• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Lets show the Shadow Ops series some love.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Veelk

Banned
You know what I genre I rarely ever see? Military Urban Fantasy. We have plenty of Military fiction and plenty of Military Science fiction and plenty of Military Fantasy set in the medieval past. But how many books have you seen about magic re-entering the world in the modern setting? Granted, I could be talking out my ass here. I'm not very into the military fiction genre in general. I am big into fantasy, and when Urban fantasy comes up, it's usually ordinary people that are in the forefront of that story. Hell, when the books got a spike in sales on amazon, they were classified as Military Sci-fi, to the author's chagrin.

I found these books when I made a friend that used to be in the military. He encouraged me to look at more military fiction, which the finding of the Shadow Ops series, in which all the protagonists are military soldiers.

And you know, the reason I always am weary of military stories is because I'm not all that for the glorification of militaries. I don't have a bone of patriotism in my body, and while I often feel like there is good moral dilemma's that can be explored, a lot of the time I feel it's shortchanged for the thrills of the battlefield itself. Perhaps that's an unfair assessment, because like I said, I don't read that much MF, so maybe I just have a misconception of it, but it's not a condemnation, I'm just explaining the reason why I personally haven't read as many military books.

Shadow Ops doesn't do that. It has plenty of action, sure, but the heart of the books is very personal. There are two trilogies in the series.

8vADZGz.jpg

The one that came was published first is centered around an the dilemma of how does society deal with people with superpowers. Think X-men, except they mostly figured out what powers are and are not possible instead of the mutant gene producing anything. In their case, they decide the solution is to press them into military service, giving them essentially the choice of either working for the government or being killed or imprisoned for life in a cell no one can find. THis is done because they are unable to control their powers and are a danger to both themselves and others. It's a very grey area that the main character, Oscar Britton (who is black, for those that believe diverse presentation is important) where he discovers that his magic awakens in a forbidden school (Different types of magic are called schools, and some (The main elements of fire, water, earth, and wind) are legally allowed into military service while others (such as necromancy) are illegal due to moral questionability and destructive scale potential) and is put on the run. Books 2 and 3 gain other protagonists as they go and struggle with this moral dilemma. I think the characters are pretty good, and I think each of them has surprised me by defying the stereotype that the narrative (mostly Britton, as he's our audience surrogate, being introduced to many elements of how the Supernatural Corps work that were hidden from him until he manifested) initially fit them in. Sometimes the narrative drags a bit, the main characters make a dumb decision once or twice, but it's mostly a pretty solid story.

The main thing I actually want to criticize though might actually be a good thing. The characters move through the world mostly holding to their own plotlines, so when we come across something interesting, they might or might not explore it. Here is one spoiler example. It's minor, but for those that want to enter the series as cleanly as possible, I marked it.
There is another dimension in the series called the Source, where all sorts of supernatural creatures (both animals and civilizations) lie. My main desire is to have that area explored, and while the characters do that when it's pertinent to their journey, they don't go further than that. Given the militaristic narrative, I'd have thought that World War III (Or Dimensional War I might be the more appropriate term) is like the most natural end point of this kind of series, which would be one epic campaign...but it never happens and there isn't any indication it's going there. And probably for the better, as there isn't as much human drama in the politics between humanity and this other dimension and I feel it would devolve into a generic alien invasion story.
And yes, I am aware of the irony of my wanting this even though I just mentioned that I didn't like it when military stories abandon the moral dilemma's for brainless action. It's natural to want epic fights, I guess, but it's probably for the best that the author focus' on the actual moral dilemma's that make the series as interesting as it is for me.


The second trilogy is a prequel to the first, but includes none of the characters or story arcs the first main trilogy. It's a second entry point, and you could easily read it without reading the first trilogy and not miss a thing other than the occasional reference that doesn't really matter. While Magic in the first has existed long enough for society of have established laws around them in the first trilogy, in this second one, magic is new and secret military intelligence is aware of it as of now, with the general public unaware of it's existence. I feel this is almost the better entry point, as the readers discover the magic along with the protagonist, though things are by no means confusing in the first trilogy.

It's hard to talk about the premise without giving away some early spoilers, which some might not mind, but I'll spoil it just in case. The main protagonist is Jim Schweitzer and
he dies in the first few chapters, before coming back as a zombie from a necromancer. He still has his own intelligence, but he has to share his body with a bloodthirsty jinn, and the only life left to him is to serve in Gemini Cell, a black ops unit that makes use of zombies like him because they're basically super soldiers.
And I think he's the best character the author has written so far. He's far more likable and personable, maintaining a relatively upbeat attitude (not overly so, but more than any of the protagonists of the first trilogy) even though life's recreational activity seems to be to shit on him from the fucking sky. He's a different flavor of soldier from the previous protagonists, who questioned even their roles in the military. He does that too, but not in the same way, not in the slightest being ashamed of his role as a killer of terrorists, while never seeming psychopathic about it. He's in fact very empathetic, thoughtful, and compassionate. You might notice that I am talking much more about the main characters actual character here than the plot premise. That's what I feel separates these main two trilogies. Where the first trilogy is mainly focused on the societal problem of dealing with the resurrection of magic, this is felt far more like a character drama. That's an oversimplification, as both trilogies have both elements, but one leans more on one, and the other leans more on the other. And with this, the main point of tension is Jim's personal happiness as he keeps encountering situations that challenge his morals, identity, and safety, and it works very well.

However, while I can safely recommend the whole trilogy of the first series, I can only recommend the first book of this new one, since I've only read the first book. The second book just came out today. But I feel the author has been on a relatively steady incline in quality. I actually like the first book of the Oscar Britton trilogy the most, but most other people seem to like the second the most, and I think everyone feels the third is a relatively good conclusion. But I feel that Gemini Cell was his best of all, and I'll update this thread once I finish the new one, which I have high hopes for.
 

Palmer_v1

Member
I've been in the mood for something different lately, so I'll give this series a try. I normally avoid anything that takes place in modern day due to the preachiness. It doesn't read into that territory too badly?
 

Veelk

Banned
I've been in the mood for something different lately, so I'll give this series a try. I normally avoid anything that takes place in modern day due to the preachiness. It doesn't read into that territory too badly?

I wouldn't say so. The moral message is a swinging pendulum, especially in the first book where the main character is desperately trying to find his place in this new military.
He goes back and forth between wanting to desert and wanting to serve, because every time he's about to agree with the institution, they do something to disgust him, and every time he wants to dessert, they do something to gain his respect.
I don't feel there's much preachiness because most of the book is the characters trying to figure out what the hell their supposed to preach in the first place.
 

MartyStu

Member
I generally really hate Urban Fantasy, so I ignored this series when it first came out.

Recently I thought to give it a try, but a friend of mine essentially put me off of the entire thing.

Maybe I will give it a shot after all.
 

Veelk

Banned
I generally really hate Urban Fantasy, so I ignored this series when it first came out.

Recently I thought to give it a try, but a friend of mine essentially put me off of the entire thing.

Maybe I will give it a shot after all.

I think it's worth trying just because it's something I never seen before. It's still the only military urban fantasy book I know of. It's not a series that I would place as the best of the best in about any individual category, but I think it's decent as a whole, especially Gemini Cell. I can't promise you'll like it as if you hate Urban fantasy as a rule, but it's the only one of it's kind in the subgenre, so I'd give it a shot for that reason if nothing else. I'd recommend you go with GC if that's the case though, since I feel that's the best written of all his work. Unless you like the societal moral dilemma angle, then the first trilogy might be more your speed.

What did you're friend say about it that put you off it?
 

Kyosaiga

Banned
Read this series.

I'm of the opinion that Gemini Cell is pretty bad, even with Jim being a relatively decent protagonist. Far too much action that drags and doesn't get to the point, and you can barely tell its a SO novel.

For the main trilogy it's 2>1>>>>>>3.


Just my .02
 

Veelk

Banned
Read this series.

I'm of the opinion that Gemini Cell is pretty bad, even with Jim being a relatively decent protagonist. Far too much action that drags and doesn't get to the point, and you can barely tell its a SO novel.

For the main trilogy it's 2>1>>>>>>3.


Just my .02

I feel they have two different styles so I can understand people having different favorites.

I'm definitely the odd duck when it comes to the main trilogy though, as I like the second book the least.
 

MartyStu

Member
I think it's worth trying just because it's something I never seen before. It's still the only military urban fantasy book I know of. It's not a series that I would place as the best of the best in about any individual category, but I think it's decent as a whole, especially Gemini Cell. I can't promise you'll like it as if you hate Urban fantasy as a rule, but it's the only one of it's kind in the subgenre, so I'd give it a shot for that reason if nothing else. I'd recommend you go with GC if that's the case though, since I feel that's the best written of all his work. Unless you like the societal moral dilemma angle, then the first trilogy might be more your speed.

What did you're friend say about it that put you off it?

According to her, the character work was overall very inconsistent.
 

Veelk

Banned
According to her, the character work was overall very inconsistent.

Well, that's too vague for me to respond to, as I'm not sure what she means by that or even which character she is referring to, if a specific one at all. I could maybe agree about Oscar Britton, but not as a fault against the series, but in that the character himself doesn't know what he wants to do, for the reasons I explained in my reply to the first guy here. Sometimes characters just change from having received development off screen, but again, that's intentional, since the reasons for that development are always mentioned even if the process isn't shown.

So idk. Like I said, worth trying, and if you don't like it, you can drop it. Simple as that.
 

Veelk

Banned
Alright, just finished Javelin Rain.

I think it had some of the most emotionally gripping moments that the series has had thus far. Jim's life fucking SUCKS, and it Javelin Rain doesn't let up on that front. For me, this was the best part of the book. Not just because Jim is the source of the best zombie action that the book has to offer, but also the moments of the most emotional sympathy. Seeing Jim struggling to hold on to the scraps of humanity were the most poignant moments of the book, and it's what mostly kept me turning the page. I once again question the author's decision to keep adding more and more PoV's, as even if those he added were arguably necessary, they weren't as compelling as the periphery ones in the first book, mainly because they lacked personal attachment to Jim. I think that the best way to describe this book is that the lows of it are sorta low, but the highs can be pretty damn high. When the book is at the top of it's game (again, usually with Jim), it's pretty good.

While Gemini Cell switched between different PoV's (mainly Sarah's and Steve's), the first book was very clearly Jim's story, and those other PoV's were constantly trying to advance Jim's plot in some way. Javelin Rain's plotlines are more loosely connected. Or maybe you could argue that they aren't, since their mission statement is to get Jim, but it doesn't feel like that, because while they care about Jim insofar as their job is concerned, Jim doesn't even strictly speaking know about them and certainly doesn't care about them beyond their jobs. It means that their plots are a lot less personal. Sarah and Steve looking for Jim was tense and involving while Dadou and Jawid's journey to try and better their skills is occupational. It's not that they're badly written, exactly, because the final climax of their journey together was pretty intense. It's just that it's a story clearly separated from Jim's. I wonder what would have happened if they had simply not included them. When Jim finally met them, they'd just be random enemies to him, and he'd have done his business and moved on. I struggle on whether that would have worked, narratively speaking, or not. Maybe having these two storylines is indespensible, but I feel they're the shakiest part of the book. Mostly because of Jawid. While I pity him, it's hard for me to get into the character as much as the others because he's a far simpler character. He's a religious fanatic and his emotional conflicts and goals toward resolving them are unrealistic. He's not a particularly smart dude, and other than being a sad sack, he doesn't have much going for him. Especially since whenever we get Dadou's PoV, we see how easily she's manipulating him. If we were going to have this storyline, I'd have rather had it all from Dadou's perspective, as she's by far the more compelling character of the two.

And we have Eldredge, who I like but there isn't much to him. I wish there was more to say about him, but his plotline is essentially realizing that the Gemini Cell is a bag of dicks and want to get out. It also involves possibly the most unrealistic scene of the series, where their murderous magic zombies lay waste to literally an entire town and they decide to cover it up by having a main valve explode. Idk, I feel that would be very difficult to cover up...but than again, somehow the Dresden Files managed to get me to buy their excuse for why the world doesn't believe in magic, so maybe. But I like Eldredge's character and he was the viewpoint that got us to see the ultimate puppetmaster, so those were pretty cool scenes.

If anyone here who is reading them has been in the military, I'd actually like them to speak up, as I'm curious if this series simply speaks more to those who have served. I like this series well enough, and they're certainly better than a lot of what I've read, but I'm not crazy about them even though I'm open to the idea of being so. Maybe I'm of the wrong personality types to enjoy these books to the fullest, and these stories will speak more to those people that have actual military experience.

I'm still wondering if he's ever going to go for a Supernatural World War though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom