Ok So I tried the Fatboy putty today, and it was ok. Didn't do anything at all with my dry hair, but after I sprayed a bit of water it worked much better but left a shine. Pretty thick and really hard to wash out. Had to use a lot as it just wasn't doing anything. Gonna try it out a few more times and see If I can master it.
Now the Gatsby Green was a different story. I love this stuff! Really creamy and easy to apply. It actually added a lot of texture to my hair. Also surprisingly had a really good hold! It gave a little bit of shine which isn't too bad. Smells so damn good too. This stuff is legit and cost half the price of fatboy putty. Now I'm just waiting for the grey matte to come in so I can try. I have a feeling that's gonna be the one for me, if not then I'm sticking with the green.