Soul Calibur on the DC IS overrated. It only got the so much praise because of the graphics, which really were the first to represent how amazing "next-gen" visuals could be at the time. It was also the first 3D fighter to have visuals far beyond the arcade version. And while SC is a great game, the graphics are what sold it to a lot of people. I didn't hear a word about SC2's game play when it was released; it was just "The game looks like SC1!!!!1111." Right.