White Man said:
On iPhone: "Why should I pay 600 bucks for a glorified. . .wait, there's nothing glorified about this? Nice voicemail, yeah, but who lets voicemail accumulate to the point where it needs organization?"
At least Wii has a spiffy controller.
It's a glorified smartphone with borked features, by your own admission due to lack of 3G, and you got a less expensive product WITH this function. Same situation.
White Man said:
The Zune's interface is slug-like compared to the iPod, and when you use the battery-killing wifi to trade tracks, the person recieving the track can only play it 3 times. The software for syncing is also, well, not as agood as iTunes. The initial setup is (this is a crapshoot) often more difficult than iTunes. Also, the Zune store is like a sad joke compared to iTunes. No videos to buy at all.
I can't be quite as definitive on Zune because, well. . .I put it back in the box. I tested it for a week, but my large music collection is more suited to my 5.5 iPod.
To use your little trick up there, on iPhone compared to, as an example, your 8525:
The 8525's interface isn't as intuitive compared to the iPhone, and when you use 3rd-party apps on it, you occasionally run the risk of borking the phone. The software for syncing is also, well, not as good as iTunes. The initial setup of software like ActiveSync or something such as The Missing Sync for a Mac to sync is (this is a crapshoot) often more difficult than iTunes. Also, the 8525 gives me no option to play my iTunes Store purchases, and Media Player 10 Mobile just isn't as solid. It also simply doesn't have the same kind of storage capacity to use as a full-fledged multimedia device, which iPhone does and may be enough capacity to decrease my necessity for an equally-expensive iPod.
Now, given that whole thing there, after the 2-year contract fee AND a mail-in rebate on the 8525, the difference between phone pricing is $200. To gain some of the value of the "substandard" iPhone (its storage capacity) and keep them as even-featured as possible, you'd need to buy some sort of SD card for the 8525, which would set you back an additional $50 or more just to get the 4GB available in the basic iPhone model. So now, we have a price difference of about $100-150... but for some, the difference simply may not be that wide of a gap and the lack of 3G might not be a big issue to them, just like features beyond the basics doesn't seem to dissuade people from buying an iPod, and just like inferior graphics and dearth of games doesn't seem to stop Wii from selling like crazy.
(and this is when I compare it to your 8525, it was even MORE brutal when I compared it to something like the top-of-the-line CrackBerry)
Please tell me you see what I'm getting at here. Just because you don't see the value in iPhone doesn't make it substandard for lacking 3G, just like lacking features don't hurt these other products lacking features compared to competing products, some of which are cheaper. It's nothing but
perceived value, not technology that you have deemed necessary for it to be of equal value in the market.