• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Person listed as 'black girl' in high school yearbook

Status
Not open for further replies.

mrklaw

MrArseFace
MIMIC said:
How does it not make any sense?

African-American = a person of African-heritage who was born in the United States

Like Chinese-American, Japanese-American, so on and so forth.


But surely people simply use it as a politically correct version of 'black guy', without thought as to the actual heritage of the person involved, therefore rendering it as stereotypical as previous terms?
 

mrklaw

MrArseFace
anglo-american.

Or viking-american (hey, us brits are basically either vikings or celts, right?)

Where does heritage stop anyway? Great-grandparents? further back?

If you go too far back, the whole of the USA are African-Americans.
 

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
MIMIC said:
Caucasian?

but isn't that any white person any where in the world? I look at being called black a way to describe me... I look at African American a way to make me different than other Americans.. just my way of thinking... not saying its correct...
 

MIMIC

Banned
Blackace said:
but isn't that any white person any where in the world? I look at being called black a way to describe me... I look at African American a way to make me different than other Americans.. just my way of thinking... not saying its correct...

I don't mind being called either because I don't see the latter form as a way of singling me out. I mean, all Americans aren't black, so either phrase are potential ways to distinguish....unless a person is simply called an "American
 

KarishBHR

Member
Im on yearbook staff at my school... and we do that shit all the time. We just never leave it in there for the final draft
 

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
MIMIC said:
I don't mind being called either because I don't see the latter form as a way of singling me out. I mean, all Americans aren't black, so either phrase is meant to distinguish...unless a person is simply called an "American."

Well being mixed as I am, I would rather be called black just because of the shade of my skin. Also, people of other races are calling me that anyways..just get out in the open...

I am often called just an American here in Japan and that suits me well... if there is more than one American and people ask which one... the black one.. hahah works for me
 

snaildog

Member
Loki said:
Well now that just takes care of those 350 years of oppression, now, doesn't it? </sarcasm>

God I hate this argument. Aren't the people who were oppressed dead? I don't see why their descendants should reap the benefits (talking about scholarships, not wangs).
 

DarienA

The black man everyone at Activision can agree on
MIMIC said:
How does it not make any sense?

African-American = a person of African-heritage who was born in the United States

Like Chinese-American, Japanese-American, so on and so forth.

Define African heritage... how much of a % of African-heritage do you have to have to be considered African American BTW?
 

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
KarishBHR said:
Im on yearbook staff at my school... and we do that shit all the time. We just never leave it in there for the final draft

do you do stuff like "Da Black Gurl!" or "AznPr1DeGuy"?
 

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
snaildog said:
God I hate this argument. Aren't the people who were oppressed dead? I don't see why their descendants should reap the benefits (talking about scholarships, not wangs).

well 350 years is a long time.. and Blacks have not been free that long.. just to put it in prespective. My father is the Son of slaves... well former slaves, but they were slaves for a bit..
 
snaildog said:
God I hate this argument. Aren't the people who were oppressed dead? I don't see why their descendants should reap the benefits (talking about scholarships, not wangs).

According to the Bible the Jewish tribes were slaves of Egypt, so in the end all of us were slaves (except fot he egyptions).
 

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
DarienA said:
Define African heritage... how much of a % of African-heritage do you have to have to be considered African American BTW?

African heritage is well people from Africa DUH! There is only one culture there didn't you know that...dude... :lol
 

MIMIC

Banned
Blackace said:
Well being mixed as I am, I would rather be called black just because of the shade of my skin. Also, people of other races are calling me that anyways..just get out in the open...

I can see how you might feel like that. I'm not mixed and either suits me just fine (although I use "black(s)" more often than I do "African American(s)")
 

Desperado

Member
Tommie Hu$tle said:
I agree with you. Blak is not a negative term stop acting like it is. Maybe jus MAYBE the did do it as a place holder.

Blacky however is not acceptable.


The problem in this incedent is that this went to print. It show a subtle negative intent due to the fact that the ENTIRE yearbook staff couldn't be bother to name one person in the Society, who by the way happened to be black. Well at least the girl is in the Honor Society. That will get her a chance to get the fuck out of Texas. The teacher who is the editor should have picked up on that.

the entire yearbook staff does not go through each page for errors.

and anyway, HS yearbook editors blow chunks, generally.
 

DarienA

The black man everyone at Activision can agree on
snaildog said:
God I hate this argument. Aren't the people who were oppressed dead? I don't see why their descendants should reap the benefits (talking about scholarships, not wangs).

Yup cause all blacks have it made today thanks to scholarships!

Blackace said:
African heritage is well people from Africa DUH! There is only one culture there didn't you know that...dude... :lol

Thank you blackace. ;) Your humorous comment is exactly what I mean...

Here's a few definitions I've seen:

1. All persons having origins in any of the Black racial groups of Africa
2. African Americans, also known as Afro-Americans or Black Americans, are an ethnic group in the United States of America whose ancestors, usually in predominant part, were indigenous to Sub-Saharan and West Africa. The majority of African Americans are of African, and (usually) Native American ancestry. Many African Americans also have European ancestors.

Now... if I apply #1 then why the f*ck go through the whole African American lable? If you have origins in the black racial groups of Africa... you're black. #2 is more interesting though because it goes in to specific WHERE in Africa your ancestors had to live to be considered are African...

How many f'n black people today who can trace back their ancestry(I can!) in this country know where in Africa there ancestors came from?

I'm Black... I don't need the politically correct "uplifting" phrase African American. I'm a proud black man, living in a crazy white mans' world... amen. ;)


None of this really touches on the biggest problem I have with this story.... there is no way in hell this girl could be Black... she's on the Honor Society for chrissakes! <rimshot>

This is a shoutout to all my other Blacks who made the Honor Roll, took AP classes in high school, etc...... we showed em boyee!!!
 

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
DarienA said:
None of this really touches on the biggest problem I have with this story.... there is no way in hell this girl could be Black... she's on the Honor Society for chrissakes! <rimshot>!!


YA heard!!! :lol
 

mrklaw

MrArseFace
Do you think black people will go through a whole deep politically sensitive phase jumping on anyone who says the 'wrong' thing? Then slowly revert to accepting phrases like 'black guy' or 'he's black'?
 

DarienA

The black man everyone at Activision can agree on
mrklaw said:
Do you think black people will go through a whole deep politically sensitive phase jumping on anyone who says the 'wrong' thing? Then slowly revert to accepting phrases like 'black guy' or 'he's black'?

We already did... that's where this dumb ass(IMO) African American term came from.

Interesting read of our progress from Negro, through Afro-American(which IMO is even worse than African-American), to today's African-American all in search of a strong identity....

http://www.africultures.com/anglais/articles_anglais/41cremieux.htm
 

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
mrklaw said:
Do you think black people will go through a whole deep politically sensitive phase jumping on anyone who says the 'wrong' thing? Then slowly revert to accepting phrases like 'black guy' or 'he's black'?

Do you think the (mostly white) media will shove every PC term on the people teaching that if they say any other term it is racist?
 

MIMIC

Banned
And BTW, "African-American" isn't considered the PC-alternative anymore (at least in the media). People say 'blacks' in the news all the time.
 

Scrow

Still Tagged Accordingly
Desperado said:
if it said "fat girl," maybe there'd be a problem.
meh, if you're fat... you're fat. whether you take offence to being called fat is your own problem. i'm so sick of all the PC shit.

fat person: "am i fat?"
other person: "uh... no. you're just big boned."
honest person: "don't be a wanker man. yes, you're fat."

edit:
catfish said:
If it were true then I think spades should be named as such!
okay, you just said what i wanted to say, but more succinctly. :)

galeninjapan said:
According to the Bible the Jewish tribes were slaves of Egypt, so in the end all of us were slaves (except fot he egyptions).
pfft, when did the bible ever get anything right.... oops.
 

mrklaw

MrArseFace
Blackace said:
Do you think the (mostly white) media will shove every PC term on the people teaching that if they say any other term it is racist?

heh, just re-read what I wrote. I guess white people (yes me!) are as/more guilty of being over-sensitive about stuff?
 
mrklaw said:
anglo-american.

Or viking-american (hey, us brits are basically either vikings or celts, right?)

Where does heritage stop anyway? Great-grandparents? further back?

If you go too far back, the whole of the USA are African-Americans.

Brits are mostly a mixed group all around. Celts are the main original population.

Vikings had numerous incursions and settlements, but their impact is more symbolic than real. It was also greatly glamorized during and after the Victorian era. DNA test show there is no great concentration of Danish and Norwegian DNA, except in a few areas in Wales and the Northern tip of England.

Saxons, another germanic group, had more of an impact all around.

The French and Romans also made a large contribution to the genetic and linguistic profile of Brits.
 

DarienA

The black man everyone at Activision can agree on
f*ck the dumb shit I'm Viking-American from now on. Henceforth I shall be known as Darien the Sour after my ancestors Ragnar the Dour, Hyglak the Quarrelsome and Haltaf the Boy(they ran out of good nicknames for poor Haltaf).

I mean come on who wouldn't want to be related to folks name:

Herger the Joyous, Edgtho the Silent, Ragnar the Dour, Helfdane the Fat, Rethel the Archer, Haltaf the Boy, Halga the Wise, Skeld the Superstitious, Weath the Musician or Hyglak the Quarrelsome?
 

karasu

Member
snaildog said:
God I hate this argument. Aren't the people who were oppressed dead? I don't see why their descendants should reap the benefits (talking about scholarships, not wangs).


My mom was opressed, my grandmom was opressed, my uncles were opressed, my aunts were opressed too. Opression didn't end with slavery dear fellow.Things are much better now, but we're playing a game of catch up here. We aren't on equal ground.

I'm Black... I don't need the politically correct "uplifting" phrase African American.

Maybe you don't need uplifting, but others did and still do. I can't believe people are finding fault with a group wanting to define THEMSELVES as oppossed to being defined by the people who felt nothing but contempt for them! In many ways the defiance that drove people to call themselves "black" is the same 'defiance' that drives them to call themselves nigga.
 

lexy

Member
:lol I don't think you guys should argue over semantics. a rose by any other name would smell as sweet.
 

karasu

Member
loxy said:
:lol I don't think you guys should argue over semantics. a rose by any other name would smell as sweet.

You're right. It's annoying because it's too easy to cast things aside as PC. It's some kind of ugly defense mechanism not in line with how the real world works.
 

DarienA

The black man everyone at Activision can agree on
karasu said:
Maybe you don't need uplifting, but others did and still do. I can't believe people are finding fault with a group wanting to define THEMSELVES as oppossed to being defined by the people who felt nothing but contempt for them! In many ways the defiance that drove people to call themselves "black" is the same 'defiance' that drives them to call themselves nigga.

Bah my disgust with it has to do with the fact that the label itself is meaningless without some type of meaningful MOVEMENT within the Black community towards change for themselves, and we have not seen that.

Until we DO see it, changing f'n labels is the least of our problems.

Yes you can bitch about the inequalities of life, I have to do this because it's the only way to surivive, etc., etc... one day you have to wake up and say... f*ck I'm gonna make it IN SPITE of the roadblocks that been put up in front of me by the white devil.

Plus when the revolution finally comes we'll just string up all the honkys and be done with it anyway...

bpp.gif
 

karasu

Member
DarienA said:
Bah my disgust with it has to do with the fact that the label itself is meaningless without some type of meaningful MOVEMENT within the Black community towards change for themselves, and we have not seen that.

Until we DO see it, changing f'n labels is the least of our problems.

Yes you can bitch about the inequalities of life, I have to do this because it's the only way to surivive, etc., etc... one day you have to wake up and say... f*ck I'm gonna make it IN SPITE of the roadblocks that been put up in front of me by the white devil.

Plus when the revolution finally comes we'll just string up all the honkys and be done with it anyway...

bpp.gif


There WAS change going on, and there still is. Nobody is talking about arguing over what to call yourself in between ginger snaps and reruns of Good Times. It's a process, everything isn't gonna turn to gold in 30 or 40 years. Especially considering that society as a whole is headed for the crapper.
 

DarienA

The black man everyone at Activision can agree on
karasu said:
There WAS change going on, and there still is. Nobody is talking about arguing over what to call yourself in between ginger snaps and reruns of Good Times. It's a process, everything isn't gonna turn to gold in 30 or 40 years. Especially considering that society as a whole is headed for the crapper.

Please point me to said change, hell please point me to INDICATORS of of said change because I sure as hell haven't seen it.

Folks much older and much wiser than I am haven't seen much of it either.

You know it's funny, talking to folks lately about this same issue we've all started to think that the Black community has never really recovered from Martin Luther King Jr's death... floundering around while all these half-assed "black leaders" come on the scene.... How much REAL progress has been made since his death?
 

lexy

Member
"white devil"

That phrase is funny to me. It reminds me of this story my dad told me about the first time a group of African children met a white person. When they saw the white person they ran back home to their parents shouting "mom, dad, we saw a ghost!"
 

Leatherface

Member
galeninjapan said:
I had a cousin that was White but born in South Africa. On all his applications he put African-American cuase he didnt know any better. He probably got a bunch of benifits that way too.

:lol

too funny..
 
MIMIC said:
C'mon.

REALLY?


Really, I don't know a one person that uses the term in any real sense. The people I know are comfortable in their Blackness to be Black. African-American is guilt speak for White people the way I see it.

Is an African-American and an African-English the same thing? What about a African-Brazillian or an African-Hatiian? These terms mean nothing to me.

Black is an race and and ethnicity it's all how it's used in context.

Besides my skin tone I have no ethnic relationship to anyone from Africa. I celebrate different customs and culture. The Black (American) cultural experience is unique.I don't consider a Hatian or a Ethopian or an Egyptian ethnically Black although they are racially African. Same thing with an Englishman and a Frenchman both are racially white (in this example) but, they have a different ethnicity.

Make sense?
 

karasu

Member
DarienA said:
Please point me to said change, hell please point me to INDICATORS of of said change because I sure as hell haven't seen it.

Folks much older and much wiser than I am haven't seen much of it either.

Aren't you a black male with a white collar job? You think you're the only one?
 

DarienA

The black man everyone at Activision can agree on
karasu said:
Aren't you a black male with a white collar job? You think you're the only one?

...The above is a dumb statement considering what I've already said in this thread, but I believe I see what you are trying to say so....

Yes and we have black business owners, black millionaires, etc.... which doesn't change the fact that on the whole %-wise the majority of blacks in American still aren't doing very well, in school, in college and in the workforce. More whites are on social services... but I believe a HIGHER percentage of the blacks relative to the total black population is on social services... that's an indicator to me... and not a good one.

As for me being the only one? No... but I'll tell you in the architectural firm I work at? There are FEW black men here. VERY few.
 

sonicfan

Venerable Member
Random thoughts.....

If anthropologists say modern humans first emerged in Africa and then spread out to the rest of the world, aren't we all "African-Americans"?

What do we make of the "Black Irish"?
 

Nerevar

they call me "Man Gravy".
my Egyptian friend was pissed that he couldn't call himself African American on his college application.

In more general terms, we need to get rid of the retarded "African American" term altogether, because it has simply become a placeholder for "black" with no thought to the actual meaning of the phrase. Moroccans can't describe themselves as "African American" if they're naturalized US citizens? How retarded is that?
 

sonicfan

Venerable Member
To go along with somebody from Egypt or somebody born in South Africa, Teresa Heinz Kerry, who born in Mozambique, called herself African American.........

hkbb.jpg
kerry3.jpg
 
I remember when African-American was in style back in 96-97 that was funny. I almost got attack in all my classes because I said that it was a dumb term I asked in class who is African American and 10 people raised there hand, then I asked who has been to Africa and no one raised their hand. So I said oh! so you are all Americans. They proceed to insist that they were African-American so I asked what am I, and they replied White. HAHAHAHAHA... I was like um actually by your standards I'm Italian-American, and they said "no your White". So then I used that to play a song call "Don't Call Me White". Oh Man they did not get it and the knuckles started cracking.

So Blackace thanks for the American comment sometimes I just don't get why we can't all just be proud Americans.
 
sonicfan said:
Random thoughts.....

If anthropologists say modern humans first emerged in Africa and then spread out to the rest of the world, aren't we all "African-Americans"?

In the grander scheme of things, yes, but that's not what is usually meant when one uses different terms for ethnic groups. People never go that far into the past to establish ancestry and their identity. They just need an unique culture, a specific geographical location with, in option, some vague physical differences to set themselves apart from other ethnic groups and nationalities.
 

mrklaw

MrArseFace
Tommie Hu$tle said:
Really, I don't know a one person that uses the term in any real sense. The people I know are comfortable in their Blackness to be Black. African-American is guilt speak for White people the way I see it.

What about Cliff Huxtable? They went really heritage towards the end of the Cosby show. Was that just the white networks pushing what they thought was a wholesome message, or one powerful Black man using his visibilty to push what he believed in?
 

sonicfan

Venerable Member
Instigator said:
In the grander scheme of things, yes, but that's not what is usually meant when one uses different terms for ethnic groups. People never go that far into the past to establish ancestry and their identity. They just need an unique culture, a specific geographical location with, in option, some vague physical differences to set themselves apart from other ethnic groups and nationalities.

That is really my point. Genetically, were are arguing over nothing more significant than eye or hair color. But culturally, these are the things that set us apart. To be honest, a lot, if not most African-Americans, Blacks, or what ever term you want to use, have much more in common with "European Americans" than they do people who acutally live in Africa today.
 

Blackace

if you see me in a fight with a bear, don't help me fool, help the bear!
sonicfan said:
Random thoughts.....

If anthropologists say modern humans first emerged in Africa and then spread out to the rest of the world, aren't we all "African-Americans"?

What do we make of the "Black Irish"?

that is my background.. but again I prefer the label "freedom challenged"
 

Escape Goat

Member
I was listed as "Nicole" in my 7th grade yearbook. Its not like I'd been called that before grades 1-6 so it was no big whoop, i moved after 7th anyways! :lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom