• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

One Bullet that changes the course of history

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nerevar

they call me "Man Gravy".
Himuro said:
You've never heard that theory?

the "theory" is mostly bandied about in conservative groups as a way to further slander the gay community (i.e. it came from a sexual deviant who had sex with monkeys, therefore he also must have just LOVED gay sex). It has virtually no scientific support.
 

Boogie

Member
Interesting thread, ignoring all the Christianity hate.

Thinking about this thread seriously is a tough one. Hitler is an obvious choice.

But I think I'd go with whoever it was who said to off Lenin sometime before he returned to Russia.

Kill Lenin, and the the October Revolution probably doesn't happen. Russia doesn't go commie, and instead proceeds (hopefully) along fairly democratic lines. Stalin doesn't come to power to kill those 20+ million people.

The post-WWI peace settlement would have been similar, but the inclusion of Russia in the League of Nations would have helped its legitimacy.

Although Russia probably wouldn't have been as industrialized as under Stalin, it wouldn't be viewed with such suspicion by the West, and as Hitler rises to power, it might have been easier for Britain, France, and Russia to join together to make Hitler back down, and WWII might not have happened.
 

demon

I don't mean to alarm you but you have dogs on your face
All you stupids are choosing people born before yourselves......you do realize that if you changed history in any significant way, you wouldn't be born, right? But then, how could you go back in time and pull the trigger in the first place? Would you just disappear as soon as you shoot your victim? Or would it create another timeline in another dimension like in Back to the Future?
 

Boogie

Member
demon said:
All you stupids are choosing people born before yourselves......you do realize that if you changed history in any significant way, you wouldn't be born, right? But then, how could you go back in time and pull the trigger in the first place? Would you just disappear as soon as you shoot your victim? Or would it create another timeline in another dimension like in Back to the Future?

I don't think we're supposed to think about that for this thread ;P
 

human5892

Queen of Denmark
Attempting to alter large, significant historical occurances with one bullet would not work, because you're only destroying the opportunist, not the catalyst; for example, with no Hitler, someone else would've seen the opportunity to lead Germany at its most vulnerable. Kill Edison, and eventually, someone else with the capacity for invention would recognize the need for better communication. History usually doesn't happen because of people, but because of events and circumstances. By killing someone like Hitler, the best you could hope for is someone less diabolical to fill the void that his death would create.

Smaller-scale assasinations, on the other hand, would work better; killing someone like Mark David Chapman would've almost certainly enabled Lennon to live for at least several more years barring a freak circumstance (like Chapman was in the first place). It depends on the context, though; someone like Notorious B.I.G. would probably have died from a different assasin even if you killed his first murderer simply because of the feud going on at the time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom