Support NeoGAF

[Kurosaki Ichigo]

[Wii] 520K
[DS] 395K
[360] 385K
[PSP] 330K
[PS2] 225K
[PS3] 135K
[GBA] 72K
[GCN] 7K

 

[Phoenix 2.0]

[Wii] 550k
[DS] 450k
[360] 395k
[PS2] 245k
[PSP] 230k
[PS3] 125k
[GBA] 75k
[GCN] 8k

Haven't done this before.

 

[Weisheit]

[Wii] 515k
[DS] 450k
[360] 495k
[PS2] 255k
[PSP] 230k
[PS3] 135k
[GBA] 75k

 

[stalker]

[360] 469,000
[GBA] 90,000
[NDS] 600,000
[PS2] 250,000
[PS3] 140,000
[PSP] 290,000
[WII] 500,000

 

[titiklabingapat]

I wonder what kind of barometer people will use with the 360+Halo vs Wii+Wii Sports angle when the latest NPD numbers get posted.

If the 360 failed to outsell the Wii but came very close, will that be considered a failure? What if it only outsold the Wii by the same razor thin margin? Does it need to do a home run? What's the GAf consensus on this thing?

 

[Haunted]

[GBA] 75k
[PS3] 145k
[PS2] 250k
[PSP] 285k
[360] 425k
[NDS] 475k
[Wii] 510k

I wonder what kind of barometer people will use with the 360+Halo vs Wii+Wii Sports angle when the latest NPD numbers get posted.

If the 360 failed to outsell the Wii but came very close, will that be considered a failure? What if it only outsold the Wii by the same razor thin margin? Does it need to do a home run? What's the GAf consensus on this thing?

Anything over 400k would be great for the 360.

 

[titiklabingapat]

[GBA] 75k
[PS3] 145k
[PS2] 250k
[PSP] 285k
[360] 425k
[NDS] 475k
[Wii] 510k



Anything over 400k would be great for the 360.

Why must everyone be so cruel to Odysseus. I never knew everyone on GAF loved Pepsiman that much :lol

 

[Sho Nuff]

WTF is the matter with you people

 

[Frankfurter]

[Wii] 480k
[NDS] 475k
[360] 380k
[PS2] 280k
[PSP] 240k
[PS3] 145k
[GBA] 75k

 

[Kosma]

WTF is the matter with you people

Explain yourself.

 

[sdlang]

Why dosn't everyone just copy VG Chartz or The simExchange's data? The simExchange actually has their predictions up, months in advance.
I am going to play it save and stick around their numbers. They seem to be more accurate then most other places.

The simExchange's September Predictions

[360] 423,000
[GBA] 80,000
[NDS] 501,000
[PS2] 245,000
[PS3] 162,000
[PSP] 284,000
[WII] 486,000

P.S. No way the 360 outsells the Wii. That thing cannot be stopped!

 

[Beer Monkey]

[Wii] 490K
[360] 500K
[NDS] 430K
[PSP] 290K
[PS2] 192K
[PS3] 141K
[GBA] 72K


I think Wii got more units into the channel than in recent months. 360 I think will get a bigger bump from Halo and the new SKU than conventional wisdom dictates. My guess may be high but I honestly think it will be closer than Odysseus.

 

[Jube3]

[360] 480k
[Wii] 380k
[DS] 420k
[PSP] 305k
[PS2] 190k
[PS3] 140k
[GBA] 60k

 

[Des0lar]

[360] 380k
[Wii] 320k
[DS] 350k
[PSP] 250k
[PS2] 180k
[PS3] 130k
[GBA] 60k

 

[Cruceh]

[360] 400,000
[NDS] 400,000
[WII] 350,000
[PS2] 200,000
[PSP] 170,000
[PS3] 140,000
[GBA] 60,000
[GCN] 5,000

 

[Provider]

[WII] 490k
[360] 430k
[NDS] 440k
[PSP] 270k
[PS2] 230k
[PS3] 160k
[GBA] 60k

 

[Xeke]

[Wii] 500k
[NDS] 490k
[360] 400k
[PS2] 235k
[PSP] 260k
[PS3] 140k
[GBA] 80k

 

[Brakara]

[Wii] 495K
[NDS] 475K
[360] 395K
[PSP] 275K
[PS2] 225K
[PS3] 140K
[GBA] 75K

Edit: some slight modifications (having second thoughts). Slight increase for NDS, and a slight decrease for PS3. Also decreased PSP numbers by 50k (don't think there was any game to push PSPs this month, unlike Japan).

 

[chadums90]

[360] 400,000
[WII] 385,000
[NDS] 375,000
[PSP] 250,000
[PS2] 200,000
[PS3] 150,000
[GBA] 50,000

 

[AdventureRacing]

[Wii] 520K
[360] 450K
[NDS] 430K
[PSP] 272K
[PS2] 231K
[PS3] 131K
[GBA] 62K

This is definitely the most interesting NPD in a long time.

 

[Amir0x]

[Wii] 490,000
[360] 375,000
[PS3] 9,833
[NDS] 470,000
[PS2] 225,000
[PSP] 255,000
[GBA] 9,800

 

[tebunker]

[360] 475,000
[GBA] 79,000
[NDS] 501,000
[PS2] 237,000
[PS3] 171,000
[PSP] 297,000
[WII] 502,000



First time I've ever done a prediction. I only say the Wii still outsells the 360 because NOA can't keep em on the damned shelves.

 

[_Alkaline_]

[360] 457K
[GBA] 72K
[NDS] 419K
[PS2] 214K
[PS3] 154K
[PSP] 273k
[WII] 431K

 

[Brak]

[Wii] 515K
[NDS] 450K
[360] 390K
[PSP] 280K
[PS2] 200K
[PS3] 120K
[GBA] 75K

 

[turtle553]

[360] 420k
[GBA] 69k
[NDS] 380k
[PS2] 210k
[PS3] 184k
[PSP] 290k
[WII] 412k

 

[D3MO]

[360] 250,000
[GBA] 50,000
[NDS] 500,000
[PS2] 200,000
[PS3] 185,000
[PSP] 200,000
[WII] 500,000

 

[BishopLamont]

Everyones sub 300k PSP makes me weep, I think I'm far offbase with 390k. :lol
Can I change my prediction or is it that not allowed?

[Wii] 490,000
[360] 375,000
[PS3] 9,833
[NDS] 470,000
[PS2] 225,000
[PSP] 255,000
[GBA] 9,800

NPD dude, not MC.

 

[TJ Bennett]

[NDS] 467K
[Wii] 453K
[360] 421K
[PSP] 255K
[PS2] 222K
[PS3] 133K
[GBA] 82K

This is my first stab at the NPD.

 

[Maxwell House]

How long is Odysseus's ban going to be? Was it a 1 month thingy?

 

[FieryBalrog]

[360] 420K
[GBA] 84K
[NDS] 460K
[PS2] 230K
[PS3] 160K
[PSP] 280k
[WII] 470K

Never done this before.

 

[Sindou_Hikaru20]

[NDS] 440K
[Wii] 430K
[360] 430K
[PSP] 255K
[PS2] 215K
[PS3] 150K
[GBA] 75K

 

[donny2112]

Can I change my prediction or is it that not allowed?

You can change it as much as you want until the parser runs on Wednesday.

 

[Michan]

[NDS] 530,000
[WII] 500,000
[360] 430,000
[PSP] 360,000
[PS2] 200,000
[PS3] 145,000
[GBA] 80,000
[GCN] 6,000
[XBX] 0

 

[jrricky]

[Wii] 470K
[NDS] 430K
[X360] 400K
[PSP] 300K
[PS2] 210K
[PS3] 150K
[GBA] 90K

I think 360 got a big boost this month. Im surprised it sold out in my store.

 

[Odysseus]

How long is Odysseus's ban going to be? Was it a 1 month thingy?

a little presumptuous, aren't we? if memory serves correctly, the bet was set so that it would not interfere with sales-age. in that case, green shinobi's ban would be for four weeks. i'll look it up to be sure.

edit: i guess it's for a month, after all. http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=7927730&postcount=163

 

[INTERNET]

[360] 480K
[GBA] 70K
[NDS] 420K
[PS2] 170K
[PS3] 100K
[PSP] 180K
[WII] 400K

 

[donny2112]

Why dosn't everyone just copy VG Chartz or The simExchange's data? The simExchange actually has their predictions up, months in advance.
I am going to play it save and stick around their numbers. They seem to be more accurate then most other places.

The simExchange's numbers are comparable to the aggregate that Cheesemeister posts of our predictions, since they are both community derived. The other place's numbers are a bannable offense to knowingly post here.

P.S. "safe"

 

[sdlang]

The simExchange's numbers are comparable to the aggregate that Cheesemeister posts of our predictions, since they are both community derived. The other place's numbers are a bannable offense to knowingly post here.

P.S. "safe"

Gotcha.. Sorry about that. But I think you are crazy to think that people don't check them before making their own predictions here. After all, there estimates are out months in advance.

 

[goldenpp72]

Does ody really have to get banned? Would be lame.

Anyways i'll pass on predictions this month as I have no clue.

 

[sdlang]

sorry about my post in the september npd threat. didnt meant to break the rules.

 

[BishopLamont]

SimsExchnage says SMG will sell 17M, wtf?

Edit: NVM they're worldwide sales.

 

[Sho_Nuff82]

I wonder what kind of barometer people will use with the 360+Halo vs Wii+Wii Sports angle when the latest NPD numbers get posted.

If the 360 failed to outsell the Wii but came very close, will that be considered a failure? What if it only outsold the Wii by the same razor thin margin? Does it need to do a home run? What's the GAf consensus on this thing?

I think anything over 400k would make Reggie look stupid, and that's all we really ask.


[360] 420k
[GBA] 85k
[NDS] 450k
[PS2] 235k
[PS3] 145k
[PSP] 480k BELIEVE
[WII] 490k

Software that matters

360 HALO 3 2500k
360 HALO 3 LIMITED EDITION 600k
360 HALO 3 LEGENDARY EDITION 400k (bomba)

DS LEGEND OF ZELDA PHANTOM HOURGLASS 350k
360 MADDEN NFL 08 310k
WII PLAY W/ REMOTE 300K

PS3 Heavenly Sword 275k
PS2 MADDEN NFL 08 250K
360 BIOSHOCK 225K (Lost? To inferior beings?)

WII CARNIVAL GAMES 200k
WII METROID PRIME 3: CORRUPTION 200K (bomba)
360 STRANGLEHOLD 175k (bomba)

PS3 MADDEN NFL 08 150K
360 SKATE 150k
WII MY SIMS 125k

PS2 GUITAR HERO 2 W/GUITAR 125K
PS2 GUITAR HERO ENCORE: ROCKS THE 80S 100K
PS3 LAIR 100k

PS3 WARHAWK w/BLUETOOTH HEADSET 90k
360 ETERNAL SONATA 85k (BOMBA)
WII DDR HOTTEST PARTY 50k

 

[AniHawk]

[PS3] 9,833

You forgot a zero.

 

[titiklabingapat]

I think anything over 400k would make Reggie look stupid, and that's all we really ask.


[360] 420k
[GBA] 85k
[NDS] 450k
[PS2] 235k
[PS3] 145k
[PSP] 480k BELIEVE
[WII] 490k

I never did get this Reggie-halo3-fool thing. It was obvious that it was hyporbole. Halo 3 will move consoles, of course. Almost every game does. Somewhere, someone will buy a console for one game, no matter how shitty.

It was obvious that Reggie meant that Halo 3 won't matter (that much) in the overall and long term console war, especially the Wii VS. 360 battle in NA.

 

[JoshuaJSlone]

Why dosn't everyone just copy VG Chartz or The simExchange's data?

******** would be more accurate using the GAF aggregate.

[PS3] 9,833
[GBA] 9,800

:lol I'd think you left off a 0 if not for the commas.

You forgot a zero.

09,833?

 

[Windu]

[360] 370k
[GBA] 60k
[NDS] 550k
[PS2] 210k
[PS3] 150k
[PSP] 345k
[WII] 410k

 

[kefka2030]

[WII] 453,000
[NDS] 446,000
[360] 384,000
[PSP] 261,000
[PS2] 226,000
[PS3] 137,000
[GBA] 73,000

 

[ThirdEye]

What will happen when Wii, DS > 360?

 

[GhaleonEB]

What will happen when Wii, DS > 360?

The usual?

 

[BuzzJive]

[360] 412k
[GBA] 82k
[NDS] 465k
[PS2] 227k
[PS3] 149k
[PSP] 266k
[WII] 466k