I enjoyed When Evil Lurks (I liked his previous movie Terrified better). Talk to Me was the best horror movie of 2023 by far.
90's I thought was always pretty weak. But some stand outs like From Dusk til Dawn, Scream 1, Event Horizon, Demon Knight (so fun), to name a few.
Early 2000's though, American Psycho, 28 Days Later, REC, House of 1k Corpses, Planet Terror, Trick R Treat, Drag Me To Hell, The Hills Have Eyes (remake), High Tension, Inside (french movie), The Descent to name a few as well. (I keep coming across some really solid ones while looking around making this post)
My favorite horror movies that I can watch anytime though?
Planet Terror, Evil Dead 2013, original Texas Chainsaw Massacre, The Thing, Tucker and Dale, plenty others that I can watch again and have no gripes.