Support NeoGAF

[TeTr1C]

It was a hard choice today at Gamestop, NCAA or Madden. I went with NCAA since I have too many NFL licensed games. ESPN 2K5 (RIP), Madden 05, and NFL Fever 2002 :lol .


Then as I went to pay for it, like always, I get bombarded with preorder questions. I did actually renew my GI subscription and reserve Burnout Revenge though. I could tell he kept wanting me to put more money down on Burnout...it was getting ridiculous.




Anyways, yeah, please answer the thread title.

 

[Shawnwhann]

The answer is simple, it doesn't. Playmakers cheese the game along with the crappy homefield advantage implementation.

 

[dskillzhtown]

I have both games. I would say Madden is better, but takes a lil getting used to. I do feel like NCAA is getting closer and closer to catching that "Anything can happen" feel of the college game. That game seems more geared towards people in dorms drunk off their ass and just wanting to have some fun with the amount of BIG plays that happen in that game. Madden on the other hand has alot less room for error and some might say that the fun factor decreased this year.

I prefer the pro game to the college game in real-life so that might have something to do with my preference of the NFL game over the college one. But I think both are good games.