Shard said:
Xbox Live Arcade
My, my, my, my, what a turbulent couple of months it has been for the XBLA. Indeed, the bad news has been flowing like rancid wine for a few months now, size cap issues, royalty rate cuts, the recent delisting snafu. Indeed the XBLA has seen some major failings due to the absolutely asinine policy choices of those in charge of the service, yet, in spite this maelstrom of stupidity the XBLA, one thing has thus far remained unaffected and that is top-rate content for the service. Oh sure, it has gotten a fair bit of shovelware (Discs of Tron, Wits and Wagers, Bliss Island, Battlezone, et al) but overall we have been graced with the likes of Rez HD, Ikaruga, N+, Poker Smash, ect, ect. Moreover, we got a nice preview of the XNA Initiative, the size cap issue has actually been resolved, not as much as Neo GAF would like, but all things considered, we are lucky to get even a size increase. Kudos are also appended to the XBLA for still having good worldwide distribution system, one submission and a publisher is good to go around the world, slight marks off for treating the Asian sector (Korea, Japan) like second-class areas though. Excellent third party support at this point in time with new games being announced or uncovered almost daily. Bonus marks for finally expanding first party development beyond Carbonated Games and expanding the Arcade Hits programs, yet more could be done in this area (more price drops, week-long price drop/free game promotions). DLC Expansion Packs have been steady but honestly unremarkable. Finally, Microsoft has pledge to fix the broken DRM issue. but that is supposed to occur later this month if it happens at all, so tha has to be left out of the grading issue one way or the other.
Final mid-term grade: B-
Real good breakdown, covered most of the points it looks like. I do think the DLC expansion for Pinball FX have been pretty good though. They came out with a free one, and then one they charged for (I didn't buy it...yet).
There's one thing that you didn't address...mainly
because it shouldn't need to be addressed, but there still exists a pre-conception regarding original vs. arcade ports on the system, and though much of it comes from fanboys who dislike anything MS at the moment, such a view would be well founded if you followed Live for the first year, and didn't bother checking it out for the last 1 and a half years, and I know some who are like that (anecdotal evidence, I know). The current release balance between original vs. arcade content is a very good balance and anyone checking out new releases would see this.
We are also seeing a lot more original content that serves niche tastes (ie more shooters, original puzzle/card games, attempts at children games in the form of Shrek and Spongebob). Though the quality of some (especially the latter mentioned) is questionable, I'm glad that these niches are being filled.
The only thing I thought you missed is the lack of high quality AAA Arcade games released during the last year. NBA Jam is one of the biggest arcade games of all time in terms of revenue, even beating out Pac Man as the top earner. Yet it's not on the system. 4P support, Live play, it's the ultimate candidate for Live, yet we don't see it. Yes, this is completely up to Acclaim (who got the rights for NBA Jam off of Midway IIRC), and perhaps there are some licensing issues...but to me this game makes a lot of sense, like TMNT, which has sold well it seems. Maybe MS should push for it?
I think there should be some debate in regards to the old, old skool arcade games, versus the mid to late 90's Arcade games. XBLA has done an EXCELLENT job of capturing the "
Golden Age of Arcade Games", but I would argue that Street Fighter, Mortal Kombat, NBA Jam, are more relevant to the perhaps largest 360 demographic of 20-30 year olds.
Personally, when I think "popular arcade titles"...I think of games like Tekken, Rave Racer, Virtua Fighter, Daytona, SEGA Rally from Namco and SEGA. I'm not even asking for those as I understand the technical hurdles involved (an ideal port would emulate the Model series of arcade boards at high res, include online play support, and leaderboard support). I'm not even asking for those, I just want the last series of 2D games that died in the late 90's. Which to me shouldn't be that bad since they are already emulated on PCs.
Sorry to respond to your well thought out and succinct post with these ramblings...