Jon Neu
Banned
Stargate? lol
Breaking Bad and the Sopranos were good, but Game Of Thrones was more ambitious and bigger in scope, while being at least as good script wise, if not actually better.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Game of Thrones Season 8 |OT| A Song of Icy and Fiery Fandom
- Thread starter cormack12
- Start date
Stargate? lol
Breaking Bad and the Sopranos were good, but Game Of Thrones was more ambitious and bigger in scope, while being at least as good script wise, if not actually better.
bitbydeath
Gold Member
I liked the twist on the ending.
Bran was the bad guy the entire time pretending to play dumb to gain power.
The Nights King was actually the good guy trying to put a stop to the evil Bran.
Clearly Sansa will be his next victim for the sly act she pulled in holding the title queen of the north.
Bran was the bad guy the entire time pretending to play dumb to gain power.
The Nights King was actually the good guy trying to put a stop to the evil Bran.
Clearly Sansa will be his next victim for the sly act she pulled in holding the title queen of the north.
AV
We ain't outta here in ten minutes, we won't need no rocket to fly through space
Initial reaction without scrolling through pages of forums: half incredibly predictable, half makes no sense. I'm in the money from all the bets I put on: Starks alive, Tyrion the hand, Sansa queen of an independent north, Arya off doing her own thing, Sam Grand Maester, Yara ruling the Irons. Made £60 from those. The betting sites will all be laughing to the iron bank today thanks to all the "will sit on the Iron Throne" bets being moot, since there's no throne. A lot of salty gamblers this morning.
But we're supposed to believe the Unsullied and Dothraki would watch a man, who just betrayed and then plotted to kill their queen, convince a group of people they've never heard of nor care about that some cripple should be king, and then just say "yeah okay as long as the usurper gets sent to live on a wall, we'll just piss off now peacefully".
Yeah, okay. Can't wait to see people justify that one.
Hell, at least it's over now and we just remember seasons 1-4 fondly.
But we're supposed to believe the Unsullied and Dothraki would watch a man, who just betrayed and then plotted to kill their queen, convince a group of people they've never heard of nor care about that some cripple should be king, and then just say "yeah okay as long as the usurper gets sent to live on a wall, we'll just piss off now peacefully".
Yeah, okay. Can't wait to see people justify that one.
Hell, at least it's over now and we just remember seasons 1-4 fondly.
Chairman Tickles
Banned
Donchu lol at muh stargate.
Game of Thrones was a relatively low budget affair up until later. The strongest aspect was the characterization owing to the fact they all had many books worth of dialogue to say on camera. That's about it bro. The story is super generic. The actual War of the Roses is more interesting.
Last edited:
Kadayi
Banned
Statements like that make me wonder what you've been watching. Much love for GOT, but please.
Ulysses 31
Gold Member
He misspelled Babylon 5.
TTOOLL
Member
Wow, that was worse than the leaks, it was kinda soulless, people were like yeah let's finish this whatever.
Anybody who defends this is completely blind.
I don't feel like listing all the cons because people have done it already, but that council meeting was one of the WORST scenes I've ever seen. For a few minutes and when convenient to the plot, fucking Grey Worm was the most powerful person in Westeros. Fuck that guy.
Anybody who defends this is completely blind.
I don't feel like listing all the cons because people have done it already, but that council meeting was one of the WORST scenes I've ever seen. For a few minutes and when convenient to the plot, fucking Grey Worm was the most powerful person in Westeros. Fuck that guy.
Chairman Tickles
Banned
Awesome, but corny as fuck. It's one of those shows I have to turn off whenever somebody walks into the room.
Jon Neu
Banned
Game of Thrones was much more expensive to make than Breaking Bad or the Sopranos, even at the beginning. And it has always being a deep coral cast of characters and places, while BB and Sopranos relied on a few places and a few characters at the beginning. Sometimes they are actually a one man show.
And no, Game Of Thrones story was the contrary of generic, it was set in a generic setting, but did a lot of fresh and smart things before they run out of books to adapt.
Kenpachii
Member
Absolute fantastic ending, I kinda predicted most of it already as the writing was on the wall. Bran being the king made absolutely sense dude is perfect for it. Arya going on exploration, snow rejoined with his dog and going to the absolute north was already forcasted and predictable, sansa the queen of the north, absolutely fantastic.
Also dany was well done, she became power hungry and completely wonky, i liked the tension it created between characters. I liked how bran also mentioned that he will track the dragon to see what happens.
The writing in the book, the new rulers the way they rule the new kingdoms now is also absolutely fantastic.
All and all very very well done.
Also dany was well done, she became power hungry and completely wonky, i liked the tension it created between characters. I liked how bran also mentioned that he will track the dragon to see what happens.
The writing in the book, the new rulers the way they rule the new kingdoms now is also absolutely fantastic.
All and all very very well done.
Last edited:
Frank Spencer
Banned
Last edited:
Rentahamster
Rodent Whores
WTF are Grey Worm and The Unsullied going to do in Naath? Die from butteryfly poison?
Rentahamster
Rodent Whores
hahaha 
Rentahamster
Rodent Whores
Also, spending all that time on what looked like Chekhov's white horse at the end of episode 5 amounted to absolutely nothing hahaha.
Frank Spencer
Banned
I think most of my issues with this season, and they are extensive, could have been mollified if they had just reversed the Cersei/NK arcs. Let Dany go to KL with her full army and torch KL. Jon and the rest are horrified, but they MUST work with her to defeat the NK. Then WF plays out with Bran and Arya and somehow, in the battle, Jon kills or lets Dany die. EVERYTHING else plays out basically the same way. But that change alone I think would have extended the "Dany gone crazy" arc, let the shift in loyalties take longer, and make a lot more tactical sense given what Dany shows up with at KL. Arya taking off after just shivving the KL would make more sense to me as well, Jon staying in the North with what's left of his brothers and the wildlings, the North earning a peaceful exit from the Sev….er Six Kingdoms due to their sacrifice. The Unsullied and Dothraki are more isolated, their leaving would make more sense as well as they could see that the South could trap them in the North rather than apparently be totally depopulated. Bran's master plan to take out the NK would be more widely witnessed by Southern lords and would make his kingship more likely.
Rentahamster
Rodent Whores
Jaxx_377
Neo Member
The Ironborn would still pitch a fit
As I said before I think when you look at the basic bullet points they have a good ending there but the build up and pay off was just missing.
After 70+ episodes that's disappointing.
I feel like if the writers are going to send Jon back to the Night's Watch then you should not have had them defeat the Night King but rather should have had them repel and severely weaken him. Hence Jon is needed to defend against his potential return.
If you are going to have Bran as king at the end then pad out the three eyed raven stuff and allow it to take center stage for a decent chunk of your final season.
The conclusions are perfectly fine in theory but in practice the whole season has just felt like "let's just get this over with as quickly as possible and move on".
Ultimately I think people will look back and see that the ending was rushed through extremely quickly and lacked any real weight as a result.
After 70+ episodes that's disappointing.
I feel like if the writers are going to send Jon back to the Night's Watch then you should not have had them defeat the Night King but rather should have had them repel and severely weaken him. Hence Jon is needed to defend against his potential return.
If you are going to have Bran as king at the end then pad out the three eyed raven stuff and allow it to take center stage for a decent chunk of your final season.
The conclusions are perfectly fine in theory but in practice the whole season has just felt like "let's just get this over with as quickly as possible and move on".
Ultimately I think people will look back and see that the ending was rushed through extremely quickly and lacked any real weight as a result.
AV
We ain't outta here in ten minutes, we won't need no rocket to fly through space
Nope. They also know that all the white walkers are dead, so there's not really anything to protect from. And hell, from the looks of things, the plan was to let Jon go anyway and just not tell the unsullied, since no-one at the wall stops him. Why not just wait until they've gone away on their boats and let him live where he wants?
And why are the wildlings going back beyond the wall when all they wanted was to come south away from the harsh wilds? Didn't they just help Sansa hold Winterfell against the dead? Wouldn't she be alright letting them have a bit of land to live on? Am I missing something?
Last edited:
Airbus Jr
Banned
I bet nobody cares about jon anymore
He can forget about his vows not to have children
He said hes going back to castle black but we all saw he continue to march north
He can fuck some wildlings, have kids and built his own house...guys endured so much burden and fought so many war...time for him to relax and enjoy life..
Last edited:
KeepThemEyesOpen
Member
But you are making assumptions. The writers on the show already have made creative liberty's with the source material in the past and that doesn't mean it's because they don't like what they got to work with. There's been lots of different books where they have been altered, for better or worse, to serve the medium it's being adapted too. This is no different.nonono..my friend the one making assumptions is you...
If they re going to film something based on a book...only to betrayed its own source..because they change their mind dont like how the book story goes...than whats the fuckin point of doing it?( making ashow based on a book)
Romulus
Member
Right. At least then from my limited perspective its overwhelmly negative.
KeepThemEyesOpen
Member
Jon is a stubbornly honorable person and tries to never compromise. He doesn't want the throne to begin with and he just killed his Queen and his lover. It would be out of his character to take the Throne himself after betraying Dany.
Last edited:
AV
We ain't outta here in ten minutes, we won't need no rocket to fly through space
So did Jaime and Cersei just get really unlucky with that brick fall? And did Dany not think to have anyone look for Cersei's corpse to confirm the kill before she started listing off the next slaughtering grounds..? Looks like the majority of the keep is pretty intact.
RedVIper
Banned
Rentahamster
Rodent Whores
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/helen-sloan-hbo-6-1-2000-166a336cf37e46f09f9227cc75bedd5d.jpg)
Emilia Clarke on the 'Game of Thrones' finale's shock twist: 'I stand by Daenerys'
Exclusive interview: Emilia Clarke and Kit Harington discuss events in the final episode of Game of Thrones (spoilers)
Ahahahahaha
Kit trying to rationalize these weird ass rushed character arcs by making the same logical error many others are willingly and unwillingly doing - selectively applying either 21st century or medeival standards of morality when it suite their argument and ignoring it when it doesn't.
Malakhov
Banned
Yep very well done and a great ending to a great season.
In pretty much all shows i watched except 6 feet under and breaking bad, none succeeded to finish such a great show that well.
eot
Banned
Kin, not kingQueenslayer. Ban this sexist fool.
Virex
Banned
He misspelled Twin Peaks
KeepThemEyesOpen
Member
It's possible he really does think it's fine the way it was written and directed but that's just his opinion. I believe there are some people who are not bothered by how rush it is and don't care for the details while us for example want those details and want these climaxes to buildup organically instead of events just happening for the sake of happening. This isn't a criticism towards them though, everybody has different taste. Just an observation.Emilia Clarke on the 'Game of Thrones' finale's shock twist: 'I stand by Daenerys'
Exclusive interview: Emilia Clarke and Kit Harington discuss events in the final episode of Game of Thrones (spoilers)ew.com
Ahahahahaha
Kit trying to rationalize these weird ass rushed character arcs by making the same logical error many others are willingly and unwillingly doing - selectively applying either 21st century or medeival standards of morality when it suite their argument and ignoring it when it doesn't.
Rentahamster
Rodent Whores
It also would have been nice if Bran the human tree encyclopedia king could have told us how The Wall got built.
Rentahamster
Rodent Whores
KeepThemEyesOpen
Member
Yea I have seen that video before, what he said in that article and what he said in the video is contradicting so we don't really know what's his honest opinion.
ParanoidRED
Banned
It was honestly decent, nothing more nor short of what i was expecting from the ending after a super mediocre season
Couple of moments that made me shade my head super hard tho
Anyway, i can finally start reading the books, super curious tbh
Couple of moments that made me shade my head super hard tho
Anyway, i can finally start reading the books, super curious tbh
Malakhov
Banned
Good luck, i tried to while watching the show but couldnt get into them. I cant get into something that ive already watched or read most of the times though.
Last edited:
Xisiqomelir
Member
_Starscream_
Member
Virex
Banned
my fucking sides
Fbh
Gold Member
Imagine living in high garden and one of the first things the new king does is appoint some drunk mercenary as your new leader because his hand promised it to him (when he was still working as the hand for the genocidal queen).
It sure would inspire a lot of confidence in this new king
It sure would inspire a lot of confidence in this new king
Musky_Cheese
Banned
Yes belonging to House Manderly.
This is not the boat Jon took when leaving White Harbor going to Dragonstone. So ok. The Stark branded boat was just made. ok fine.
Why is it not crewed by House Stark... or Northmen at all? She is the only crew member that was carrying a weapon. The ship has no weapons.
So Arya has a Stark Branded Boat crewed by exactly how Jack Sparrow crewed his stolen ship in the first pirates movie, with no means to defend themselves. Should have just teamed up with the Greyjoys, seeing as how they ain't got shit to do now and this mission is right up their alley.
Or just ask Bran. Seeing as he is Google in a wheel chair.
Lionel Richie
Member
Just in case you're being serious, explain to me: why didn't the unsullied and the dothraki avenge her Christ-like queen?
Similar threads
- Locked