• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

March 2008: Iraq war veteran tosses his medals

Status
Not open for further replies.
Video of press conference

Jon Turner is a former Marine who fought with the 3rd Battalion, 8th Marines in Iraq and who testified at Winter Soldier March 13-16. This aired Monday March 17, 2008 on Democracy Now.

AMY GOODMAN: Iraq and Afghanistan veterans gathered in Maryland this past weekend to testify at Winter Soldier, an eyewitness indictment of atrocities committed by US troops during the ongoing occupations in Iraq and Afghanistan. Organized by Iraq Veterans Against the War, the event was modeled after the historic 1971 Winter Soldier hearings held during the Vietnam War.

Over the weekend, war veterans spoke of free-fire zones, the shootings and beatings of innocent civilians, racism at the highest levels of the military, sexual harassment and assault within the military, and the torturing of prisoners.

Although Winter Soldier was held just outside the nation’s capital, it was almost entirely ignored by the American corporate media. A search on the Lexis database found that no major television network or cable news network even mentioned Winter Soldier over the weekend, neither did the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Los Angeles Times or most other major newspapers in the country. The editors of the Washington Post chose to cover Winter Soldier but placed the article in the local section.

On Friday, Democracy Now! broadcast from Winter Soldier. This week, we play excerpts from the proceedings. We begin with Jon Michael Turner, who fought with the 3rd Battalion, 8th Marines.

JON MICHAEL TURNER: Good afternoon. My name is Jon Michael Turner. I currently reside in Burlington, Vermont. I served with Kilo Company, 3rd Battalion, 8th Marines as an automatic machine gunner. There’s a term, “Once a Marine, always a Marine.” But there’s also the term, “Eat the apple, F the corps, I don’t work for you no more.”

AMY GOODMAN: That was Jon Michael Turner, stripping his medals and ribbons from his chest and throwing them into the audience to the applause of attendees at Winter Soldier. Turner then went on to describe some of his time in Iraq.


JON MICHAEL TURNER: On April 18, 2006, I had my first confirmed killed. This man was innocent. I don’t know his name. I called him “the fat man.” He was walking back to his house, and I shot him in front of his friend and his father. The first round didn’t kill him, after I had hit him up here in his neck area. And afterwards he started screaming and looked right into my eyes. So I looked at my friend, who I was on post with, and I said, “Well, I can’t let that happen.” So I took another shot and took him out. He was then carried away by the rest of his family. It took seven people to carry his body away.

We were all congratulated after we had our first kills, and that happened to have been mine. My company commander personally congratulated me, as he did everyone else in our company. This is the same individual who had stated that whoever gets their first kill by stabbing them to death will get a four-day pass when we return from Iraq.

There was one incident, where we got into a firefight just south of the government center about 2,000 meters. We had no idea where the fire was coming from. And the way our rules of engagement were, pinpoint where the fire is coming from and throw a rocket at it. So, at that being said, we still didn’t know where the fire was coming from, and an eighty-four-millimeter rocket was shot into a house. I do not know if there was anyone in it. We do not know if that’s where the fire was coming from. But that’s what was done.

Please go to the next image. This man right here was my third confirmed killed. As you can see, he was riding his bicycle. Later on in the day, we went ahead, and we had CBS’s Lara Logan with us, but she was with the other squad, and so she wasn’t with us. So, myself and two other people went ahead and took out some individuals, because we were excited about the firefight we had just gotten into, and we didn’t have a cameraman or woman with us. With that being said, any time we did have embedded reporters with us, our actions would change drastically. We never acted the same. We were always on key with everything, did everything by the books. The man on the bicycle, he was left in the street for about ten minutes until we realized that we needed to leave where we were. And his body was dragged about ten feet to the right of him, where his body was thrown behind a rock wall and his bicycle was thrown on top of him.

Another thing that we used to do a lot was recon by fire, where we would go ahead and try to start a firefight if we felt threatened in any way, shape or form. There was one particular incident where we were working with the Iraqi Army and the Iraqi Special Forces in downtown Ramadi, and with our squad and the Iraqi Army there was also lieutenant colonels, majors, first sergeants and sergeant majors—sorry, sergeants major. With that being said, the Iraqi Army would go into the house, kick in the doors and then go ahead and shoot. And there were loud bursts of machinegun fire. We thought we were taking fire, but then we later found out that it was them.

House raids—because we were a grunt battalion, we were responsible for going on several patrols. A lot of the raids and patrols we did were at night around 3:00 in the morning, around there. And what we would do is just kick in the doors and terrorize the families. That was an image taken around 3:00 in the morning through night vision goggles. And that is the segregation of the women and children and the men. If the men of the household were giving us problems, we’d go ahead and take care of them anyway we felt necessary, whether it be choking them or slamming their head against the walls. If you go back to that one picture, that was one man that wasn’t taking—that was taken care of in a very bad way, because of all the wiring that he had. We considered it IED-making material.

On my wrist, there’s Arabic for “F you.” I got that put on my wrist just two weeks before we went to Iraq, because that was my choking hand, and any time I felt the need to take out aggression, I would go ahead and use it.

Please go to the next picture. Next, there’s an instance of detainees and how they were treated in a nice manner.

Next, that is the Fatima Mosque minaret. As you can see, it is ridden with bullet holes and holes in the top of it. Those were from mortars. And the next video that I’m going to show you is a tank round that went into that minaret, where we weren’t sure if we were taking fire or not. Actually, I’ll talk about this one. This is after one of the guys in a weapons company had gotten shot. This is a way that we would take out our aggression. For those of you who don’t know, it is illegal to shoot into a mosque, unless you were taking fire from it. There was no fire that was taken from that mosque. It was shot into because we were angry.

Next image. That—OK, with that being said, there’s many more stories and incidents for me to talk about, although we don’t have the time to. But this just goes to show you that that was the aftereffect of the tank round. This just goes to show you that everyone sitting up here has these stories, and there’s been over a million trips that have gone in and out of Iraq, so the possibilities are endless.

Next image, please. The reason I am doing this today is not only for myself and for the rest of society to hear, but it’s for all those who can’t be here to talk about the things that we went through, talk about the things that we did.

Next image. Those four crosses and this memorial service were for the five guys in Kilo Company, 3rd Battalion, 8th Marines that we lost. Throughout our unit, we had eighteen that got killed. With that being said, that is my testimony. I just want to say that I am sorry for the hate and destruction that I have inflicted on innocent people, and I’m sorry for the hate and destruction that others have inflicted on innocent people. At one point, it was OK. But reality has shown that it’s not and that this is happening and that until people hear about what is going on with this war, it will continue to happen and people will continue to die. I am sorry for the things that I did. I am no longer the monster that I once was. Thank you.

http://www.democracynow.org/2008/3/17/winter_soldier_us_vets_active_duty
 

Barrett2

Member
An individual soldier has a political opinion on something. Better hold a press conference.


Over the weekend, war veterans spoke of free-fire zones, the shootings and beatings of innocent civilians, racism at the highest levels of the military

How exactly would low level soldiers have first-hand knowledge of this?
 
tumblr_lm7dzeN1ZM1qii6tmo1_500.gif
 

LuchaShaq

Banned
I think it's telling that out of the 6 under 30 acquaintances/friends that I know that went into the army/navy the only one who doesn't regret it is the nuclear engineer who works on a sub.
 

LQX

Member
Watch him deny this ever happened 20 years from now when he is running for some office.
 

DarkKyo

Member
What the fuck? Why do these soldiers have carte blanche on epic brutality and cruelty?

Disgusting. These soldiers are no better than the terrorists they went over there for.
 

Barrett2

Member
Should only civilians who have never been in combat talk about the war?

I don't know what you're getting at.


My point is that its super annoying IMO that soldiers get hoisted up by the media any time they are willing to say something politically useful for a particular political party.

Not to mention that this guy admits to following orders to kill innocent people? So he is a murderer? If he has such damning evidence, seems like he should be able to do something more useful with it than a press conference.
 
What the fuck? Why do these soldiers have carte blanche on epic brutality and cruelty?

Disgusting. These soldiers are no better than the terrorists they went over there for.

It's not fair to brush everyone with the same stroke. The abuse of power by soliders in conflicts is as ancient as war itself, but most do not fall into the category he is speaking about
 
So this guy is saying that, on more than one occasion, he willfully followed unlawful orders?

More than that. His belief is that there is a culture of it within the military to do so. Not until he realised his own remorse did he begin to acknowledge that. The topic isn't new but I found his experiences worth being shared
 

DY_nasty

NeoGAF's official "was this shooting justified" consultant
So this guy is saying that, on more than one occasion, he willfully followed unlawful orders?

Yep.

And that commander is pretty much a laughing stock for his "bounty"/incentive. My SGM actually showed me the coins he used to hand out - dude essentially created warzones out of generally peaceful areas. He's not in charge of anything important anymore. Just still looks bad regularly.
More than that. His belief is that there is a culture of it within the military to do so. Not until he realised his own remorse did he begin to acknowledge that. The topic isn't new but I found his experiences worth being shared

war is fucked up

its not just a us soldier thing guy

war has always been fucked up
 

dejay

Banned
"War is hell" as a statement is almost literal. There's nothing nice, noble or chivalrous about war. If you support a war, know that shit like that is going to happen. A lot of innocent people are going to be butchered. A lot of young soldiers are going to have their lives ripped apart, even if they survive physically intact. So you'd better be certain there's no better alternative to war, because starting a war is condemning hundreds of thousands of people to torment, maming or death.
 

DY_nasty

NeoGAF's official "was this shooting justified" consultant
I think the point of his messages were that 'unlawful orders' were common practice.
No, it wasn't. It was one unit of many.

Please don't take a few articles and immediately think some large percentage of 140,000 soldiers are raping and pillaging unchecked in the middle east.

An article about something good = "Isn't that nice." ":D".

An article about something bad = "OMG" "I hate humanity" "there is no point of the military at all" "there is no god" "fuck america" "they're no better than terrorists!" "i don't wanna live on this planet anymore" "these soldiers are just animals" x 20
 

DarkKyo

Member
It's not fair to brush everyone with the same stroke. The abuse of power by soliders in conflicts is as ancient as war itself, but most do not fall into the category he is speaking about

Yeah I know. I didn't say all soldiers. I said "these soldiers" referring to the ones they are describing in this article.
 
No, it wasn't. It was one unit of many.

Please don't take a few articles and immediately think some large percentage of 140,000 soldiers are raping and pillaging unchecked in the middle east.

An article about something good = "Isn't that nice." ":D".

An article about something bad = "OMG" "I hate humanity" "there is no point of the military at all" "there is no god" "fuck america" "they're no better than terrorists!" "i don't wanna live on this planet anymore" "these soldiers are just animals" x 20

If you go to the timeframe of 7 mins and 15 seconds into the video, he remarks "There have been a million troops going into Iraq and so the possibilities are endless", he is implicitly saying there is a high probability that these have happened on a wider scale than what he has personally seen.
 
People do these things and they come back and we still call them heroes? People go to other countries and do this and then they come back and are saluted like they're the second coming? No. Enough of that. No more.

He isn't a hero. He broke the law by following unlawful orders.
 

DY_nasty

NeoGAF's official "was this shooting justified" consultant
If you go to the timeframe of 7 mins and 15 seconds into the video, he remarks "There have been a million troops going into Iraq and so the possibilities are endless", he is implicitly saying there is a high probability that these have happened on a wider scale than what he has personally seen.

So we're going off the "one guy saw it all" angle now?

On top of that, what war didn't have fucked up situations like this one? Not a single one. The only difference is that because there are mediums to reach more people and their are more than just the occasional painter in the field with them, more are starting to get an idea of just how fucked it up it is.

Shit irks the hell out of me how people haven't even been remotely close to anything slightly resembling something in the general fucking neighborhood of stuff like this, and then they want to throw their two cents in like things should/could/would be different if _____. Or they should really do something about _____. The article is old as shit, did you even bother to look up the commanding officer who is now an official embarrassment and walking punchline because of this? No - you just threw the shit up here.

I'm not trying to diminish the importance of what this soldier is saying, because that sentiment is shared upon a lot of soldiers - but its not just isolated to the US soldier OR the Iraq War. And the way you went about posting some old ass article on it, I can't help but get pissed off by it. If you're trying to raise awareness, empathy, anger at command, there are MUCH better ways to go about it and I'd at least appreciate the effort in some form instead of some slapped up article about one soldier who probably can share that story with a soldier from every war ever.
 
So we're going off the "one guy saw it all" angle now?

On top of that, what war didn't have fucked up situations like this one? Not a single one. The only difference is that because there are mediums to reach more people and their are more than just the occasional painter in the field with them, more are starting to get an idea of just how fucked it up it is.

Shit irks the hell out of me how people haven't even been remotely close to anything slightly resembling something in the general fucking neighborhood of stuff like this, and then they want to throw their two cents in like things should/could/would be different if _____. Or they should really do something about _____. The article is old as shit, did you even bother to look up the commanding officer who is now an official embarrassment and walking punchline because of this? No - you just threw the shit up here.

I'm not trying to diminish the importance of what this soldier is saying, because that sentiment is shared upon a lot of soldiers - but its not just isolated to the US soldier OR the Iraq War. And the way you went about posting some old ass article on it, I can't help but get pissed off by it. If you're trying to raise awareness, empathy, anger at command, there are MUCH better ways to go about it and I'd at least appreciate the effort in some form instead of some slapped up article about one soldier who probably can share that story with a soldier from every war ever.

This is true. I wasn't trying to demonise the US here but use this as an opportunity to highlight what war often brings.

Secondly, I don't understand this complaint about the timeline. This took place in a war that has just recently officially ended but has been fought for almost a decade whilst the case for future conflict in the region is being made elsewhere. In that context, the criticism of the date -as if it somehow negates the fundamental point about the degenerate facet of war - is unwarranted.

This isn't a political thread. All I'm doing is revealing a side to war that has been (IMO) grossly ignored

You can do that in a lot of different ways then bringing up old shit that has since been handled from guys being sent to military prisons, labeled war criminals, and had entire systems from prevention to reporting put in place to make it a lot harder for the same thing to happen again.

I'm sorry you feel offended, that wasn't my intent. But I disagree with your impression of what this thread is about.
 

DY_nasty

NeoGAF's official "was this shooting justified" consultant
This is true. I wasn't trying to demonise the US here but use this as an opportunity to highlight what war often brings.

You can do that in a lot of different ways then bringing up old shit that has since been handled from guys being sent to military prisons, labeled war criminals, and had entire systems from prevention to reporting put in place to make it a lot harder for the same thing to happen again.
Secondly, I don't understand this complaint about the timeline. This took place in a war that has just recently officially ended but has been fought for almost a decade whilst the case for future conflict in the region is being made elsewhere. In that context, the criticism of the date -as if it somehow negates the fundamental point about the degenerate facet of war - is unwarranted IMHO.
Units and soldiers are cycled in and out constantly. That unit wasn't there the entire time and the marines didn't fight the entire war. The war has been fought in many different ways all the way from conventional warfare down to counter insurgency and in each step of the war the way things operated changed. The guys who were in Iraq in 2008 didn't see the same things as the guys did in 2004 or the guys in 2010.

edit: so what the hell was the thread about? You just threw an article up with nothing behind it. An old one at that.
 

WanderingWind

Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
He isn't a hero. He broke the law by following unlawful orders.

Indeed. And frankly, I question whether or not he ever got orders to just shoot some random fucking people, and from what rank they were. A Marine fire team leader, for instance, can give orders. He can also be a lance corporal or a corporal.

All I got from this was this particular Marine is a murdering sociopath who is so far removed from a center of reality that only now he's "sorry for the hate and destruction" that he caused. Well, bud, you had not only the right to not cause it, but the legal and moral obligation to not kill innocent people.
 
Units and soldiers are cycled in and out constantly. That unit wasn't there the entire time and the marines didn't fight the entire war. The war has been fought in many different ways all the way from conventional warfare down to counter insurgency and in each step of the war the way things operated changed. The guys who were in Iraq in 2008 didn't see the same things as the guys did in 2004 or the guys in 2010.

The type of behaviour the vet describes in the video has unfortunately been retold throughout the entire war, from examples going back to 2003. This isn't limited to a particular unit or a particular deployment time, if that is what you were implying

so what the hell was the thread about? You just threw an article up with nothing behind it. An old one at that.

One of the reasons I didn't include 'US' in the thread title was so to avoid this misunderstanding. I should have just titled it 'War vet'. As to what its about, I've said already:

This is true. I wasn't trying to demonise the US here but use this as an opportunity to highlight what war often brings.
..the fundamental point about the degenerate facet of war
This isn't a political thread. All I'm doing is revealing a side to war that has been (IMO) grossly ignored​
 

DY_nasty

NeoGAF's official "was this shooting justified" consultant
The type of behaviour the vet describes in the video has unfortunately been retold throughout the entire war, from examples going back to 2003. This isn't limited to a particular unit or a particular deployment time, if that is what you were implying
No, the Iraq War vet part kinda implies that

but whatever, there were a number of things you could' have specifically addressed instead of shotgun approaching it so i really couldn't give a fuck anymore. this kinda shit just makes me roll my fucking eyes and be slightly more pissed off that I don't get to see my family after busting my ass on the border for 6 months and people can't even be bother to actually look up what they want to argue about the military that they don't even know
 

Zaptruder

Banned
He isn't a hero. He broke the law by following unlawful orders.

When the military by necessity drills it into their recruits that the Chain of command is all important... Where does legality fit into that scheme of things?

Obedience and groupthink is a systemic cultural feature of militaries all over the world past and present.

This kind of stuff isn't an exception to a rule... Its part and parcel of all military campaigns. Especially ones as protracted and meaningless as this. And should be factored into the calculations of any that think that war should be pursued on a moral basis.
 

WanderingWind

Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
When the military by necessity drills it into their recruits that the Chain of command is all important... Where does legality fit into that scheme of things

This is the kind of thing that DY is talking about. You clearly do not know what you're talking about.

Yes, chain of command is important, but along with every lesson regarding chain of command is a dual lesson in following lawful orders and proper procedures for jumping a link in the chain of command. It's why saying "I was only following orders" is so odious. It's a way to absolve yourself of guilt and has nothing to do with actualities (and not the movies) of the U.S. military. It's basically saying you're scared of an ass-chewing, so you'll commit murder. It's not an excuse. At all.
 
No, the Iraq War vet part kinda implies that

but whatever, there were a number of things you could' have specifically addressed instead of shotgun approaching it so i really couldn't give a fuck anymore. this kinda shit just makes me roll my fucking eyes and be slightly more pissed off that I don't get to see my family after busting my ass on the border for 6 months and people can't even be bother to actually look up what they want to argue about the military that they don't even know

You're right in that I should have been more specific
 
When the military by necessity drills it into their recruits that the Chain of command is all important... Where does legality fit into that scheme of things

One of the first things a good drill instructor/Sargent SHOULD install in a soldier is to know the difference between right and wrong. Yes, Chain of Command is important but ROE is order of law while deployed.

If anyone in a position of power gives you a command and it breaks ROE you're supposed to tell them to fuck off and report them.
 

Zaptruder

Banned
This is the kind of thing that DY is talking about. You clearly do not know what you're talking about.

Yes, chain of command is important, but along with every lesson regarding chain of command is a dual lesson in following lawful orders and proper procedures for jumping a link in the chain of command. It's why saying "I was only following orders" is so odious. It's a way to absolve yourself of guilt and has nothing to do with actualities (and not the movies) of the U.S. military. It's basically saying you're scared of an ass-chewing, so you'll commit murder. It's not an excuse. At all.

It's good that there's a counteractive system like that in place - but when you play it out in the kinds of numbers that wars see - where the experience of training and induction isn't going to ever be universally similar - where the culture between units is also not going to be the same... this is the kind of variance you should expect in units and individuals.

Is there a way to skew it in a better direction? Yeah. Be more vigilant about finding individuals and units that break lawful orders. But when weighing up many competing needs in a complex warzone situation - is it surprising that civilian casualties of people that we can barely empathize with gets the short shrift at all levels?

But if this report on this kind of stuff is anything to go by... it would appear that we're not just been not vigilant about this kind of stuff happening... we're trying to actively bury it, to reduce our collective social cognitive dissonance on the subject.
 

WanderingWind

Mecklemore Is My Favorite Wrapper
One of the first things a good drill instructor/Sargent SHOULD install in a soldier is to know the difference between right and wrong. Yes, Chain of Command is important but ROE is order of law while deployed.

If anyone in a position of power gives you a command and it breaks ROE you're supposed to tell them to fuck off and report them.

And it doesn't stop after recruit training. That is constantly drilled into service members in garrison, in pre-deployment training and in country. It's absurd to treat the chain of command as brainwashing, when it's simple a system like any other company that has low-level employees, middle management, upper management, a board of directors and a CEO.

It gives shitbags a nice excuse to fall back on when they fuck up though!

It's good that there's a counteractive system like that in place - but when you play it out in the kinds of numbers that wars see - where the experience of training and induction isn't going to ever be universally similar - where the culture between units is also not going to be the same... this is the kind of variance you should expect in units and individuals.

Is there a way to skew it in a better direction? Yeah. Be more vigilant about finding individuals and units that break lawful orders. But when weighing up many competing needs in a complex warzone situation - is it surprising that civilian casualties of people that we can barely empathize with gets the short shrift at all levels?

But if this report on this kind of stuff is anything to go by... it would appear that we're not just been not vigilant about this kind of stuff happening... we're trying to actively bury it, to reduce our collective social cognitive dissonance on the subject.

Except for recruit training and pre-deployment training, as well as DoD and military-specific training doctrines and laws are HIGHLY regimented and excruciatingly detailed. That is the military in a nutshell. It's patently false that something as big as chain of command procedures and ROE are fragmented, and over the past 20 years or so (as far back as I can intelligently speak) the constant barrage of what are"legal" and "moral" actions have been HUGE in the military. You simply cannot escape it. It's instilled from day 1 and never lets up.

Clearly, that does not mean that horrendous actions haven't been taken by service members. But it does mean that falling back "I was ordered" is the fault of the morally weak individual, and not indicative of an inherent flaw in the chain of command. It's rarely easy to do the right thing, military or otherwise.

Bah. Fuck, this is bordering on work now.
 

DY_nasty

NeoGAF's official "was this shooting justified" consultant
But if this report on this kind of stuff is anything to go by... it would appear that we're not just been not vigilant about this kind of stuff happening... we're trying to actively bury it, to reduce our collective social cognitive dissonance on the subject.
This is the shit I'm talking about. fucking hell
 

Zaptruder

Banned
This is the shit I'm talking about. fucking hell

Do you think a society that is vigilant about the excesses of war is going to do more harm then one that glorifies it?

Yeah, you're on point. There is just a lot of generalities been thrown around - this kind of stuff does happen in every war. And there's no hardcore study of how different policies has affected the rate at which war-crimes occur (and how this war stacks up against other wars) - at least not that we have access to.

But fuck - tighten the screws on the system and been mindful > bunch of dead innocents.

That goes not just for the guys on the front lines, but the civilian population back home that ultimately gives their consensus on funding wars.

And that's kind of the point I was trying to make - if we provide our support for war, then we need to account for atrocities as part and parcel of the thing that we're supporting.
 

Dmented

Banned
So we're going off the "one guy saw it all" angle now?

On top of that, what war didn't have fucked up situations like this one? Not a single one. The only difference is that because there are mediums to reach more people and their are more than just the occasional painter in the field with them, more are starting to get an idea of just how fucked it up it is.

Shit irks the hell out of me how people haven't even been remotely close to anything slightly resembling something in the general fucking neighborhood of stuff like this, and then they want to throw their two cents in like things should/could/would be different if _____. Or they should really do something about _____. The article is old as shit, did you even bother to look up the commanding officer who is now an official embarrassment and walking punchline because of this? No - you just threw the shit up here.

I'm not trying to diminish the importance of what this soldier is saying, because that sentiment is shared upon a lot of soldiers - but its not just isolated to the US soldier OR the Iraq War. And the way you went about posting some old ass article on it, I can't help but get pissed off by it. If you're trying to raise awareness, empathy, anger at command, there are MUCH better ways to go about it and I'd at least appreciate the effort in some form instead of some slapped up article about one soldier who probably can share that story with a soldier from every war ever.

You are dead on with everything. You pretty much sum up what I explain to everyone when it comes to these types of stories.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom