SO
I go back to gamestop to pick up the case/manual for Atelier Rorona.
They hand me a new copy of Atelier Totori (the sequel).
You know what? Fuck it. I'm okay with this.
Awesome deal. On top of that if you just go into a store that has Atelier Rorona used and tell them what happened to you, they will let you take the case, cover art and manual for your game. That way you will have a complete Atelier Rorona too!