "let's enjoy this" the last week and last day which hit me hard in the movie. Hung out the entire day running around an empty house, having her try to wrestle with me in my front lawn, finding secluded areas to make out in my empty house, carrying each other on the moving roller. Never stopping to catch our breath the whole day. It ended though when we seen dark come and the movers were getting the last heavy things. She asked if I wanted one more run through of the house and I said no. I told her to "come here" and we sat on my porch's swing which oddly we never sat on once. We just layed together choked up crying, as we watched the mover's loading the last stuff, while we whispered stuff to each other and held each other until they were done and I had to leave.
Dude, that almost made me a bit misty eyed. Almost. ;) And i've never even been in a relationship. I can imagine it, though. And it seems like a beautiful thing. I'd be so afraid of getting that close to a girl and knowing it would end, though. Then again, knowing I'm in my early 20s and have never experienced something like that makes me kind of depressed.

But, umm....I lost a dog once.

Just curious, how old were you when you were with her?
 

J2 Cool

Member
demon said:
Dude, that almost made me a bit misty eyed. Almost. ;) And i've never even been in a relationship. I can imagine it, though. And it seems like a beautiful thing. I'd be so afraid of getting that close to a girl and knowing it would end, though. Then again, knowing I'm in my early 20s and have never experienced something like that makes me kind of depressed.

But, umm....I lost a dog once.

Just curious, how old were you when you were with her?

17, her 16
 
I don't really have any stories related to the movie, but I thought Adaptation and Being John Malkovich were A LOT better than Eternal Sunshine...
 

Mama Smurf

My penis is still intact.
When I look back on past relationships, all I see is a lack of caring (for example I'm still friends with an ex, and out relationship was fine, but there was nothing strong there) or bitterness. Intense bitterness which hopefully one day I'll let go of.

...and I'm not sure which one of us is better off.
 
I just watched this movie last night. Wow, it really was amazing. Best movie I've seen this year and one the best I've ever seen. Can't say enough about Jim Carrey. The guy is a wonderful actor.
 

J2 Cool

Member
Bacon said:
I don't really have any stories related to the movie, but I thought Adaptation and Being John Malkovich were A LOT better than Eternal Sunshine...

Never seen either. Are you just not impressed with Eternal Sunshine or are they that good?
 
Eternal Sunshine is good, but I don't think it's as great as people are hyping it to be in this thread. Like, I don't see how anyone can say that it's more clever than Adaptation, which is just a really neat concept.

I won't say Eternal Sunshine is amazing, but it is a good movie with a nice story.
 
Can't speak for Adaptation, as I haven't seen it, but Being John Malkovich is one of my favorite movies of all time. Perfectly abstract yet fleshed out, just like Eternal Sunshine.
 

demon

I don't mean to alarm you but you have dogs on your face
J2 Cool said:
Never seen either. Are you just not impressed with Eternal Sunshine or are they that good?
Meh. IMO, Eternal Sunshine was just slightly better than Being John Malkovich, which was better than Adaptation. Adaptation was really interesting, but I found Eternal Sunshine to be far more moving than either of the other two movies.
 

J2 Cool

Member
Eternal Sunshine has so many little nuances I love though. Like when Clementine was in his memories it was his accumulated thought of who she was. She may have not said any of that but thats what he thought she would say, thats who he thinks she is. Always laughing and fun, even if she has a lot shorter temper than he imagined. Also, when they meet after the memory thing she says her names Clementine and says dont make any jokes which he doesnt this time. It shows how he changed as a person soley because of her and just didnt approach her the same way. It's just so well rounded. It's smart, sad, uplifting, and seriously funny but not to an akward extent. Right ammount of everything. I never felt as many mixed emotions when watching a movie. Not to mention its as weird as it needs to be to help this film hit the right spots. Again, just the right ammount and perfect effects to exaggerate and get across how he feels. It's really a one of a kind film.
 

etiolate

Banned
A couple relationships remind of the movie. One when I was in highschool, which was full of all those moments you don't want to forget, even though it ended horribly. The other relationship didn't end horribly, but it just broke down and at one point was like the "Dining Dead" scene.
 
J2 Cool said:
Also, when they meet after the memory thing she says her names Clementine and says dont make any jokes which he doesnt this time. It shows how he changed as a person soley because of her and just didnt approach her the same way. It's just so well rounded.

He didn't make a comment about her name because he didn't really know any jokes about it, not because he changed as a person. Everything related to her and her name (including the Huckleberry Hound reference) was erased.
 

J2 Cool

Member
Bacon said:
He didn't make a comment about her name because he didn't really know any jokes about it, not because he changed as a person. Everything related to her and her name (including the Huckleberry Hound reference) was erased.

oops. yeah, my bad but still a cool nuance. I noticed a ton the whole way through I just can't recall them really with one viewing. I even lapsed on Clementine's name for a second
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom