-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Game of Thrones - Season 2 - George RR Martin's Song of Ice and Fire - Sundays on HBO
- Thread starter Cornballer
- Start date
- Status
bengraven
Member
-Plasma Reus-
Service guarantees member status
So...
Stannis is the rightful heir.
Renly has no right to the throne since he is fourth in line. I don't know what his problem is really. He should just stop wasting everyone's time and help is brother.
Robb Stark wants to avenge his father, kill Joffery and every other Lannister. And declare the North a separate Kingdom. At least that's what I gather from this trailer.
Everyone agrees Joffery needs to die already.
So why don't they do the following:
Renly stops being an arse, joins his brother and Robb to sack King's Landing. Stannis declares the North free and a separate kingdom. They put Joffrey in the dungeons with men who have a ...certain taste for young meat. And.. feed cersei to the direwolves. She probably thought the north forgot about that shit she did to Sansa's poor direwolf Lady. The north remembers, bitch.
This whole situation reminds me of boondocks.
Stannis is the rightful heir.
Renly has no right to the throne since he is fourth in line. I don't know what his problem is really. He should just stop wasting everyone's time and help is brother.
Robb Stark wants to avenge his father, kill Joffery and every other Lannister. And declare the North a separate Kingdom. At least that's what I gather from this trailer.
Everyone agrees Joffery needs to die already.
So why don't they do the following:
Renly stops being an arse, joins his brother and Robb to sack King's Landing. Stannis declares the North free and a separate kingdom. They put Joffrey in the dungeons with men who have a ...certain taste for young meat. And.. feed cersei to the direwolves. She probably thought the north forgot about that shit she did to Sansa's poor direwolf Lady. The north remembers, bitch.
This whole situation reminds me of boondocks.
fallengorn
Bitches love smiley faces
That's a loaded question for this thread. I'll just say everyone has their own motivations for doing the things they do and leave it at that.
But I will correct you in saying Renly is second in-line to Stannis.
Cornballer
Member
New trailer looks great.
- Quick hits from WiC.net. I think we've covered most of these already, but there might be a few new ones in there.
- Quick hits from WiC.net. I think we've covered most of these already, but there might be a few new ones in there.
28 Posts Later
Member
Edit: Please don't correct me anymore.
Renly believes he should be king, not Stannis. He doesn't believe in the line of succession and points to the fact Robert took the throne from the Targaryens [as stated to Ned before he fled Kings Landing]. The scene with Lora's in season one formed the idea.
Indeed. Ultimately he wants his sisters returned though.
You'll see why during the season.
To be fair if you haven't read the books you won't yet understand the events that unfold and the motivations [and personalities] of all the characters you're discussing.
-Plasma Reus-
Service guarantees member status
Thanks. Yea, I haven't really read the books. So it's going to be a fun ride for viewers like me.
And a quick question about this here:
And a quick question about this here:
But isn't the only reason that Robert was on the throne, and not Ned Stark/Jaime Lannister because one of Robert Baratheon's distant ancestors was a Targaryen? And in that sense, didn't the line of succession matter to an extent?
28 Posts Later
Member
No, I believe Robert claimed the throne after he killed Rhaegar. The other combatants [including Ned] refused the throne. You're right, in that technically he is distantly related to the Targaryens, but that's not the reason he's king.
He is not actually Robert's son.
Cabaratier
Neo Member
After all the rebels were united, it was decided they would stand behind Robert, whose grandmother had been the daughter of King Aegon V Targaryen, giving him the best claim to the throne outside of Aerys, his children and grandchildren.
http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/War_of_the_Usurper Series spoilers, obviously
28 Posts Later
Member
Ah, fair enough then, I didn't realize that factored in.
Either way Renly clearly doesn't agree with the line of succession and believes he would be a better king than Stannis due to the fact he is a popular figure.
Buckethead
Banned
Pretty obvious it was coming when Osha went from looking like Robert Smith to looking like a cat in heat.
:lol :lol
Funky Papa
FUNK-Y-PPA-4
BertramCooper
Banned
Holy shit, I never caught this until Dan and Dave's commentary on the season finale.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WF9UzgTkDG0#t=0m25s
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WF9UzgTkDG0#t=0m25s
RENLY IS NOT RIGHT!
fallengorn
Bitches love smiley faces
If only there was a hilarious facial expression to gif like the TDK No more dead cops gif.
Cornballer
Member
- WiC.net: New character profile video for Robb Stark
BertramCooper
Banned
I love how Dan, Dave, and Alan can't figure out how the hell that line actually got into the final cut - but they think it's awesome and hilarious and they're glad it's there.
It wasn't scripted; it was just some really shitty ad-lib by a random extra that somehow made it through.
It wasn't scripted; it was just some really shitty ad-lib by a random extra that somehow made it through.
BlueTsunami
there is joy in sucking dick
wait wat
Lawdy, can't wait for this scene
Also I love the contrast between the drabness of Dragonstone and its inhabitants and Melisandre's red garb.
Lionheart1337
Member
HAHA dat slap
timetokill
Banned
(ACoK)
Stannis knows that Joff (and the other kids) are the product of incest. He sends out a letter to everyone in the seven kingdoms saying as much, and that since they're not Robert's kids, that he is the rightful heir. There's never going to really be proof or anything since it's not like the have DNA testing in this era anyway.
Citizen_Insane
Member
I believe Ned sent out a letter to Stannis before he died.
Stannis believes he should be king, because Ned sent him a letter, just before he went to confront the queen and the little shit.
Edit: beaten.
28 Posts Later
Member
Fair enough, thanks for the correction - it's been a while since I read the novel.
bengraven
Member
I know. I'm like "pleaseshowit".
PhoenixDark
Banned
Stannis knows Joffery is illegitimate. It's why he left King's Landing; after the murder of Arryn, he knew a coup was happening.
He didn't know Joffery was illegitimate until Ned sent him the letter. If Stannis knew what Jon Arryn knew while at Kings Landing he would have told Robert.
Buckethead
Banned
Guess we aren't using spoiler tags anymore.
FFS.
FFS.
So wait, has (minor SoS spoilers)
Jeyne been rewritten as a commoner for the show? That girl Robb was talking to definitely looked like her, but was dressed like a serving maid. Can't say I like the change, if true.
elrechazado
Banned
Not really, Ned "knew" just as much as stannis knew. Only difference is that cersei confirmed it to one of them.
Not spoilered because this is the season 2 thread and that is season 1 stuff.
I would think Stannis would have confronted Cersi much like Ned did. He seems like the kind of guy that would do something like that. Perhaps I missed it but I thought Jon Arryn knew more than Stannis but Stannis knew something was not right.
Cornballer
Member
Keep an eye on your tags, folks. There are a few things that occur during the timeline of Season 1 but aren't revealed until later. If it hasn't happened on the television show, it should be tagged. Thanks.
PhoenixDark
Banned
He never received Ned's letter, as the carrier was killed. Stannis left King's Landing in anger after being spurned for the Hand appointment, and because he knew something was wrong with Joffery/Tommen/Myrcella
I will take your word for it as it's kind of blur to me right now. I should freshen up on the details.
Are you creating another thread with untagged spoilers like season 1?
wait wat
A similar scene was also in the earlier trailer if you were looking hard enough. Book 2 spoiler:
Osha and Theon? She will distract him while Bran makes his escape. This wasn't in book 2 though. Osha was waking up out of a bed in the seven devils trailer
PhoenixDark
Banned
anyway I ran across this on youtube, and now you all must share my fate
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=0nLl1kdzJvQ#!
wuuut lol
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=0nLl1kdzJvQ#!
wuuut lol
It's made pretty clear by Renly in the first season that he does not think Stannis will make a good king, which is why he chooses to go for it himself.
I'm not sure how much of this has been seen at all in the trailers, but (ACoK Spoilers)
if I do remember correctly, Stannis isn't one to abide by the concept of "The enemy of my enemy is my friend," and sees Renly as just as bad as Joffrey, in that they're both trying to take the throne that they have no right to. And since he sees himself as the true king, he sees Robb's actions as an open rebellion against his rule, and wants to bring him to justice.
And since it's been a while since I've read ACoK does anybody remember if (ACoK spoilers)
Stannis has any animosity towards the Starks? I remember him saying at one point that Robert treated Ned as more of a brother than he ever did with Stannis, but I thought that was more of a dig at Robert than anything else. Though his actions, unless explained in some way, could be construed by new viewers as being anti-Stark, since he and Robb both share a common enemy.
I'm just hoping that the show is able to convey Stannis in the same way as in the books (Stubborn adherence to his own code of honor, to a fault) rather than being the dick who thinks he is entitled to everything, and will stop at nothing to further his own power.
I'm just hoping that the show is able to convey Stannis in the same way as in the books (Stubborn adherence to his own code of honor, to a fault) rather than being the dick who thinks he is entitled to everything, and will stop at nothing to further his own power.
Funky Papa
FUNK-Y-PPA-4
I feel as if somebody slipped a pill in my coffee.
$70 million well spent.
bengraven
Member
She's wearing some nice clothes, just dirty.
There was just a battle at her father's castle - her dad is a Lannister bannerman. If I remember correctly, weren't they originally prisoners of Robbs before swearing to him?
KuwabaraTheMan
Banned
No, Stannis knew before Ned. (not really spoilers since it's mentioned in the first book, but I'll tag it since I think they glossed over this in the show)
Stannis and Jon Arryn were investigating the legitimacy of Robert's children together prior to the series. That's why the two of them were going around together examining Robert's bastards.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked