• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Sky High getting good reviews

Status
Not open for further replies.
Desperado said:
no...
Click to expand...

Its got a population of generic Superheroes.
Its by Disney.
Its in a white suburban setting.
Dumbass kid can't use powers properly.
Parents are famous superheroes.
Kids save the day.
Stupid villans.
BS ending.

This is Incredibles 2 with people instead of CG.
 
SteveMeister said:
No, you're going to have to explain yourself here. You're not getting off that easily. Why was the villain in The Incredibles lame? How did the movie have a BS ending?

You are most definitely in the minority...
Click to expand...

It ended with then defeating the superrobot. I'm fine with that. And then it ended again with the kidnapping. 2 climaxes is BS. Its just a stupid way to clean up all the loose ends and open it up for a sequel. Did the baby have any purpose but to extend the story for 10 minutes?

As for the villans. The guards were typical dumbasses same with stock robot with lame weakness. If you didn't see the main bad guy coming from 2 miles away . . .

What was he some dork that didn't get to be a sidekick. Why would you hold a vendetta like that? You don't get what you want so you create evil and artificially become thehero. That's got to be the stupidest villan. I understand robbing banks and world domination, but pretending to save the world for fame and glory.

That would be like a kid wanting to be a cop or a soldier and when they told him he was not a cop/soldier material he would grow up and be a pseudo vigilante saving people from his own terrorism. Or a kid wanting to be an athlete and getting cut from the team. Then he sabotages the team in an attempt to win the big game.
 
acidviper said:
It ended with then defeating the superrobot. I'm fine with that. And then it ended again with the kidnapping. 2 climaxes is BS. Its just a stupid way to clean up all the loose ends and open it up for a sequel. Did the baby have any purpose but to extend the story for 10 minutes?
Click to expand...

When they defeated the robot, there was still a loose end -- what happened to Syndrome? Can't leave a loose end like that lying around. The Incredibles was a fantastic movie -- if you don't see that, you're not only in a very small minority, you're also way, WAY too jaded.
 
acidviper said:
It ended with then defeating the superrobot. I'm fine with that. And then it ended again with the kidnapping. 2 climaxes is BS. Its just a stupid way to clean up all the loose ends and open it up for a sequel. Did the baby have any purpose but to extend the story for 10 minutes?

As for the villans. The guards were typical dumbasses same with stock robot with lame weakness. If you didn't see the main bad guy coming from 2 miles away . . .

What was he some dork that didn't get to be a sidekick. Why would you hold a vendetta like that? You don't get what you want so you create evil and artificially become thehero. That's got to be the stupidest villan. I understand robbing banks and world domination, but pretending to save the world for fame and glory.

That would be like a kid wanting to be a cop or a soldier and when they told him he was not a cop/soldier material he would grow up and be a pseudo vigilante saving people from his own terrorism. Or a kid wanting to be an athlete and getting cut from the team. Then he sabotages the team in an attempt to win the big game.
Click to expand...

2 climaxes is BS :lol Ok. And yes, they had to take care of Syndrome and the baby was a subplot the entire movie. They planned it from the start with "the baby doesn't have superpowers". The guards are dumbasses? :lol Of course they are, they played on the logic of superhero cliches. The villain was villainous, guards dumb, and there was monologuing.

And you hold it against The Incredibles because they didn't give an ultra-generic cliche plot of robbing a bank as the main storyline? The beginning hit those marks, with the train and guy jumping out the window. All the normal stuff for a bizarre and dangerous villain plotline later on. And yeah, the main villain's motives were flawed. He was a kid doing it for all the wrong reasons, running the risk of being a villain and eventually is one. That's not stupid, it's different and a little understandable.

Also, the last thing on Pixar's mind is a sequel if you know anything about Pixar. And I'd be willing to bet Brad Bird isn't going to do a sequel. He has stated he doesn't want one. The very last scene was just a joke and homage to a Fantastic Four issue, as was the baby, having completed the 4 powers of the Fantastic Four. As far as Sky High, I wouldn't expect 1/4 of The Incredibles' genius.
 
acidviper said:
Isn't this just the Incredibles 2 with people instead of CG.
Click to expand...

I thought that was Fantastic Four. :P

Also, these kind of threads are absolutely worthless. I remember there was a "THE ISLAND IS GETTING GOOD REVIEWS OMGWTF" thread...and now it's at 41% at RT. :P
 
SteveMeister said:
When they defeated the robot, there was still a loose end -- what happened to Syndrome? Can't leave a loose end like that lying around. The Incredibles was a fantastic movie -- if you don't see that, you're not only in a very small minority, you're also way, WAY too jaded.
Click to expand...

I never said I didn't like the movie, its a good movie with great CG and effects, but some of its problems lie in the villans and the ending.

Its far from a perfect movie. And rottentomatoes gives a ripe tomato if you give it 2/4 stars so don't be too skewed with that site. Its also odd that parents didn't buy the DVD as well as it should have? Maybe there is a large minority out there.
 
jett said:
I thought that was Fantastic Four. :P

Also, these kind of threads are absolutely worthless. I remember there was a "THE ISLAND IS GETTING GOOD REVIEWS OMGWTF" thread...and now it's at 41% at RT. :P
Click to expand...

I'll dodge the villlan/ending comparison cuz I didn't see FF4, but the only similarity was stretch girl and reed richards and it was a family foursome (But SamJack kinda made Incredibles 5 and the FF4 were not all family).
 
acidviper said:
Its got a population of generic Superheroes.
Its by Disney.
Its in a white suburban setting.
Dumbass kid can't use powers properly.
Parents are famous superheroes.
Kids save the day.
Stupid villans.
BS ending.

This is Incredibles 2 with people instead of CG.
Click to expand...


you've seen sky high? is it out already, or was it a preview showing?



acidviper said:
It ended with then defeating the superrobot. I'm fine with that. And then it ended again with the kidnapping. 2 climaxes is BS. Its just a stupid way to clean up all the loose ends and open it up for a sequel. Did the baby have any purpose but to extend the story for 10 minutes?

As for the villans. The guards were typical dumbasses same with stock robot with lame weakness. If you didn't see the main bad guy coming from 2 miles away . . .

What was he some dork that didn't get to be a sidekick. Why would you hold a vendetta like that? You don't get what you want so you create evil and artificially become thehero. That's got to be the stupidest villan. I understand robbing banks and world domination, but pretending to save the world for fame and glory.

That would be like a kid wanting to be a cop or a soldier and when they told him he was not a cop/soldier material he would grow up and be a pseudo vigilante saving people from his own terrorism. Or a kid wanting to be an athlete and getting cut from the team. Then he sabotages the team in an attempt to win the big game.
Click to expand...


oh, wait.. no, you're just an idiot.
 
acidviper said:
And rottentomatoes gives a ripe tomato if you give it 2/4 stars so don't be too skewed with that site.
Click to expand...

Well, at RT I usually only pay attention to the average ratings for that very reason. 8.2/10 out of 207 reviews, not bad.
 
I just saw this.


Thought it was pretty good. Especially as far as the whole superhero story through a teen comedy filter. Some of the effects shots were ropey... but I'd imagine they didn't have a very steep budget(I could be wrong), and in the end, the powers weren't really the point anyway. It did a good job of paying homage to superhero conventions, while at its heart remaining an allegory. Superheroes work best as allegories, in that respect this was a pretty good movie.

All in all it's probably about as close as we'll ever get to this:
http://www.ifilm.com/ifilmdetail/2483385

Anybody else catch this?
 
acidviper said:
I never said I didn't like the movie, its a good movie with great CG and effects, but some of its problems lie in the villans and the ending.

Its far from a perfect movie. And rottentomatoes gives a ripe tomato if you give it 2/4 stars so don't be too skewed with that site. Its also odd that parents didn't buy the DVD as well as it should have? Maybe there is a large minority out there.
Click to expand...


Actually, it's usually 3 stars and above. Look at this. http://deseretnews.com/movies/view/1,1257,405000641,00.html

He gave Sky High 2 1/2 stars out of 4, and it shows up as rotten.

http://www.wafflemovies.com/skyhigh.html

This guy gives it 2/4, and it shows up as rotten.

http://ae.freep.com/entertainment/ui/michigan/movie.html?id=373238&reviewId=18666

This guy gives it 3/4, and it shows up as fresh.

The site explains it like this:
You're seeing this discrepancy because star systems are not consistent between critics. For critics like Roger Ebert and James Berardinelli, 2.5 stars or lower out of 4 stars is always negative. For other critics, 2.5 stars can either be positive or negative. Even though Eric Lurio uses a 5 star system, his grading is very relaxed. So, 2 stars can be positive.

So basically, some critics grade more easily than others.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Canada's First High Speed Rail Line
23
343
JackHanma replied
Underrated movies that are good.
43
472
Itchy.Tasty. replied
Massive fire engulfs high rises in Hong Kong
41
514
StereoVsn replied
Some good upcoming films
25
461
GateofD replied
Side hustles? Anyone got any good ones?
38
526
bitbydeath replied
Top Bottom