Score: 9
"Other than the control scheme, [the GC version is] practically identical to its PS2 counterpart. Representing a complete revision of the basics of game production, this intense title bears the stamp of its creators all over it, from the art, sound, word usage and controller button layout. Even so, there are not areas of the game that reflect the creators' pushing their own agenda, and the title stands tall as a complete piece of high-quality entertainment."
Score: 9
"[The title is] more accessible than it appears. Although the basic controls and content of the actual game doesn't differ from its PS2 counterpart, the GC version has a slight edge due to faster loading times and button placement that allows for easier control. The nature of progression through the game is linear, but the player will not sense this thanks to a superb puzzle-solving element involving personality switching."
Score: 8
"Although it appears difficult at first glance, players will find it to be relatively straightforward and easy to grasp once they try it. Plus points go to the surreal laughs spread throughout the game, which fit the title's atmosphere nicely. The basic content [of the GC version] is the same as its PS2 counterpart; however, taking into consideration factors such as load times and ease of control, the GC version is easier to play as a whole."
Score: 10
"While the system inherent in the usage of characters and the shooting sequences is standard, the game effectively pulling you into its world makes it a joy to play. Dialog sequences and cut scenes full of surreal humor add quality flavor to the title. When load times and slight differences in control and appearance are taken into consideration, it might be better to go with this version."
The perception of the mag's reviews by US fans is slowly moving from blind trust to a more sensible realistic view, and you probably saw a lot of that happen during the Nintendogs mess.
