• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NFL 2012 Week 4 |OT| Dewey Beats Truman

eznark

Banned
3 wins by a combined 4 points. Eagles are looking at a serious reckoning in the coming weeks.

Collinsworth is so fucking biased it aint even funny. Dude strait mugged Nnamdi on that PI call.

Apparently you also missed him bitching about the DPI called previously?
 

Brinbe

Member
Yeah, good game, Giants-Age... Y'all are classy as always. Wouldn't have been surprised if we lost, it was that close. The 2nd meeting at the Meadowlands will surely be just as dramatic, it always is.
 

MKAllDay

Member
Ugh, Barden really fucked the game with his OPI. Fuck.

Any Giants fan that tries to put this on Barden is just dumb. He did the only thing he could there, the alternative was letting Nnamdi pick off his quarterback for making a terrible throw/decision. So you either end the game right there or keep the drive alive and lose 10 yards. Your choice.
 
The fuck, how is there debate on that offensive PI? It's clear on the replay


There's more debate on the defensive PI
Namdi bodyblocked Barden out of bounds. Barden put his hands on Namdi to try and move him out of the way. While bot are guilty, Nnamdi initiated it, which is why it's debatable to why they only called it on Barden.
Then make it an out route. With 15 sconds left, a 54 yard FG is insane IMO
And Nnamdi would've sat on it. Eagles CBs aren't dumb.
 
Top Bottom