Thanks for the list. I own a lot of these games. Probably going to buy both Eschalon games.
Would really appreciate some impressions on Saria and Mosby's Confederacy if anyone's got 'em.
GAMES YOU SHOULD BUY
Buy Space Giraffe. PC version is superior to the XBLA version. It even lets you tone down the visual craziness if you're some kind of pussy. Don't play it like Tempest 2000. Read the Help section and maybe watch a youtube video. If you played Space Giraffe like Space Giraffe it's an amazing experience.
Buy Jamestown. I tend to be a shooter snob. I didn't buy this at launch because the whole widescreen Western developed shooter with unlockables was a turnoff. But it's actually pretty good. I can think of a bunch of little tweaks that would improve it, but it's obviously a labor of love and so much better than any other Western shooter I've played recently. So now I kinda regret not paying full price. Definitely worth the $6.xx it's selling for right now.
Buy VVVVVV When it comes to the 2D platformers of 2010 I think I had more fun with VVVVVV than Super Meat Boy. Great soundtrack, nice slippy controls, clever gimmicks and puzzles, perfect length.
Buy X-Com. Because it's the best. I'd say buy Jagged Alliance 2 but the Steam version had a bug that they didn't patch for years. Dunno if they fixed it yet?
Buy Real Myst. It's $3. It's a Myst remake. By Sunsoft. Yeah, the guys who did Blaster Master and Batman and Journey to Silius and Gimmick. They remade Myst in a 3D engine. Got it as a gift during the Christmas sale and was surprised to find myself actually digging it. Cheat once you get to that tunnel maze though. That thing blows.
Buy Shatter. I honestly haven't put too much time into it, so I'm not fully comfortable going all bold text on it...but I'm pretty sure it's a good game. Those Gripshift dudes make some good stuff.
Buy Hinterland. Hinterland is a really great concept. Diablo with some low-level city building built in. It didn't have the longevity I'd hoped for but I'd recommend it over most of the Diablo clones out there, cuz none of them are better than Diablo. Hinterland is at least something very different.
Buy Recettear cuz I still feel guilty for getting it in that $5 indie bundle. Steal of the century.
Buy Sid Meier's Pirates
Buy Aquaria cuz it's a pretty good 2D exploration Metroid-y deal.
GAMES YOU SHOULDN'T BUY - LEARN FROM MY MISTAKES
Do not buy the Path. Tales of Tales makes games that don't require a player. I try not to throw out the 'it's not even a game' card, but when it comes to Tales of Tales it's true. They're not games. They're not even good examples of interactive storytelling. If their games were films -- and they may as well be -- they'd be laughed at, because they are embarrassingly bad. Do not buy the Path.
Do not buy Jolly Rover. I guess I got it in one of the indie Christmas sale bundles? I played it to earn a summer camp ticket because I am stupid. By the third puzzle the lead character is mouthing off about how stupidly nonsensical the puzzle solutions are, which is a very, very bad sign. "Sometimes I don't understand why I do the things I do!"
It's like this. Except it's from 2010 or something. I'm not nuts about the new Telltale adventure games but they are many times better than Jolly Rover.
Do not buy Dark Void Zero. It's a jetpack game that constantly strips you of your jetpack. It's very short and easy. It's got lousy level design and iffy collision detection. It's by Backbone or one of its offshoots. If you want to play 8-bit style games go play the real thing. This is a terrible impersonation that gets nearly everything wrong.
I played
the Polynomial to get a ticket. I dunno what the hell was going on in that game. I don't think anyone who played it has a clue what was going on. I swear half the indie games on Steam are barely designed REZ-inspired neon musical borefests and I probably own all of them thanks to all these bundles.
Is Beat Hazard on this list?
Because no one should buy Beat Hazard. The game is an eyesore. It's like they ripped some sprites from a mid 90's shareware shooter and laid them on top of a blindingly obnoxious MP3 visualizer. It's also another score attack game designed by people who don't seem to understand score attack games. If you wanna blow your eyes out buy Space Giraffe. If you wanna solid twin stick shooter buy Geometry Wars. Don't buy Beat Hazard.
Zombie Driver is a better concept than it is a game, and it's still not as good a concept as Simple 2000 Zombie Vs Ambulance.
Do not buy any of those dejobaan games. I feel somewhat bad for being so negative in this post. Bitching comes easier than praising. I'm sure these games are all products of hardworking people. Many of them probably never made a game before. I'm sure they'll get better! But I have a very, very strong dislike for dejobaan's games, and I don't think I can go into detail without sounding like the biggest asshole in the world. That Katamari clone just offended me deeply, OK? And everything they've made since seems similarly sloppy and forced, though at least they're original shitty games rather than blatant ripoffs.