Support NeoGAF

[Flying_Phoenix]

Allspark only has a third of the posts we do...

Trolling doesn't compromise that much of our post history.

 

[KtSlime]

Allspark only has a third of the posts we do...

Trolling doesn't compromise that much of our post history.

It really doesn't, we have around 100 members (people that have posted ~>20 times favorably) here.

 

[Neki]

Allspark only has a third of the posts we do...

Trolling doesn't compromise that much of our post history.

PonyGAF has a very enriching history, just browse through the pages here, and you'll find a story about love, despair, and redemption.

 

[Feep]

Man, did anyone see this? Wow.

Spoiler

GLaDOS-Pony

 

[Neki]

I didn't know this thread had friendly lurkers. I was only aware of the people who browsed this thread to get incriminating evidence (dream) or browsed it to ignore every single poster in here (forget his name, lol) or to troll us (Jenga)

 

[mj1108]

I stand corrected, this is the best rule. We'll either need this or to ban pandaman, which ever one is easier.

Agreed. We need 'The Creepy Rule' in here too. Keep that shit outta Ponyville.

Most of the posts in here are trolling and random spam and random pictures though. CAN'T WAIT FOR PONY OT2 THOUGH.

Amazing with the trolling that has happened that PonyGAF continues on. Every troll just makes PonyGAF stronger.

 

[Zucchi]

I'm a long time lurker of this thread!

Spoiler

and of gaf in general...

I actually used to watch the G1 show as a kid (I realize now most of the episodes were shit, but I still like a bunch of them for various reasons) My sisters and I have 100+ G1 ponies in our basement at home. So many memories... plus it's fun because I recognize almost all of the G1 references in the show.

I love what Lauren Faust has done with the MLP name. She's restored dignity, in a way. In any case, I'm a huge fan of the new show. Makes me feel like a kid again to be watching ponies I've been depressed lately too, so watching something as cheery as FiM is a welcomed distraction.

Keep up the good work, this thread is awesome. YAY PONIES

 

[RiccochetJ]

I didn't know this thread had friendly lurkers. I was only aware of the people who browsed this thread to get incriminating evidence (dream) or browsed it to ignore every single poster in here (forget his name, lol) or to troll us (Jenga)

Jenga is a closet brony. I kinda miss him.

 

[Boss Doggie]

No more human ponies or I'll squeeze the life out of you!

 

[Darte]

I suggest a compromise.
Regular pony images: OK
Humanized pony images: throw a link if you wanna share and spare the rest of us!

 

[Cday]

There's nothing wrong with human ponies as long as it isn't arbitrarily sexualized or edgy. It's called art.

 

[Boss Doggie]

You know how human characters are drawn as furries and are annoying? Yeah, same thing. =/

 

[Cday]

Considering we are humans and not ponies I don't see how it's comparable to the counterculture of furries.

 

[mj1108]

I suggest a compromise.
Regular pony images: OK
Humanized pony images: throw a link if you wanna share and spare the rest of us!

I think what we should do is set an example for Pony threads throughout the internet. PonyGAF has weathered troll storms and neighsayers (many which have turned into Bronies)....it's important for this thread to stay on track and not go down creepy highway.

My 2 cents.

(place brohoof here)

 

[Boss Doggie]

Considering we are humans and not ponies I don't see how it's comparable to the counterculture of furries.

I really don't care about the notion of "we are humans" and such - I just want to keep them as ponies, nothing else. Changing them has some sort of creep value in them already. And as someone said, it is reaching creep levels.

 

[akira28]

and if it's clever and chic, a little tongue in cheek or a nice tweak is welcome. But human Apple Jack, bursting forth from her field is much too much with far too little imagination involved. If it's more than mild, best leave it where you found it and flag it with a link(if you must).

 

[Darte]

and if it's clever and chic, a little tongue in cheek or a nice tweak is welcome. But human Apple Jack, bursting forth from her field is much too much with far too little imagination involved. If it's more than mild, best leave it where you found it and flag it with a link(if you must).

This, I don't have a problem with humanized ponies, its just people don't know where to draw the line between normal and creepy.

 

[Cday]

I really don't care about the notion of "we are humans" and such - I just want to keep them as ponies, nothing else. Changing them has some sort of creep value in them already. And as someone said, it is reaching creep levels.

The "creep value" lies within the intention of the artist. A lot of them are without creepy intentions and so there's nothing creepy about it.

 

[Choppasmith]

Whew! Put a lot of work into this, spent many a late nights, but it's done, and I'm really proud of it. My first real, full fledged, completely original, MAD-styled parody of the Avengers EMH Opening.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hYTGRRdDK3k

And for those who aren't too familiar with the show, here's the original for comparison
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxaJpUnF6xA

 

[Myke Greywolf]

This, I don't have a problem with humanized ponies, its just people don't know where to draw the line between normal and creepy.

It's not up to us to draw that line anyway, especially since it's so differently placed for each fan. Let's leave that task to someone who both cares and has the authority to do it, like duckroll.

But I do agree that full-size image embedding is becoming a little annoying. Links or reduced versions (at most imgur "M" size) are better for this thread's sanity.

 

[Aske]

Whew! Put a lot of work into this, spent many a late nights, but it's done, and I'm really proud of it. My first real, full fledged, completely original, MAD-styled parody of the Avengers EMH Opening.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hYTGRRdDK3k

And for those who aren't too familiar with the show, here's the original for comparison
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxaJpUnF6xA

Love it. I especially enjoyed what you did with Flutterhulk and Iron Sparkle. Awesome work!

 

[ZealousD]

Something that really works in our favor when gauging our community when compared to others is that we have some posters that post a LOT in this thread. G-Fex and Myke both have over 500 posts in this thread, taking about 5% of the thread for each of them.

So I wouldn't just judge based on post counts alone.

 

[Mechanical Snowman]

I really don't care about the notion of "we are humans" and such - I just want to keep them as ponies, nothing else. Changing them has some sort of creep value in them already. And as someone said, it is reaching creep levels.

Wasn't it you who said you're a furry? I'm a bit confused about why you're taking this stance. Maybe it creeps you out more because you're naturally drawing a link between human ponies and pornography that people with less exposure to furry images aren't likely to do.

Not trying to be a dick or condescending, by the way, I'm just confused by your hostility towards that kind of art.

 

[Boss Doggie]

Nah, I just find it weird in both ways (turning non-humans to humans and vice-versa).

 

[OMG Aero]

PonyGAF has an admirer on Reddit.

The "He" in the first sentence is referring to Jenga.

Hahaha. I love that people who aren't even on GAF are talking about Jenga when mentioning PonyGAF.

 

[Pandaman]

i suggest a compromise:
no compromises.
love and tolerance for all.
people are creeped out by men liking my little pony and most of us dislike that and ask for tolerance, yet those same pony lovers would not extend that tolerance to a group that they in turn find creepy.
y'all are basically Gilda, demanding a level of respect you would not grant to someone in a similar position to you.

 

[Regulus Tera]

Pandaman is the voice of reason for once.

 

[ZealousD]

Pandaman is the voice of reason for once.

Now there's a scary thought.

 

[Feep]

Hey, PonyGAF!

My game, Sequence, just released. You can click here for the official thread, or here to download the game directly to your Xbox.

As promised, here's the secret code:

Spoiler

Upon reaching the seventh floor, go to the Gear screen. Hold down the following buttons: D-Pad Left, A, Y, Left Trigger, and Right Bumper. Then, use your mouth or something to press the Right Analog Stick inward. You'll get your special PonyGAF item!

 

[SouthernDragon]

i suggest a compromise:
no compromises.
love and tolerance for all.
people are creeped out by men liking my little pony and most of us dislike that and ask for tolerance, yet those same pony lovers would not extend that tolerance to a group that they in turn find creepy.
y'all are basically Gilda, demanding a level of respect you would not grant to someone in a similar position to you.

When the intolerable position may lead to the destruction of the group, that position should be intolerable. Not all positions are equal.

 

[Dennis]

 

[Darte]

When the intolerable position may lead to the destruction of the group, that position should be intolerable. Not all positions are equal.

Sadly this is what I fear the most. If you frequented the previous incarnation of the "Pics that make you laugh" threads, then you'll understand my stance.

Just don't wanna see this thread locked D:


Edit: ^ needs PP in that gif!

 

[Myke Greywolf]

I'll help in any way possible. If anything I'll take the roll of Twilight as I'm not fantastic at Photoshop or .gifs or stuff of that nature. But I can sure type and edit like a mad man. Organization! Where's my multicolored vest?

OK, so here's my plan.

It will, of course, feature all the great OT staples:
- Custom graphic banner and section headers
- Introduction
- Thread rules
- Cultural context
- Character bios
- Episode list for both seasons (updated regularly)
- Merchandise information
- Avatars
- Wallpapers
- About the community
- Notable fan creations
- Reviews and testimonies
- Useful links

However, the centerpiece of the OP, and the way I plan to set it apart from what has been done before, would be a large comic starring our very own mascot, wandering through Equestria in "ghost" form (not seen or heard by any other character, since she, as a projection of our particular community, is not really part of that universe), and introducing to the reader the many locations of Equestria and its inhabitants... in song form. This comic would link to a video featuring the song itself, written in the spirit of the show, and with lyrics contributed by Pony-GAF members. A song I have already started composing (hence the musical notes I posted yesterday), and for which I have already found a very talented singer willing to do the vocals. The video would feature a semi-animated version of the comic itself, of course.

Talents needed:
- Designers for banners, headers and wallpapers
- Writers
- Link/content gatherers
- Avatar creators (I'm looking at you, Foxix and Nishastra)
- Comic artists (I can do this too, but I could use help)
- MIDI arrangers or musicians
- Animators (nothing too complex)
- Video editors

We have about six months to do this thing, if you think it's a good idea.

... Is this overkill?

 

[Feep]

I had 305 MS points just sitting around doing nothing on my account so I'll be putting it to use here. Definitely interested to see the PonyGAF extra you put in.

Thanks!

But I mean, it's just a little bonus. Don't expect too much.

 

[Ellis Kim]

I'm kind of interested in the comic... though why does she have to sing :x

Your proposal is ambitious, certainly, but I'd like to join in on the ride to help.

 

[Pancakes]

That's pretty ambitious, but I believe we can do it.

 

[Myke Greywolf]

I'm kind of interested in the comic... though why does she have to sing :x

Because Winter Wrap Up.

Seriously: IMHO, the songs are one of the great things about this show. I will drop it if people don't think it's appropriate, but I would really be happy if we went forward with it.

 

[Boss Doggie]

That's pretty ambitious, but I Belle Eve we can do it.

Fixed.

 

[DeadPhoenix]

... Is this overkill?

Sounds absolutely insane, but with the Magic of Friendship, truly no obstacle can stand in your way!

Seriously though in my experience attempting something like this(for me it was usually game making, fortunately your plans probably won't require quite as much work) with random people on an online forum is a bitch and a half, but fortunately you've already got a topic full of people who have been getting to know each other better for about 2~3 months(team building!), they all have some kind of emotional investment in this show, and probably even PonyGAF itself(less likely to lose interest), so really you're already ahead of the curve. I can't say much about the talent you have available here(I know there are at least a few people who can do pretty good music and videos), but you've got the entire brony culture out there with awesome people who could probably do a few jobs for you if you can't get everything you need from here.

Hmm that felt kinda weird typing that, so to awesome this post up, I present to you...
Dudududu du dududu
Venture Bronies

To many awesome videos, getting harder and harder to fight my urge to make my overly complicated Gargoyles x MLP crossover video idea.

 

[Mechanical Snowman]

I'm up for designing the header, I don't mind if others want to give it a shot as well.

I'm kind of interested in the comic... though why does she have to sing :x

Your proposal is ambitious, certainly, but I'd like to join in on the ride to help.

Haven't seen you in here before, welcome!

 

[Pandaman]

When the intolerable position may lead to the destruction of the group, that position should be intolerable. Not all positions are equal.

where have i heard this before?
oh right, in all the forums where ponies were banned and in all the posters that called for the ban of pony related avatars.

 

[Ellis Kim]

I'm up for designing the header, I don't mind if others want to give it a shot as well.


Haven't seen you in here before, welcome!

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=422909&page=11

lol

I dropped by again after going "lol wut" seeing Flying Phoenix's NeoGaf'd pony avatar.

I was disappointed by the recent Owl episode :S

 

[tiff]

I'm against a ban on humanized pics because I have a humanized Applejack sitting on my hard drive and I don't know what else to do with it.

It really doesn't, we have around 100 members (people that have posted ~>20 times favorably) here.

That's all it takes to be a member!?

 

[SouthernDragon]

where have i heard this before?
oh right, in all the forums where ponies were banned and in all the posters that called for the ban of pony related avatars.

I dunno, dude, PonyGAF wasn't, and isn't, going to cause GAF to a) ban itself from the net or b) destroy GAF from existence. Antics like posting increasingly inappropriate content would cause ponies, and PonyGAF to be prohibited from GAF, causing the destruction of the community.

Ponies do not violate the ToS GAF has, or the GAF rules the mods have set up. Inappropriate content, of any kind, does and gives them just cause to eliminate this thread. While some topics manage to resurrect themselves (pics that make you laugh, seductive women), they do that because the mods give some leeway and there's no sense of community in those threads. It's a drive-by phenomenon.

PonyGAF is different, because it's a real community with real discussions. However, inappropriate content for it exists (just like most other topics) and this content (in particular) can attract the ire of others.

Because of the irresponsible actions of one person, a lot of people can suffer.

Now, speaking directly to your tendencies, you can easily find other boards which can accomodate your preferences and let loose your inhibitions there. And that's cool, because you are free to like what you like and share that with others. It's just not cool here, because you'll be inconveniencing a lot of people with whom you share a community with.

tl;dr : Don't be selfish, we can't all do what we want all the time, realize that we give up some things so that everyone doesn't suffer.

 

[mazeedibeedi]

Whew! Put a lot of work into this, spent many a late nights, but it's done, and I'm really proud of it. My first real, full fledged, completely original, MAD-styled parody of the Avengers EMH Opening.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hYTGRRdDK3k

And for those who aren't too familiar with the show, here's the original for comparison
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxaJpUnF6xA

I love the extra details you put into the video. It's really faithful to the Avenger's intro. Also FlutterHulk is awesome.

 

[OMG Aero]

Hey, PonyGAF!

My game, Sequence, just released. You can click here for the official thread, or here to download the game directly to your Xbox.

As promised, here's the secret code:

Spoiler

Upon reaching the seventh floor, go to the Gear screen. Hold down the following buttons: D-Pad Left, A, Y, Left Trigger, and Right Bumper. Then, use your mouth or something to press the Right Analog Stick inward. You'll get your special PonyGAF item!

After playing through the trial, this just became the second Xbox Indie game I've bought. I don't play a lot of Indie games but the production values and voice acting quality of this one really surprised me.

Talents needed:
- Designers for banners, headers and wallpapers
- Writers
- Link/content gatherers
- Avatar creators (I'm looking at you, Foxix and Nishastra)
- Comic artists (I can do this too, but I could use help)
- MIDI arrangers or musicians
- Animators (nothing too complex)
- Video editors

We have about six months to do this thing, if you think it's a good idea.

... Is this overkill?

If I'm honest I think the song is kinda overkill. I would like to help you out with the design, animation and maybe art stuff though.

 

[McNum]

That Season 2 OP sounds ridiculously overkill. Awesome! I know I made a few testimonials in this thread already, so if you want to use either, go right ahead. I'm not much of an artist, but if you need to offload some writing, like episode summaries, pony bios or similar then go ahead and PM me.

Did you think of the style of the OP? Straightforward? Tongue-in-cheek? Over-the-top friendly? Spoken by Belle Eve? (Great name, by the way.)

 

[Myke Greywolf]

Whew! Put a lot of work into this, spent many a late nights, but it's done, and I'm really proud of it. My first real, full fledged, completely original, MAD-styled parody of the Avengers EMH Opening.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hYTGRRdDK3k

And for those who aren't too familiar with the show, here's the original for comparison
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xxaJpUnF6xA

Just watched this. Liked, favorited, imprinted permanently into memory. Excellent work!

 

[Nishastra]

Talents needed:
- Designers for banners, headers and wallpapers
- Writers
- Link/content gatherers
- Avatar creators (I'm looking at you, Foxix and Nishastra)
- Comic artists (I can do this too, but I could use help)
- MIDI arrangers or musicians
- Animators (nothing too complex)
- Video editors

We have about six months to do this thing, if you think it's a good idea.

... Is this overkill?

This whole thing sounds vaguely insane, but I'm gonna keep making new avatars regardless, so I guess you can say I'll be available for that

 

[mazeedibeedi]

Talents needed:
- Designers for banners, headers and wallpapers
- Writers
- Link/content gatherers
- Avatar creators (I'm looking at you, Foxix and Nishastra)
- Comic artists (I can do this too, but I could use help)
- MIDI arrangers or musicians
- Animators (nothing too complex)
- Video editors

We have about six months to do this thing, if you think it's a good idea.

... Is this overkill?

It kinda is, but if we want to make a Mega-thread then the more the merrier.
I have a suggestion, what if we make an introductory video in the OP to those who are new to MLP, with voice-overs etc. I can provide some voices for it (putting my only talent to use).

I just found out that Edgar Wright included my video in his blog, and I found myself having a Rainbow Dash moment: Ohmygoshohmygoshohmygoshohmygosh!

Congrats. You really deserved it.