• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

MLB The Show 26 announced

Apparently not. Even being the "fastest selling console ever" hasn't helped.


Why is fastest selling console in quotes?

laugh-smile.gif
 
Meanwhile in Pro Baseball Spirits 2025...
To be fair, these have very different development cycles. Pro Yakyuu Spirits 2024-2025 came out on PS5 (September 19, 2024) five years after Pro Yakyuu Spirits 2019 did on PS4 and PS Vita (July 18, 2019). There was eBaseball Pro Yakyuu Spirits 2021: Grand Slam on Switch (July 8, 2021) in between, but still nowhere near a yearly cycle.
 
Last edited:
I don't know if specific platforms are forced rather than just making them support Nintendo as a whole. It could still come to Switch 1 and not Switch 2, even if it seems unlikely.
Lol, I called it three months ago.
 
Last edited:
I want an MLB game like that so badly 😢
You and me both friend.

I'm skipping The Show until they do some meaningful upgrades. At a minimum that means expanded rosters, international free agency, revamped progression/regression (like NBA 2k), created and sharable draft classes, the ability to have full realignment and expansion, additional sliders to adjust tendencies in franchise, and things like untouchables, etc, full league customization like NBA 2k. Just let me turn off the damn 3 batter minimum!!!!!!!!

So basically I'm not buying the game ever again unless it comes to PC and someone mods all these things in. Which they would in about half the time of one dev cycle of this game.
 
Last edited:
lol this looks like dogshit. worse than the ps4 entries. when they showed Judge's ps3 era face i legit LOL'd.

This is what happens when devs just give up and start phoning it in. Literally no shame. No self respect. Just resign and go flip burgers you lazy cunts.
 
Haven't touched The Show in years and going by the newest trailer that won't change. Man what a sad fucking state all these sports games are in these days.

Good thing there's still at least one excellent baseball game out there. You may need to jump through a bunch of hoops to get it as it's only available in Japan (this includes PSN and Steam) and is also entirely in Japanese. But hey, it never hurts to learn a new language and there are also plenty of translation tools available these days. I promise you this game is worth the effort if you're itching for a good baseball sim. It doesn't have the MLB license obviously but it's the best basegall game I've played since MVP 2005.

 
My rig must be fried, the pictures didn't load in so I didn't even see there were already about a hundred posts about PYS above mine lol.
 
They can keep it.

They haven't improved this game in any substantial fashion in over 10 years.

All the effort goes to DD. Everything else has been virtually static, except for cosmetic bullshit no one asked for. Offline play is virtually identical to the first version I played, which was 14.

Which is all really sad because, at one point, SDS was the Anti-EA. Now they're EA Jr.

🖕
 
Yeah, I think it's the first year I skip this game. I'm a lifelong diehard baseball fan and have bought every baseball game since like…World Series Baseball on Sega Genesis lol

I even had this series on the PSP.

I find myself playing it less and less every year. I just don't care for the DD stuff, at all. I even gave it a solid try a couple years ago.

I'm not their target audience anymore and haven't been for a long time.

It's fun to follow my team during the season, but they've been trash for years lol

Switch 2 would've been a bit different, at least.

Sucks 😣
 
Ok, come forward early access peeps - how is it so far? This used to be an annual purchase for me up until a few years ago with me being a massive fan of baseball. Tempted to buy this year.
 
Only managed to play one game.
I am liking the ability to challenge any pitch at any time.

Last year- if it popped up, you knew you were gonna win the challenge. Irritating during couch/local match. So a welcome change for sure.
 
Last edited:
The only reason I get MLB The Show is for the Negro Leagues.

I always wait and get it on a deep sale.

However, I forgot I have Pro Baseball Spirits 2025, and reinstalled it and plan on playing it in the meantime.
 
Only managed to play one game.
I am liking the ability to challenge any pitch at any time.

Last year- if it popped up, you knew you were gonna win the challenge. Irritating during couch/local match. So a welcome change for sure.
I hate when sports games add the ability to challenge calls. It's a video game, not real life, so the play calling should be flawless. Human error is taken out of the equation. This just means they programmed plays to be called incorrectly, so if you don't catch it then you get screwed over.
 
I hate when sports games add the ability to challenge calls. It's a video game, not real life, so the play calling should be flawless. Human error is taken out of the equation. This just means they programmed plays to be called incorrectly, so if you don't catch it then you get screwed over.
I get why that feels frustrating, but I actually think it makes sense depending on what the game is trying to be.

If it's aiming to be a pure, "perfect logic" video game, then yeah, calls should be 100% accurate every time. But most modern sports games are trying to simulate the full experience of the sport, and in real sports, human error is part of the game. Challenges aren't just about fixing mistakes, they're part of strategy, timing, and momentum.

So it's less about the game "messing up on purpose" and more about recreating that layer of decision-making. Do you risk a challenge here? Do you save it for later? That adds tension in a different way than just perfect officiating.

That said, I think your take works better for certain modes. If you're playing something more arcade-style or competitive online, flawless calls probably make more sense. But in a simulation-style mode, having challenges included is just part of trying to mirror the real sport as closely as possible.
 
Good thing there's still at least one excellent baseball game out there. You may need to jump through a bunch of hoops to get it as it's only available in Japan (this includes PSN and Steam) and is also entirely in Japanese... It doesn't have the MLB license obviously but it's the best basegall game I've played since MVP 2005.



Big change since then: it out internationally (kind of; this is a free to play version, like eFootball,) in a stealth drop.



Fun baseball game, although the hitting mechanics are notoriously difficult and the structure just might not be for everybody. But it's free, on PS5 and Steam, so check it out even if you do get this year's MLB.

(... BTW. I'm curious if some of those like Slimy who hammered MLB The Show with gifs of this Konami UE5 Pro Spirits game have now actually played the game? I personally think it shows all the Unreal seams and shortcuts that those glamour shots couldn't, and although i am frustrated that MLB the Show never really went wild graphically with the PS5 gen (I already felt the PS4 'jump' back in the day was a sign of leveling off), I would say there are visible reasons why Sony SD's tech approach is still viable. Still, an upgrade next year would be great.)
 
I don't think it's fair to compare the f2p version to the real Professional Baseball Spirits game. This is downgraded to hell to be able to run on phones and stuff, whereas the region locked :messenger_angry: full version is ps5 and pc exclusive.

free version


version that I can't buy
 
Last edited:
I hate when sports games add the ability to challenge calls. It's a video game, not real life, so the play calling should be flawless. Human error is taken out of the equation. This just means they programmed plays to be called incorrectly, so if you don't catch it then you get screwed over.
Its attempting to simulate real life. Where in real life bad calls happen and you challenge them if you feel the need/risk. Its better than the alternative last year where if a challenge came up in a critical moment- the game was telling you for a reason. You were gonna wina bad call.
 
Top Bottom