Support NeoGAF

[Screaming Meat]

He's also an ex-Scientologist. Or maybe still a sort of Scientologist? It's not clear.

When he was a kid. His Dad was a spokesperson for the Church.

 

[hugocésar]

Moore is undoubtably more impactful, but Gaiman is the most consistent writer when it comes to quality. I Could care less about Miller. (Brubaker has been my favorite for the past couple of years.)

 

[Platy]

This guy:

OP didn't ask who would be a better Dungeun Master.

That being said, Gaiman would probably beat Moore by very little because he usualy do open mic poetry stuff. But Moore would bring the better drugs to use during tabletop fun

 

[ElBoxyBrown]

Allan Moore had the biggest positive impact on comics.
Miller had the biggest negative impact on comics.

But Gaiman is my favorite.

I wouldn't call it positive considering every writer that tried to copy Moore and Miller's style ended up making some of the most edgy tryhard comics.

 

[d00d3n]

OP didn't ask who would be a better Dungeun Master.

That being said, Gaiman would probably beat Moore by very little because he usualy do open mic poetry stuff. But Moore would bring the better drugs to use during tabletop fun

Well, that's your opinion. I stand with corporate Alan Moore!

 

[Corpsepyre]

Neil and Alan are great writers. Alan's written my favourite comic of all time. However, Grant is in a very, very different league. There's really no other writer like him.

 

[suffah]

I grew up with frank miller comics so biased. Too bad he's lost his mind nowadays.

Luckily my LCS pushed sandman/death etc on me back when Vertigo/indie stuff started to gain momentum (early 90s?) Enjoy and read every novel Gaiman writes.

But I think Moore Is superior when it comes to comics. Completely agree with the previous poster.

 

[EGM1966]

Moore.

Still like Gaiman a lot and quite like some of Miller's stuff but Moore is GOAT status in the medium.

 

[……forgetit]

Alan Moore

I still haven't gotten to Gaiman's stuff and Frank Miller is a crazy person.

 

[Platy]

Alan Moore

I still haven't gotten to Gaiman's stuff and Frank Miller is a crazy person.

Sandman.

NOW

 

[OniBarubary]

Warren Ellis.