no to that tooIs Kill Bill the greatest movie of all time?
And one of the best at that!Newbie said:I wouldn't even call Kill Bill an action film to be honest. Terminator 2 is what i'd consider an action film
karasu said:FUCK no. It has some of the best visuals, but as a film it's incredibly flawed. Part two ownz it, and don't give me that crap about it being one movie, because it wasn't. The best action movie ever made is Police Story. ~Fin
Of course it was, it's about the only way to justify Vol. 2 being so stretched out and padded. Vol. 1 just about stood on its own, although they were plenty of places where the supposedly uncutable film could have done with some editing. Kill Bill could have been an absolutely amazing 2 and a half hour film. Instead it was 4 hours that is as likely to have you yawning as being gripped with excitement.
ManDudeChild said:If by "greatest action movie" you mean steaming pile of hackneyed crap then yes, Kill Bill IS the "greatest action movie.
Society said:No.
Watch more action movies.
I agree with you. And the best action seen in the movie (the fight between the Bride and the one eyed girl) was great not because of the choreography (almost non-existant) and not because of the camera work but instead because of the intensity of the actors and the sound editing.Teddman said:You guys are just like all the geeks in college back when Pulp Fiction came out, froathing at the mouth about how Tarantino the best director of all time, saying that Pulp Fiction and Reservoir Dogs were in the top ten movies of all time, etc.
It's happening again.
Kill Bill's no slouch, but the action is nowhere near the all-time greats. Flicks with either bigger budget special efx setpieces or more intricate and original choreography have it beat by a mile. It's still a great movie, but get real.
This man is correct.ManDudeChild said:If by "greatest action movie" you mean steaming pile of hackneyed crap then yes, Kill Bill IS the "greatest action movie.
YOU SIR, ARE AN IDIOT!Mrbob said:Yes.
Discuss.
Mr Gump said:This man is correct.
No. Terminator 2 is the greatest action movie of all time. This isn't up for discussion.Mrbob said:Is Kill Bill the greatest action movie of all time?
Lyte Edge said:So my question is, is the House Of Blue Leaves scene the only scene that got censored like this, or are there more scenes with extra footage?
Teddman said:You guys are just like all the geeks in college back when Pulp Fiction came out, froathing at the mouth about how Tarantino the best director of all time, saying that Pulp Fiction and Reservoir Dogs were in the top ten movies of all time, etc.
It's happening again.
Kill Bill's no slouch, but the action is nowhere near the all-time greats. Flicks with either bigger budget special efx setpieces or more intricate and original choreography have it beat by a mile. It's still a great movie, but get real.
Not in general. But does it help for an action film? Yes. Especially you are talking about the GREATEST ACTION MOVIE OF ALL TIME.Mrbob said:So more money = better film ???
Sure, the choreography is great. But let's make this clear: You think Kill Bill has the best choreography of all time?Don't give me the choreography, either. It's brilliant in Kill Bill. Tarantino hired on Wu Ping (however you spell it), the man behind the choreography in the Matrix (Dunno if he was with them for reloaded and crapalutions), as a consultant with his action scenes. There is hardly a repetitive scene in any of the fights. Especially the House of Blue Leaves. And that is amazing considering how long it is. But that's fine, if you want to ignore brilliance in the favor of high budget crap thats your opinion.