• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Spike Video Game Award nominees

U

UltimaPooh

Member
Game of the Year
Halo: Reach (Microsoft/Bungie Studios)

Studio of the Year
Bungie Studios

Best Xbox 360 Game
Alan Wake (Microsoft/Remedy)

Best PS3 Game
God of War III (Sony Computer Entertainment/SCE Studios Santa Monica)

Best Shooter
Battlefield: Bad Company 2 (Electronic Arts/DICE)

Best Multiplayer Game
Halo: Reach (Microsoft/Bungie Studios)

Best Music Game
Rock Band 3 (MTV Games/Harmonix)

Best Soundtrack
Rock Band 3 (MTV Games/Harmonix)

Best Song in a Game
Won't Back Down by Eminem (Call of Duty: Black Ops)

Best Original Score
Red Dead Redemption (Rockstar Games/Rockstar San Diego)

Best Graphics
God of War III (Sony Computer Entertainment/SCE Studios Santa Monica)

Best Adapted Video Game
Scott Pilgrim vs. The World: The Game (Ubisoft/Ubisoft Montreal/Ubisoft Chengdu)

Best Performance by a Human Male
Rob Wiethoff as John Marston (Red Dead Redemption/Rockstar Games)

Best Downloadable Game
Scott Pilgrim vs. The World: The Game (Ubisoft/Ubisoft Montreal/ Ubisoft Chengdu)

Best DLC
Red Dead Redemption - Undead Nightmare (Rockstar Games/Rockstar San Diego)

Best Independent Game
Super Meat Boy (Team Meat)

Most Anticipated Game
Portal 2 (Valve/Valve)
 
Rhazer Fusion

Rhazer Fusion

Member
Aokage said:
I'm sorry. Uh.

Bayonetta isn't nominated for "Best Action Adventure Game"? What the FUCK?
Click to expand...



Not trying to start anything, but do these shows have something against Japanese, non mainstream games? No Galaxy 2, Super Street Fighter 4, BlazBlue, Bayonetta, Vanquish? Was Demon's Souls even nominated for anything last year? It seems to be more of a popularity contest based on mainstream appeal or unit sales instead of quality unfortunately.
 
S

sixteen-bit

Member
Best PS3 Game
God of War III (Sony Computer Entertainment/SCE Studios Santa Monica)
Heavy Rain (Sony Computer Entertainment/Quantic Dream)
ModNation Racers (Sony Computer Entertainment/United Front Games)
Red Dead Redemption (Rockstar Games/Rockstar San Diego)
Click to expand...
RDR is multiplat, right?
 
N

Nert

Member
Rhazer Fusion said:
Not trying to start anything, but do these shows have something against Japanese, non mainstream games? No Galaxy 2, Super Street Fighter 4, BlazBlue, Bayonetta, Vanquish? Was Demon's Souls even nominated for anything last year? It seems to be more of a popularity contest based on mainstream appeal or unit sales instead of quality unfortunately.
Click to expand...

I'm kind of surprised by the existence of an indie category at all. At least Super Meat Boy might end up getting *something.* But yeah, not a lot of Japanese games on those lists.
 
S

sdornan

Member
GhaleonQ said:
Japan, represent!

...

......

.........

Metroid: Other M (Nintendo/Team Ninja/Nintendo)
Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker (Konami / Kojima Productions)
Professor Layton and the Unwound Future (Nintendo/ Level-5)
Super Mario Galaxy 2 (Nintendo/Nintendo)
Final Fantasy XIII (Square Enix/Square Enix)
Kirby's Epic Yarn (Nintendo/Good-Feel)

Oh, come ON, Spike. I know this award show is purposely bad, but no amount of Mountain Dew plugging can distract from 9 slots out of 100 or so.
Click to expand...
Which games do you think are missing?

I think it's a fair list. Could be way worse. Did you really expect them to nominate <insert_niche_game> for <insert_category>?
 
G

GuardianE

Santa May Claus
Rhazer Fusion said:
Not trying to start anything, but do these shows have something against Japanese, non mainstream games? No Galaxy 2, Super Street Fighter 4, BlazBlue, Bayonetta, Vanquish? Was Demon's Souls even nominated for anything last year? It seems to be more of a popularity contest based on mainstream appeal or unit sales instead of quality unfortunately.
Click to expand...

The fact that they don't have a fighting game category baffles me.
 
K

kinggroin

Banned
sdornan said:
Which games do you think are missing?

I think it's a fair list. Could be way worse. Did you really expect them to nominate <insert_niche_game> for <insert_category>?
Click to expand...

If there was any kind of integrity, being niche wouldn't (shouldn't) factor into this.
 
M

Meier

Member
I am surprised that SMG2 did not get nominated more. I think it's a pretty good list of nominees though all told.
 
S

sdornan

Member
kinggroin said:
If there was any kind of integrity, being niche wouldn't (shouldn't) factor into this.
Click to expand...
But it always does. Look at the list of Grammy nominees for the past decade.

I guess I just have low expectations when it comes to awards shows.

szaromir said:
By dudebro games I meant exactly the games above - I know the term is oriented more towards shooters akin GoW or CoD, but I meant high budget blockbusters that are shooter oriented (5 out of 7 fit the description). Look at this year's GOTY nominees...
Click to expand...
And 5 out of 7 critically acclaimed games fit that description as well. You're really grasping at straws if you're calling Bioshock or Uncharted 2 "dudebro" games.
 
S

szaromir

Banned
Loxley said:
I have a feeling Red Dead and Black Ops will sweep the show, which I have no problem with; both were excellent games.

I am, however, staying tuned in to GAF during the awards anyway to watch the obligatory "Yeah these awards are bullshit anyway" reactions when ME2 doesn't win GotY :lol



I can't believe I'm actually defending this B-list award show, but here's a list of the previous GotY winners:

2003 - Madden 2004
2004 - GTA: San Andreas
2005 - Resident Evil 4
2006 - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion
2007 - Bioshock
2008 - Grand Theft Auto IV
2009 - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

Yeah man, just look at all those Dudebro shooters that won the Game of the Year. Absolutely none of those games were critical darlings :lol
Click to expand...
By dudebro games I meant exactly the games above - I know the term is oriented more towards shooters akin GoW or CoD, but I meant high budget blockbusters that are shooter oriented (5 out of 7 fit the description). Look at this year's GOTY nominees...
 
S

squicken

Member
It's weird that FF13 got a nomination, but I doubt the nomination panel plays obscure Bulgarian CRPGs.

The only categories that bug me are the voice acting set. Sam Worthington? I don't hate him like most people on GAF, but his accent was all over the place in Blops. Felicia Day? Just b/c she is some nerd goddess?

More broadly, celebraphilia makes sense with the Oscars and VMAs. But by pandering so sadly to Hollywood, it just cheapens the work that the actual game makers do.
 
Miggytronz

Miggytronz

Gold Member
Game of the Year
Red Dead Redemption (Rockstar Games/Rockstar San Diego)
Studio of the Year
Bungie Studios
Best Xbox 360 Game
Halo: Reach (Microsoft/Bungie Studios)
Best PS3 Game
Red Dead Redemption (Rockstar Games/Rockstar San Diego)
Best Wii Game
Super Mario Galaxy 2 (Nintendo/Nintendo)
Best PC Game
NA
Best Handheld Game
God of War: Ghost of Sparta (Sony Computer Entertainment / Ready At Dawn Studios)
Best Shooter
Halo: Reach (Microsoft/Bungie Studios)
Best Action Adventure Game
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood (Ubisoft/Ubisoft Montreal)
Best RPG
Mass Effect 2 (Electronic Arts/BioWare)
Best Multiplayer Game
Halo: Reach (Microsoft/Bungie Studios)
Best Individual Sports Game
NA
Best Team Sports Game
FIFA Soccer 11 (Electronic Arts/EA Canada)
Best Driving Game
NA
Best Music Game
NA
Best Soundtrack
NA
Best Song in a Game
Far Away by José González (Red Dead Redemption)
Best Original Score
Halo: Reach (Microsoft/Bungie Studios)
Best Graphics
Red Dead Redemption (Rockstar Games/Rockstar San Diego)
Best Adapted Video Game
Transformers: War for Cybertron (Activision/High Moon Studios)
Best Performance by a Human Male
Nathan Fillion as Sergeant Edward Buck (Halo: Reach/Microsoft)
Best Performance by a Human Female
Yvonne Strahovski as Miranda Lawson (Mass Effect 2/Electronic Arts)
Best Downloadable Game
NA
Best DLC
Red Dead Redemption - Undead Nightmare (Rockstar Games/Rockstar San Diego)
Best Independent Game
Limbo (PlayDead)
Most Anticipated Game
Batman: Arkham City (Warner Bros Interactive Entertainment/Rocksteady Studios)
 
P

Pooya

Member
squicken said:
The only categories that bug me are the voice acting set. Sam Worthington? I don't hate him like most people on GAF, but his accent was all over the place in Blops. Felicia Day? Just b/c she is some nerd goddess?
.
Click to expand...
No, her performance was surprisingly great in the game, I didn't expect it to be that great, she deserves it I think. Sam Worthington is awful I agree.
 
7

7echnicolor

Member
I bet Black Ops will win Game of The Year.

It's almost inevitable really.
Though I'm hoping either Mass Effect 2 or Halo: Reach wins.

Also, Bungie should win Studio of the Year, without a doubt.
 
S

szaromir

Banned
sdornan said:
And 5 out of 7 critically acclaimed games fit that description as well. You're really grasping at straws if you're calling Bioshock or Uncharted 2 "dudebro" games.
Click to expand...

Definitely not.
 
G

GhaleonEB

Member
squicken said:
It's weird that FF13 got a nomination, but I doubt the nomination panel plays obscure Bulgarian CRPGs.

The only categories that bug me are the voice acting set. Sam Worthington? I don't hate him like most people on GAF, but his accent was all over the place in Blops. Felicia Day? Just b/c she is some nerd goddess?

More broadly, celebraphilia makes sense with the Oscars and VMAs. But by pandering so sadly to Hollywood, it just cheapens the work that the actual game makers do.
Click to expand...
I like how Fillion is up for a nom when he has one minute of dialog on a sub-mission that appears once in three play thorughs of the level he's on.
 
S

squicken

Member
GhaleonEB said:
I like how Fillion is up for a nom when he has one minute of dialog on a sub-mission that appears once in three play thorughs of the level he's on.
Click to expand...

Rabbitwork said:
how is nathan fillion nominated for THREE LINES OF DIALOGUE?
Click to expand...

okay this is the worst nomination. I had forgot he was even in the game.
 
W

WillyFive

Member
Man, these awards are absolutely awful. Might as well be the MTV Awards.

It's like honoring which games had the biggest budget on the HD systems.
 
Revolutionary

Revolutionary

Member
RDR should take GOTY.... but it's Spike, so either Halo, CoD, or Mass Effect will. :lol

But anyway, who cares about the rewards. I'll be watching for the Uncharted 3 premiere *crosses fingers*
 
MAtgS

MAtgS

Member
sdornan said:
Which games do you think are missing?

I think it's a fair list. Could be way worse. Did you really expect them to nominate <insert_niche_game> for <insert_category>?
Click to expand...
I'd say Kingdom Hearts BBS for best handheld would've been a heck of a lot less niche than layton & scribblenauts.

& maybe TvC for Wii.
 
S

sdornan

Member
szaromir said:
Definitely not.
Click to expand...
Okay, I was exaggerating, but my point still stands: the majority of high-profile game releases involve shooting things, so it shouldn't be too surprising to see a bunch of shooters on this list.


MAtgS said:
I'd say Kingdom Hearts BBS for best handheld would've been a heck of a lot less niche than layton & scribblenauts.
Click to expand...
Fair enough, though Layton did get better reviews than the two others.

& maybe TvC for Wii.
Click to expand...
I've gotta admit that not having a fighting category is kind of weird.
 
N

Neuromancer

Member
GhaleonEB said:
I like how Fillion is up for a nom when he has one minute of dialog on a sub-mission that appears once in three play thorughs of the level he's on.
Click to expand...
Yeah I would have rather seen Hakeem Kae-Kazim (Jorge's voice actor) up there, I thought he did the best job in the game. But of course, he's not famous.
 
X

Xater

Member
Black Ops is fun but no where near GOTY material. :lol

Sam Worthington as Alex Mason (Call of Duty: Black Ops/Activision)
Click to expand...

Holy shit I almost missed this. Oh fuck off Spike. :lol

English isn't my native language and even I heard the Australien in his perfomance.
 
G

GhaleonEB

Member
Neuromancer said:
Yeah I would have rather seen Hakeem Kae-Kazim (Jorge's voice actor) up there, I thought he did the best job in the game. But of course, he's not famous.
Click to expand...
Same, he did a great job. Heck, I thought Kat's voice actor was excellent. But like you said, Fillion - whom I like a great deal - got the nom for who he was. It was a cameo, FFS. It's an insult to all the other excellent voice work in Reach, not to mention other games.
 
S

scently

Member
GhaleonEB said:
Same, he did a great job. Heck, I thought Kat's voice actor was excellent. But like you said, Fillion - whom I like a great deal - got the nom for who he was. It was a cameo, FFS. It's an insult to all the other excellent voice work in Reach, not to mention other games.
Click to expand...

Indeed.
 
S

Sadist

Member
Donkey Kong as best Wii game? It's not even out yet.

And Galaxy 2 nowhere near the game of the year nominees?

Ha
 
S

Stumpokapow

listen to the mad man
My picks, given the nominees:

Game of the Year: Only played Mass Effect 2 of the five; don't like GoW as a franchise, don't like Call of Duty as a franchise, still haven't finished ODST single player, and stopped about a quarter of the way through RDR.

Studio of the Year: All four nominees suck; RSD released a pretty great game, but it had a seriously troubled development. Bungie released, again, a supposedly pretty great game, but they've been working on it for years. Ditto Blizzard. Ditto BioWare, really. Unless Studio of the Year means "Studio that made the Game of the Year", this is a pretty bad category. Of the four I'd give it to BioWare simply because they appear to be working on a lot of projects at once, doing well with all of them, and did good in terms of post-release Mass Effect 2 DLC support.

Best 360 Game: Played every nominee except Halo Reach; liked Alan Wake, liking Fable 3 so far. Mass Effect 2 is pretty unambiguously the best received game of the three, though.
Best PS3 Game: Didn't play GOW, don't think it makes sense to give it to a multiplatform title. Heavy Rain and Modnation Racers both succeeded in very different ways. I'd probably give the edge to Heavy Rain although I liked MNR a lot.
Best Wii Game: DKCR isn't out, M:OM is seriously divisive, KEY is divisive on GAF (AKA Amir0x doesn't like it and will make this point very obviously everywhere he posts). SMG2, meanwhile, huge metascores. Personally SMG2 didn't really capture me, I'd give it to KEY between the two.
Best PC Game: I'd eliminate FNV and ME2 by virtue of being multiplatform. Haven't played either of the other two.
Best Handheld Game: Haven't played any of them.

Shooter: Only played BS2, wasn't all that impressed.
Action Adventure: SMG2 isn't an action adventure game, haven't played ACB or GOW, didn't finish RDR... so....

RPG: I think I'd say that I liked Mass Effect 2 more, but F:NV is the better RPG.
Multiplayer: Haven't played any of them.
Sports/Team Sports: Haven't played any of them.
Driving: LOL no GT5. This has gotta go to Hot Pursuit, although I've only played MNR
Music: Dance Central by a long shot.

Soundtrack: No input, depends on the type of music you like. Clearly all 4 nominees well represent the target genres of music they were going for.
Best Song: The Goldeneye theme is the only one recorded specifically for the game, so fuck the other ones. It's not like we're talking about "best use of a song", half the nominees are just tracks in music games.
Original Score: No input, played 1.5 out of 4
Graphics: No input, but I'd argue that KEY has the best style of the four while GOW3 is the most technically complex. Both RDR and HR looked greater though.
Adapted Video Game: Lego HP is good, but probably I'd give this one to Scott Pilgrim. Didn't play any of the other three.

Male: Illusive Man; Craig, Oldman, and Worthington didn't really do that great from what I've heard, Cleese is good but really is just lending his voice, there's not much "acting" involved, Fillion is barely in his game.
Female: No input, but Jennifer Hale's VA for ME2 is quite good.

Best Downloadable: None of the above, holy shit. I liked Costume Quest the best.
Best DLC: I don't see how, based purely on scope, it could be anything other than Undead Nightmare.
Independent: I'd give it to Meat Boy over Winterbottom, didn't play the full Limbo and haven't tried Joe Danger.

Most Anticipated is a joke category by definition, although I'm personally anticipating all four nominees quite a bit.
 
S

szaromir

Banned
sdornan said:
Okay, I was exaggerating, but my point still stands: the majority of high-profile game releases involve shooting things, so it shouldn't be too surprising to see a bunch of shooters on this list.
Click to expand...
Why do nominees have to be high profile releases? That's my point, shooting is a secondary complaint. But again, these nominations have million other retarted choices (just look at VA discussion).
 
J

jergrah

Member
ModNation Racers for best PS3 game? What? The game isnt horrible by any means, but it's not good enough to be mentioned as a nominee in my opinion.

Anyways - as for GotY - my vote would be #1 Mass Effect 2 #1A RDR
 
graywolf323

graywolf323

Member
Best PC Game
Fallout: New Vegas (Bethesda Softworks/Obsidian Entertainment)
Mass Effect 2 (Electronic Arts/BioWare)
Sid Meier's Civilization V (2K Games/Firaxis)
StarCraft II: Wings of Liberty (Blizzard Entertainment/Blizzard Entertainment)

oh man that category is loaded
 
H

Hamblasto

Member
Fimbulvetr said:
Next thing you're gonna want holographic cartoon characters at US pop concerts?
Click to expand...

While not pop, it has been done.

On topic, I would like to see a more varied list of nominees, but for such a joke of an award show, that's like saying I'd like better bread with my turd sandwich.
 
H

Hey You

Member
Why cant we vote in any other categories beside Most anticipate game?

Edit: Best PS3 game catergory includes a Mult-Platform game? Sony must not have much exclusives this year.
 
D

Dizzy-4U

Member
Best Soundtrack
Def Jam Rapstar (Konami/Autumn Games /4mm Games)
DJ Hero 2 (Activision/FreeStyleGames)
Guitar Hero: Warriors of Rock (Activision/Neversoft Entertainment)
Rock Band 3 (MTV Games/Harmonix)
Click to expand...
All licenced music? What's the point? Fuck that.

No Super Meat Boy? No Nier? This sucks...

wmat said:
CMD-F —› "Amnesia" —› 0 Results.

Fuck this shit yo.
Click to expand...
Agreed.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

[GI.biz] UK August '24 top ten games (digital and physical) - yep, GTA V is #1 again
25
847
mckmas8808 replied
GDC '24 Awards | Nominee's
11
1K
Fake replied
GDC Awards 2024 - Winners - Baldurs Gate 3 Wins GoTY
3
865
IAmRei replied
Germany Best Selling Games of September 2024: EA FC 25 #1, The Crew 2 #2, Space Marine 2 #3, Astro Bot #4, Hogwarts Legacy #5
Sales-Age
30
1K
Woopah replied
Baldur's Gate 3 Wins Game of The Year at GDC 2024
News Hype
3
795
manfestival replied
Top Bottom