• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Jury duty

DKehoe

Gold Member
I’ve had to go along about four times now and never been picked. The last three years, almost to the exact same day in November, I’ve had to go along for it.

I dunno how it is where you are but here they invite way more people than they need so you’re more likely to not get picked than to be picked. It’s a pretty dull process waiting around to find out if you have been picked or not so take a book.
 

MudoSkills

Volcano High Alumnus (Cum Laude)
19 weeks, must be a hell of a case.

Like nush said, admitting to being a racist will get you kicked.
 

keraj37

Contacted PSN to add his card back to his account
Look at the judge with this smile for a couple of minutes - discharged of the duty the same day guaranteed
743009.jpg


But if you stay I am really worried about impact you can have for justice system in Australia :(
 

West Texas CEO

GAF's Nicest Lunch Thief and Nosiest Dildo Archeologist
Let me share one of my jury duty experiences..

I was on a wacky case. A man and woman were driving to a motel so they could engage in carnal relations. They couldn't wait, so pulled into a parking lot at a 7-11 and went at it. The clerk called the police, and when they came both the man and woman appeared very drunk. Because there were no bottles in the car, it was obvious that they had driven while drunk.

The man took a breath test and failed, but once at the station, the woman claimed that she had been driving. At that point, several hours later, she passed a breath test.

One funny aspect was that the woman came dressed like a Victorian school teacher, in order to show she was not the drunken slut the case was portraying her as. Unfortunately, the jury all felt the case could not be made against them given the evidence, even though it was pretty obvious that they were driving drunk.

The jury experience was irritating. One woman kept saying how the man was sneezing when questioned, and so probably had allergies, and that allergy medicine can make you appear drunk even when you aren't. We kept having to explain that the fact he was drunk was not a point of contention - he failed the breath test and admitted to drinking. But she kept coming back to it, like she was thought she was Sherlock Holmes or something with her keen inferences. Most of the people couldn't make a logical argument to save their life.

The defense lawyer did all these things during the selection to, I guess, hypnotize us into thinking the defendant was innocent. He asked each person to say, "I presume the defendant is innocent" as if hearing that over and over would implant that into our brains.
 

Maiden Voyage

Gold™ Member
I've been selected on call for the past few years. One advantage of living in a low population, low crime area is that they never call you in.
 

diffusionx

Gold Member
I have no idea how it works in literal kangaroo courts, but I went and sat in a room for 6 hours then they told me to go home.
 

DKehoe

Gold Member
I should have mentioned this in my earlier post. On one of the previous times I was waiting to see if I would be selected the person who was on trial showed up to court wearing a white T-shirt that had “I AM AWESOME” written on it in bold black lettering. They plead guilty
 
If you don’t want to do it then just put on the form you are going through a bit of depression or anxiety. Anything mental health related and they will exempt you without hesitation.
 

420bits

Member
I would be all over that shit if it was 19 weeks, must be some really fucked up shit and you get the chance to decide the future.

Sadly, in Sweden we don't have this because it would be useless to have a jury when we don't really punish people who commit crime.
 

V4skunk

Banned
I would be all over that shit if it was 19 weeks, must be some really fucked up shit and you get the chance to decide the future.

Sadly, in Sweden we don't have this because it would be useless to have a jury when we don't really punish people who commit crime.
Sweden is lost. Will fall to Islam and communism.
Your country used to be considered the greatest place to live on the planet. Not so much any more.......
 

ManaByte

Gold Member
Just get out of it by telling them you're a racist. You're an aussie, so it's probably true anyway.

That doesn't work anymore. People used to try the Homer Simpson thing by saying they were prejudice against all races, but that now just gets you mandatory sensitivity training on top of jury duty.
 
I was called in a few years ago. The lady was questioning all of us (potential jurors) but her theatrics and over the top questioning when aimed at me made me chuckle, and I was quickly dismissed. I really didn't want to be dismissed, I wanted to hear someones dirt and judge them.
 

ManaByte

Gold Member
I was called in a few years ago. The lady was questioning all of us (potential jurors) but her theatrics and over the top questioning when aimed at me made me chuckle, and I was quickly dismissed. I really didn't want to be dismissed, I wanted to hear someones dirt and judge them.

Nah I didn't want to be on a jury. I was once almost seated for this case about some child molester who was trying to get released early and in the questioning by the judge of potential jurors I looked at the guy and asked why we couldn't just put an electric chair in here and get it over with.
 
I've gone a few times, was only selected once to be on a jury. It was a boring dispute about a car company's warranty and whether or not a certain item was covered under it. Basically 5 years after buying the car, right after the warranty expired, they wanted to return it because they had come to understand something was wrong with it. The car company brought an expert in to testify that actually, the car was designed to do the specific thing they were complaining about. The trial took 3 days. It was an interesting experience.


I will take jury duty if I can get it. Yeah it's boring but so is work, and you learn stuff. It's an interesting experience that makes one of your weeks slightly more interesting.
 

Sorcerer

Member
I don't understand why the Judge can't handle the process. Things would move along much faster. The Judge understands the law inside and out. He also is making $200,000 a year and he is there all day everyday. It seems like such a burden to choose twelve people, and then go through the hassle of babying them because their understanding of the law is limited in scope compared to judges and lawyers.

Next time I have to go in for Jury duty, I should bring this up, should get me kicked out (but not sent home unfortunately).
 
Last edited:
I don't understand why the Judge can't handle the process. Things would move along much faster. The Judge understands the law inside and out. He also is making $200,000 a year and he is there all day everyday. It seems like such a burden to choose twelve people, and then go through the hassle of babying them because their understanding of the law is limited in scope compared to judges and lawyers.

Next time I have to go in for Jury duty, I should bring this up, should get me kicked out (but not sent home unfortunately).

You can ask for a judge to decide the case. I'm no lawyer so I don't know all of the details but people do ask judges to decide cases based on the law and a summary of events.


The whole jury thing is a matter of fairness and legitamacy.


Edit: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Summary_judgment
 
Last edited:

notseqi

Member
rant against lawyers in your interview

I don't understand why the Judge can't handle the process. Things would move along much faster. The Judge understands the law inside and out. He also is making $200,000 a year and he is there all day everyday. It seems like such a burden to choose twelve people, and then go through the hassle of babying them because their understanding of the law is limited in scope compared to judges and lawyers.
Jury of your peers, y'know. It's the law.
 
S

SLoWMoTIoN

Unconfirmed Member
Been to jd 5 times. I usually bring a book,manga or portable when they are picking people out. So I never get picked :).
 

zeorhymer

Member
Let me share one of my jury duty experiences..

<snip>

The jury experience was irritating. One woman kept saying how the man was sneezing when questioned, and so probably had allergies, and that allergy medicine can make you appear drunk even when you aren't. We kept having to explain that the fact he was drunk was not a point of contention - he failed the breath test and admitted to drinking. But she kept coming back to it, like she was thought she was Sherlock Holmes or something with her keen inferences. Most of the people couldn't make a logical argument to save their life.

The defense lawyer did all these things during the selection to, I guess, hypnotize us into thinking the defendant was innocent. He asked each person to say, "I presume the defendant is innocent" as if hearing that over and over would implant that into our brains.
Na. That's the nature of the jury selection. Attorneys have no incentive to get a fair juror and need to stack the deck in their favor. I remember being drilled on by both sides about circumstantial evidence etc etc. Also, the defense lawyer has to stay that because presumption of innocence often gets forgotten. Sometimes they get jurors give the guilty look at a guy who is dressed like a thug or what have you.
 
Yes, I served as a juror for a case 2 summers ago. I went Monday - Friday for about 2 weeks. The case was quite interesting and it was cool to see how the court system worked. The food we got was also pretty good.

If you want to avoid being selected, just say something that makes you look like a bad candidate (you distrust cops in a case on poultice brutality, for example).
 

ManaByte

Gold Member
I don't understand why the Judge can't handle the process. Things would move along much faster. The Judge understands the law inside and out. He also is making $200,000 a year and he is there all day everyday. It seems like such a burden to choose twelve people, and then go through the hassle of babying them because their understanding of the law is limited in scope compared to judges and lawyers.

Next time I have to go in for Jury duty, I should bring this up, should get me kicked out (but not sent home unfortunately).

 

Hari Seldon

Member
Was a juror on a double murder trial. It was only like 6 days and the days were short, like 5-6 hours. The judge was squeezing cases in before and after us. It was an interesting experience, but 19 weeks is fucked.
 

BadBurger

Many “Whelps”! Handle It!
When they're doing jury selection think of any reason you can to disqualify yourself given the case, plaintiff, and or defendant. The only time I had jury duty I was able to get off. It was a medical malpractice lawsuit. I happened to be doing contract work for the healthcare network the doctor practiced at. I was gone quick.
 

Cunth

Fingerlickin' Good!
So i went to this shit today. Sat in a room for 2 hours watching youtube on my phone and then a guy comes out and says that the judge said the trial isnt going ahead this week so we are free to go. Then when I was leaving they asked me 'do you wish to serve on the jury when the trial begins next week?' and i was like, hells naw LOL
 
Top Bottom