I dunno, I guess I feel like Graces really, really shined in its first 1/3. So much so that it unfortunately outshines the rest of the game, and the last 1/3 feels like it drags on way too long. And then Lineage and Legacies comes along, and while the premise mildly interesting, stretches on way too long and overstays its welcome long before you get through half the extremely obtuse dungeons. Entire
dungeon was rage-inducing. Actually in hindsight I probably should have caved in and just used a guide to speed through it.
The contrast hits me even harder now that I'm starting ToGf NG+.
Like I said, it would have made a great 3-part OVA. (based ufotable)
edit: If I could sum up my disappointment, it's probably looking back and remembering how much I enjoyed ToG, overlooking the fact that the latter portion of the game stretched out pointlessly, and then upon playing ToGf to see what was added, discovering that the future arc was pretty much an extension of the part of the game that I found a complete slog, which therefore made me feel like I completely wasted my time playing through the game again.
Combat additions were good though. I think I might have preferred it better if it were baked into the base game, sorta like a "Final Mix" or IZJS. Not playing as Richard would be a tradeoff I'd be glad to make.
edit2: Embarassingly enough, the first time I played ToG, it -was- ToGf and on PS3. I actually didn't know that the future arc was a thing. (It was also during a relatively busy period of my life)
Falk confirmed for worst Tales fan ever.