• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Star Wars The Force Awakens Trailer

Status
Not open for further replies.
But there would be a beam inside the metal. All beams would originate from the same central crystal.

I know, I mentioned that a few posts back.

So if there is a beam, why is there metal there to begin with?

The sith flips his lightsaber mid battle and grabs it by the beam with his Mandelorian iron hands before smacking Luke in the head with it.

Fanboys everywhere begin to riot.

tumblr_n32b3xzdKT1stvmp7o4_500.gif
 
Having that crossguard would also greatly limit one's maneuverability and choice of moves. Any move that brings the blade close to the user's body would have to be carried out with extreme care to make sure the crossguard blades aren't going to swipe them as well. The prequel trilogy style of fighting that would have the blade wizzing around one's head or behind the back couldn't be done. I'm sure many would be fine with that. Bring back the two handed, medieval knight original trilogy style.
 
Except swords are multipurpose and gross guards are also used as a hammer or pick by grabbing the blade and singing the sword like a sledge hammer.

Augsburg_Cod.I.6.4%C2%BA.2_(Codex_Wallerstein)_107v.jpg

Ah, half-swording. Old dorks have tried staging practice fights to show how totally viable this strategy of sword fighting is and have taken "ow yes it hurts when you bash me with the cross guard" as proof that it's true, disregarding the fact that smashing solid steel of any shape into someone is going to hurt like a motherfucker.

I'm not sure if this was ever really something swords were meant to do by design or if the old illustrations demonstrating it are more meant to say "uh, hey, in a pinch you could try this."
 
I don't get why people are so stuck on the "it's impractical for defense" thing. It would at least be somewhat helpful for defense, but more likely than not it's to give an opponent a nasty poke when you've locked swords with him or her.

I CAN'T BELIEVE I LET MYSELF GET SUCKED INTO THE HILT DEBATE. That's it, walking away from it now!

I guess it's a good sign that THAT, as silly as it is, is one of the main nitpicks from the trailer.
 
Except swords are multipurpose and gross guards are also used as a hammer or pick by grabbing the blade and singing the sword like a sledge hammer.

Augsburg_Cod.I.6.4%C2%BA.2_(Codex_Wallerstein)_107v.jpg

Leaked set footage of Hamill/Sith fight:

Kidding. Kidding. As much as I am skeptical about the claymore saber, I think the overall teaser was great. I love that it looks real and dirty with call backs to the OT. Hopefully the next trailer will shed light on the story.
 
Wow, dat lightsaber is awesome. Honestly the trailer didn't amaze me... i liked the jp one more

I don't want to feed the JW vs FA thing but Pratt and his biker gang of raptors is the goofiest thing I've ever seen. It takes a lot of cocaine to pitch that in a writers' meeting.
 
At this point, I've seen way more reasons why the cross-guard could be functional as opposed to it being stupid. Furthermore, ever reason against it's practicality has been refuted by a possibility.

We'll have to wait and see.
 
Not before Leia dying in hans arms.

-leia dies in han's arms (start the force theme here)
-han and chewie decide to go out in a final blaze of glory, taking out the film's big bad on their own (the force theme playing throughout)
-a hooded figure watches the demise of the millenium falcon from afar. he pulls off the hood: it's luke skywalker (music swells aaaaand cut to credits)
 
Yes.

What are the chances of Admiral Ackbar making a appearance?

Based on his age at the time, highly unlikely. Then again, who am I to comment Calamari lifespans?

However, I can see a scene happening where an old officer is recounting old war stories at a bonfire going like "And then he yells 'It's a trap!".
 
The cross guard is especially superfluous because it's been shown through all six films that lightsabers "bind" when struck together, they don't slide past each other, so you can't slide a strike down an opposing lightsaber to the opponent's hands.

Also, reposting:

iVYC5SKIm8s1Q.gif
 
-leia dies in han's arms (start the force theme here)
-han and chewie decide to go out in a final blaze of glory, taking out the film's big bad on their own (the force theme playing throughout)
-a hooded figure watches the demise of the millenium falcon from afar. he pulls off the hood: it's luke skywalker (music swells aaaaand cut to credits)

I think the sith you see will last more then one film.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom