• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Musashi: Samurai Legend - IGN review

Wario64

works for Gamestop (lol)
http://ps2.ign.com/articles/595/595877p1.html

Musashi is a collision course of too many genres and not enough time tweaking the game to stand on its own. Everything about the game is just too slow and too repetitive and too awkward to hold your attention. The style is certainly worth checking out for a few minutes, but soon after that you're better off moving on to either an action title or more of a straight-up RPG. If there is any game that comes far from living up to the promise of the intro movie, it's Musashi: Samurai Legend.



7.0 Presentation
A decent menu system and clear ways of getting around make navigating the rest of Musashi's world much easier.
6.0 Graphics
The manga shading is a neat trick and some of the character designs hold up, but with a slow framerate and endlessly repeated areas those effects are diminished.
6.0 Sound
A surf rock score that barely makes sense along with some decent to mediocre voiceover that's only good if you still love Saturday morning cartoons.
5.0 Gameplay
Slow movement and long drawn out gameplay with too much backtracking makes for a game that seems to barely move at all.
4.0 Lasting Appeal
There is a storyline to progress through, but the slow running back and forth is just for those who don't ahve anything better to do until the next game comes along.
5.2 OVERALL
(out of 10 / not an average)
 
Ahaha, I watched Agent Dormer play this a bunch over the weekend and it's definitely one of the worst games I've ever seen. The camera is just attrociously bad.. probably worse than even Dino Crisis 3. I'd have scored the graphics and presentation higher though. There are some frame rate drops, but the visuals are beautiful in my opinion so I'd give the graphics a solid 8 to 8.5. One thing that has to be said, the voice overs in this are just god awful... like mindblowingly bad.

I was very negative of this game after E3 last year and it's clear they didnt do a whole lot to improve the gameplay. At least all the tearing and other graphical problems were switched.. but this is a definite pass.
 
Fuck everyone, I'm buying this. I love BFM TOO MUCH. Who did the music, by the way? Was it Tsuyoshi Sekito? Was that mystery ever solved?
 
hehe, and now we see why SE released it in the US first while there is still no date for the Jpn version :P
 
Odnetnin said:
plus the lead character wears a training bra.
Hehe, how come a lot of main characters in JRPG's wear those "training bra's"? Another example would be the lead from Tales of Eternia. And their pants go right down to their crotches too. Do Japanese people dress like this?
 
Eric-GCA said:
Hehe, how come a lot of main characters in JRPG's wear those "training bra's"? Another example would be the lead from Tales of Eternia. And their pants go right down to their crotches too. Do Japanese people dress like this?

You ever been to Japan? Shinjuku man, everyone dresses like that. It's Musashi style!
 
Sadly, I am not surprised to hear this news. Every time I've seen this game, everything about it screams "this is not Brave Fencer Musashi" to me. BFM was one of Square's AAA PSOne games and it was obvious they put a lot of focus and effort into. This game seems like some 3rd stringer team's make-work project just so Square could have some product on the shelf until FFXII and KH2.

Kinda the Devil May Cry 2 to Brave Fencer Musashi
 
Kaijima said:
Sadly, I am not surprised to hear this news. Every time I've seen this game, everything about it screams "this is not Brave Fencer Musashi" to me. BFM was one of Square's AAA PSOne games and it was obvious they put a lot of focus and effort into. This game seems like some 3rd stringer team's make-work project just so Square could have some product on the shelf until FFXII and KH2.

Kinda the Devil May Cry 2 to Brave Fencer Musashi

BFM was one of Square's AAA game?! You gotta be kidding me right? It was terrible! Voice acting really whiny and overdone, graphics ugly, gameplay simple and repetitive...

BFM and Threads of Fate...*shudder*

I thought Musashi looked good, but after reading all the reviews, I don't need another crappy action rpg from Squenix
 
Sho Nuff said:
You ever been to Japan? Shinjuku man, everyone dresses like that. It's Musashi style!
Nope, never been to Japan, I'd like to go one day. But hopefully there really aren't that many boys wearing training bra's over there.
 
nitewulf said:
psx: ff7, ff8, ff9, vagrant story, chrono cross, ff tactics.
ps2: ffx, ffx-2, and this.

nice. very nice.

um.. them next gen visuals sure take a lot of effort to produce... uh oh = next gen (ps3+more)
 
nitewulf said:
psx: ff7, ff8, ff9, vagrant story, chrono cross, ff tactics.
ps2: ffx, ffx-2, and this.

nice. very nice.

I knew this was the case, but actually seeing it put into writing like this is just so .. painful. What the hell happened?
 
You don't have to like FFX, but it was a well made game. Musashi, on the other hand, doesn't seem worth it. Then again I never liked the original Musashi, either.
 
FFX was quality. Stop the hate.
Also FFXI must have taken a lot of resources. It is (was) a great MMORPG and made them a ton of money. It's also laid the ground for future online games from Square Enix.
FFXII may well be good too, if it ever comes out.

They haven't done a lot of good "extra-curricular activity" this gen though.
 
Since Square peaked with Secret of Mana it has been all downhill.

SOM1.gif



Where have the rabites gone? -_-
 
I was looking forward to this till the GA bashing train started thanks guys.
On a brighter note Chris Kohler over at 1up gave it a 7/10.
 
isnt radiata stories by atlus?
and parallax, i only listed games i personally played and enjoyed on the psx, and know of on the ps2 (only played ffx). obviously there are the 2d ports and lesser titles and so on that i didnt list.
 
nitewulf said:
isnt radiata stories by atlus?
and parallax, i only listed games i personally played and enjoyed on the psx, and know of on the ps2 (only played ffx). obviously there are the 2d ports and lesser titles and so on that i didnt list.

Not by Atlus, and only published by SE...not developed
 
I thought Tri-Ace was part and parcel of Enix. They're located in SE headquarters anyway.

I would have given Musashi a 6.8 had the system allowed for it. Soz.
 
Kobun Heat said:
I thought Tri-Ace was part and parcel of Enix. They're located in SE headquarters anyway.

I would have given Musashi a 6.8 had the system allowed for it. Soz.

oh are they? if so then plain not by altus
 
They're also doing that saga frontier title this gen but it looks like a bomba... not ever picking up another of the Sage Titles again so no harm done.

UPCOMING PS2 HITS


KINGDOM FUCKING SELL YOUR HOUSE AND BUY THIS GAME HEARTS 2

FFXII - KICKER MY ASS

FF (VINCENT TITLE)


so good stuff is still to come. Pity they abandoned Vagrant Story (which I couldn't get into but was keen to) and Parasite EVE. :( They also have that Itakagi street title which will never see light of day in the west (dubious play quality of course) I never cared for MUSASHI so this review is no loss to me. As long as KH2 + FFXII kicks mucho asso. I'll love Squaresoft mucho.
 
Kobun Heat said:
I thought Tri-Ace was part and parcel of Enix. They're located in SE headquarters anyway.

I would have given Musashi a 6.8 had the system allowed for it. Soz.

6.8 is too low I think 7 is far more accurate. Actually 7.15 is probably the closest you could get to a representative score.
 
I consider my self a really big fan of BFM, but I played the demo and my heart deflated. Maybe my mind is still stuck on the last mission of BFM (assault on the Thirstquencher Fortress), but the demo was just so boring and slow and NOT FUN. I hope the full game is tons better, because that demo killed me.
 
Well, being a fan of the original, I thought I would go against the reviews and pick this up.

I have beaten the intro level and Chapter 1. My impressions so far are really positive. It really has the feel of the first game and is fun to play. I ran into some camera issues with the boss at the end of Chapter 1 and got really frustrated after I died about 6 times. I then decided to stand back and watch the bosses pattern and lo and behold I was able to finish him off with no problems with the camera or major health loss. The camera was screwed up when I ran in and just went toe to toe with the boss, but when I sat back and fought him the way the game intended (hit and run based on bosses pattern) there was no issue at all. The only ongoing problem I have had so far is that once you start an attack you cannot stop it, and so special moves take at least a few seconds to fully animate... If an enemy has already died and you wanna move on to the next guy, you are s.o.l. if you are in the last stages of some super combo. Oh... And while the voice acting is passable in general, Mushashi sounds like he was voiced by a mentally retarted 10 year old. It is painfully bad. The music is good over all and the character designs are really good, reminding me fondly of Breath of Fire Dragon Quarter.

I hope you guys give it a chance... It doesn't seem like a bad investment of $40 so far, and 2 hours in it is a lot of fun.
 
I would have given Musashi a 6.8 had the system allowed for it. Soz.

Your review is lame. You bring up the Surf Coasters' opening theme, but Hamauzu and Nakano, who composed the entire rest of the soundtrack, don't even get a mention? Hamauzu is one of the most remarkable composers working in game music or in any field for that matter, and any review of any game he's involved with should devote at least 70% of its space to praising him.
 
Top Bottom