• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Laserdisc 2 vs Laserdisc 3

Heian-kyo said:
HD video is a premium over DVD as far as I'm concerned, and it has been created to co-exist with DVD for quite some time.

To say you want said premium, but want to skimp on the price, is the same as buying a Mustang instead of an Aston Martin or a TVR. IMO, it defeats the entire fucking purpose.



Whaaaaa....?
 
gofreak said:
No word yet. Maybe tomorrow at the BDA presentation. Might be down to whether the HD-DVD camp announce pricing today. A premium over DVD is a given, of course.

I'm hoping for a $35 MRSP, with $40 being the top limit. That gives them their nice $10-15 premium over dvds, while still being fairly affordable if you can pick up a film at Best Buy or Dvdplanet for <$30.
 
monkeymagic said:
With that said, it's clear that all the HD-DVD/Blu-Ray damage control in this thread is coming from XBox fans. Anyone that is interested in technology and/or home entertainment will be greatly looking forward to these new formats.

Funny, I was going to say all this focus on the benefits of Blue-Ray damage control was coming from Sony fans.

Seriously, the Console Wars have no place in this thread. This is about High End Tech, not gaming. I could go on and on about how it's XBL that makes the 360 such a rewarding and valuable experience but that's just rot. This is about the TV and Video Player that your rich friend's dad is going to get and that he'll lord over you until you graduate and go to a small Liberal Arts school in New England and take up Stick Juggling.
 
Deg said:
$50 for Blu Ray movies. I think. Or is that blank disks??

Blanks.

On pricing, it doesn't look like we'll be getting details at CES, but soon:

Sony did not disclose the discs' retail price, which Feingold says will be announced in the next couple of weeks. He says that the discs will be priced at a premium over existing DVDs, but that they won't be a lot more expensive.

"I think people will be happy," he says of the pricing.

http://www.pcworld.com/news/article/0,aid,124194,00.asp
 
A blank Panasonic 50GB recordable BD-RE was introduced in Japan last year for ~50 USD...perhaps this is what you are thinking of??

Of course, Blu-ray ROM will be cheaper than this....
 
i hope there'll be some way to hear the lossless audio on a standard 5.1 receiver...i expect a lot of those audio tracks to be 7.1, but maybe some players will be able to mix them down to 5.1 through the discrete outputs. well, it's not as if dts or dd sound bad anyway.
 
golem said:
Pioneer's Blu Ray recorder pc drive

http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=172

$995, single layer 25gb

I thought the more interesting part of that article was that their first player won't support HD resolution over analog yet - with perhaps the suggestion that later, "consumer-level" models might. Seems to suggest further that HD over digital-outs may not be a requirement for movie playback (although I guess it could still be a requirement for that, but not your own blu-ray recorded content for example).

dorio said:
Actually, I don't see anywhere there that confirms 1080p movie playback.

Well, it doesn't confirm any movie playback whatsoever if you want to get picky like that ! :p The hardware is capable of it, so unless Sony goes out of their way to limit it, there's no reason why it won't.
 
gofreak said:
Well, it doesn't confirm any movie playback whatsoever if you want to get picky like that ! :p The hardware is capable of it, so unless Sony goes out of their way to limit it, there's no reason why it won't.
Sorry, I'm not trying to be nitpicky. I'm just trying to figure out what enticement they will give consumers to buy an expensive standalone player with less features and if limiting ps3 playback to 720p will be one of them.
 
krypt0nian said:
Not sure about a live feed, but www.majornelson.com will have a podcast of it up about an hour afterwards.

Plus he just posted a brand new pre-CES Peter Moore interview at his site.

click bill gates pic on first post. it says feed starts at 6:30 pst and has links for 3 speeds
 
dorio said:
Sorry, I'm not trying to be nitpicky. I'm just trying to figure out what enticement they will give consumers to buy an expensive standalone player with less features

There is a (small) market out there that simply does not care about the extra functionality PS3 will offer as a games machine, but simply the extra functionality offered for movies by a player like the Pioneer etc. It's still like asking how someone can ask for x amount for one product in a particular line and ask for much less for another that fundamentally does the same thing, but it happens all the time. There's also the fact that for a (short) time, these will be the only players available. These prices are the MSRPs for launch, not necessarily for a post-PS3 world (although to be honest i expect their prices will remain largely unchanged, but will be joined by other cheaper models). The ultra high end will eat them up without thinking too much about the price.
 
Here's a pic of the 1080p Pioneer Elite plasma.

pro-fhd1.jpg


CES is turning into Attack of the 50-inch TVs. Pioneer claims its new $10,000 PRO-FHD1 display, positioned as a companion to the company's Blu-ray player, has pixels 35% smaller than previous models. It's so new we couldn't get any decent press photos, but we snapped this shot at their press conference. Specs: 1920 x 1080 progressive, built-in upconversion and HDMI.

http://ces.engadget.com/2006/01/04/pioneer-50-inch-1080p-plasma-screen-due-in-june/

Panasonic have a cheaper 50" 1080p plasma i think.
 
I'm looking at buying a 50" HDTV myself in 2006. Can't wait to hear about all the announcements over the next couple days.
 
gofreak said:
There is a (small) market out there that simply does not care about the extra functionality PS3 will offer as a games machine, but simply the extra functionality offered for movies by a player like the Pioneer etc. It's still like asking how someone can ask for x amount for one product in a particular line and ask for much less for another that fundamentally does the same thing, but it happens all the time. There's also the fact that for a (short) time, these will be the only players available. These prices are the MSRPs for launch, not necessarily for a post-PS3 world (although to be honest i expect their prices will remain largely unchanged, but will be joined by other cheaper models). The ultra high end will eat them up without thinking too much about the price.
But the ps3 is not just offering equivalent functionality it's offering much better functionality ie. 1080p vs. 1080i then the $1000 players. We'll see if consumers are that snobbish about having a standalone player to buy a device with less features at twice the price.
 
Philips player:

phil2.jpg


http://ces.engadget.com/2006/01/04/philips-keynote-address-the-liveblog/

No more details yet..

dorio said:
But the ps3 is not just offering equivalent functionality it's offering much better functionality ie. 1080p vs. 1080i then the $1000 players. We'll see if consumers are that snobbish about having a standalone player to buy a device with less features at twice the price.

Resolution aside, I don't know if the functionality is equal or better..(simply don't know enough about the Samsung or all the movie functionality in PS3).

Again, if what you think will happen, happens, it simply means the prices will come down faster. But there will always be a high end, regardless, that's my point. There'll always be $1000+ players (just as there are still $1000+ dvd players). Samsung are out to make a buck in that category because they know lots of the first adopters won't mind paying for that (and note that Samsung is aiming to be the first player in the US). Ditto for the others, they'll all want to cream some profits off that segment with more expensive drives.
 
krypt0nian said:
Not sure about a live feed, but www.majornelson.com will have a podcast of it up about an hour afterwards.

Plus he just posted a brand new pre-CES Peter Moore interview at his site.
says (moore) is gonna talk about HD, 99 nights, Live, Marketplace at the keynote
 
Panasonic has announced pricing for their writable/rewritable Blu-ray discs, to be introduced this Spring:

Model Number Specification SRP*

LM-BE50DE Rewritable, 50GB, Single-Sided, Dual Layer $59.99

LM-BE25DE Rewritable, 25GB, Single-Sided, Single Layer $24.99

LM-BR50DE Write once, 50GB, Single-Sided, Dual Layer $42.99

LM-BR25DE Write once, 25GB, Single-Sided, Single Layer $17.99

http://www.prnewswire.com/cgi-bin/stories.pl?ACCT=104&STORY=/www/story/01-04-2006/0004242836&EDATE=

About $1 a gigabyte, then.
 
Interestingly, both players -- and all forthcoming HD-DVD players -- will only output high-definition resolutions via copy-protected HDMI outputs, so people whose HDTVs don't have HDMI or DVI/HDCP inputs won't be able to enjoy the improved image quality of HD-DVD. According to Pioneer and Philips, the competing Blu-ray players may still enable high-def output via analog outputs, but we're sceptical about that. If Blu-ray did allow HD resolutions via analog, it would have one more major advantage over the less expensive HD-DVD players.


Lets wait and see. But Blu Ray clearly seems more mature and has much more content already. Analog output might be abit too much :P
 
I'm wondering now... I think it's entirely realistic that Sony will not have the PS3 ship with BD-ROM playback out of the box...and, instead, sell you an optional (and very expensive) dongle for that usage, much like the XBOX with the DVD remote.
 
gofreak said:
Panasonic has announced pricing for their writable/rewritable Blu-ray discs, to be introduced this Spring:

Model Number Specification SRP*

LM-BE50DE Rewritable, 50GB, Single-Sided, Dual Layer $59.99

LM-BE25DE Rewritable, 25GB, Single-Sided, Single Layer $24.99

LM-BR50DE Write once, 50GB, Single-Sided, Dual Layer $42.99

LM-BR25DE Write once, 25GB, Single-Sided, Single Layer $17.99

http://www.prnewswire.com/cgi-bin/stories.pl?ACCT=104&STORY=/www/story/01-04-2006/0004242836&EDATE=

About $1 a gigabyte, then.
Yup...I'll be getting a BD writer about the time I can pick up a 50pack for $30 on Pricegrabber. :lol Those prices are off the hook. Early adopters should be renamed guinea pigs. PEACE.
 
MightyHedgehog said:
I'm wondering now... I think it's entirely realistic that Sony will not have the PS3 ship with BD-ROM playback out of the box...and, instead, sell you an optional (and very expensive) dongle for that usage, much like the XBOX with the DVD remote.

Why would Sony do that?
 
MightyHedgehog said:
I'm wondering now... I think it's entirely realistic that Sony will not have the PS3 ship with BD-ROM playback out of the box...and, instead, sell you an optional (and very expensive) dongle for that usage, much like the XBOX with the DVD remote.

hmmm... how is that realistic? Sounds absurd to me?
 
SolidSnakex said:
It's brilliant marketing dont you think? Hype up the feature and right before launch..Just kidding ya, you've gotta buy this other thing if you want playback.

Ahhh, I see the logic in that. I think it would be a nice kick in the balls though. The PS3 better allow Blu Ray playback with the regular controller.
 
BlueTsunami said:
Ahhh, I see the logic in that. I think it would be a nice kick in the balls though. The PS3 better allow Blu Ray playback with the regular controller.

SSX was just being sarcastic
 
BlueTsunami said:
Ahhh, I see the logic in that. I think it would be a nice kick in the balls though. The PS3 better allow Blu Ray playback with the regular controller.

I was being sarcastic, there's no logic to that other than pissing people off.
 
BlueTsunami said:
Why would Sony do that?
Cost. PS3 is already a hell of an expensive piece of hardware as it is. I understand uncutting dedicated players by a margin, but I find it highly unrealistic to believe you'll be able to play BD-ROM movies on a $399 or less console coming out close to the same time as dedicated players starting at around 1k. Unless there's a significant difference in capabilities, anyway...
 
MightyHedgehog said:
Cost. PS3 is already a hell of an expensive piece of hardware as it is. I understand uncutting dedicated players by a margin, but I find it highly unrealistic to believe you'll be able to play BD-ROM movies on a $399 or less console coming out close to the same time as dedicated players starting at around 1k. Unless there's a significant difference in capabilities, anyway...


I just had a year 2000 deja vu. The *very same* things were said about the PS2 in regards to its capabilities as a DVD-Video player before it launched.
 
SolidSnakex said:
I was being sarcastic, there's no logic to that other than pissing people off.

My sarcasm meter is off today

;_;

But yeah, thats why I was initially surprised at Hedgehogs comment
 
TTP said:
I just had a year 2000 deja vu. The *very same* things were said about the PS2 in regards to its capabilities as a DVD-Video player before it launched.

Except that DVD players had been around for almost four years prior to the PS2 launch. And there were some out on the market that cost as little as $400 at the time of PS2's release. I'm not sure about the whole dongle idea, but it seems very realistic to me. That difference in cost and the fact that we'll supposedly see PS3 debut close to the time of those ~1k priced players gives me that idea.
 
dorio said:
Sorry, I'm not trying to be nitpicky. I'm just trying to figure out what enticement they will give consumers to buy an expensive standalone player with less features and if limiting ps3 playback to 720p will be one of them.


Since certain overall details of PS3 are vague, some of the questions you are asking cant be answered yet........if PS3 dosesn't support 1080p BRD movies, then it would be because SCEI is going out of their way to disable that functionality because RSX can output 1080p X2 via HDMI...

Also, many audio/video early adopters wouldn't be caught DEAD with a *videogame console* as their main player.....this trend was true of CD and DVD powered consoles vs. stand alone CD and DVD players when they were introduced and it will most likely continue true when BRD and HD-DVD are superceded by some other delivery system in the future.....many early adopters just perfer high end products period....not to mention owning high-gloss piano black Pioneer Elite products just makes you feel all warm and fuzzy inside....trust me, I know :D

It seems to me this concept of consumer thinking escapes you......this is no crime and being you post on a videogame forum, it is not surprising either.....

To drive the point home, I just took delivery of a 2006 Corvette Z06($73K)....this is a car that offers ~90% the performance of a Porsche Carrera GT(about 1/2 a million$), but if I could afford a CGT, I would not give the Z a second glance, BeeLee DAT!



*DISCLAIMER*


The above post is based on the assumption you are *not* asking loaded/flamebait questions to stir up shit in this thread :)
 
Top Bottom