• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Tennessee High School Principal assaults student for wearing GSA T-Shirt

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mollymauk

Member
http://www.aclu.org/free-speech-lgbt-rights/tennessee-high-school-student-principal-assaulted-me-wearing-t-shirt

MADISONVILLE, Tenn. – A 17-year-old senior at Sequoyah High School was reportedly shoved, bumped in the chest and verbally harassed by his principal last week for wearing a T-shirt in support of efforts to establish a gay-straight alliance (GSA) club on campus. In response, the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU of Tennessee sent a letter to the school district today demanding that students’ rights to free speech be protected in the classroom.

The ACLU has been assisting the student, Chris Sigler, in his and other students’ efforts to overcome resistance from school officials to establish a GSA. Principal Maurice Moser had previously threatened to punish students who circulated petitions about the club.

“It is totally unacceptable that a young man who was peacefully exercising his First Amendment rights would have his speech shut down by the public school principal,” said Hedy Weinberg, executive director of the ACLU of Tennessee. “Last week’s incident clearly illustrates the hostile environment LGBT students face at Sequoyah High School. Given this context, it’s especially important that supportive voices like Sigler’s can be heard in order to overcome the school’s resistance to a GSA.”

Sigler wore a homemade T-shirt to school last Tuesday that said “GSA: We’ve Got Your Back.” A teacher ordered Sigler to cover up the shirt in the future. Sigler, knowing he had a right to wear the shirt, wore it again Friday, and resisted an order to remove the shirt. Sigler says that Moser then ordered all students out of the classroom, except for Sigler’s sister Jessica, who refused to leave. According to both students, Moser then grabbed Sigler’s arm, shoved him, and chest-bumped him repeatedly while asking “Who’s the big man now?” Sigler’s mother reported that when she arrived at the school, she saw her son seated in a desk with Moser leaning over him and shouting in Sigler’s face. The Siglers filed a report about the incident that afternoon with the Monroe County Sheriff’s Department.

“All I want is to have a GSA at my school to help stop the bullying against gays and lesbians and their friends who support them,” Sigler said. “The shirt was a way to use my voice and show my support for the club. The way I was treated shows even more why we need a GSA here.”

“All students deserve a safe and respectful learning environment. Harassment, abuse or censorship of any student – regardless of sexual orientation – is absolutely reprehensible as well as illegal,” said Amanda Goad, staff attorney with the ACLU Lesbian Gay Bisexual and Transgender Project. “We expect the police to investigate this quickly and fairly, and take statements from all witnesses who were present.”
 
Mollymauk said:
http://www.aclu.org/free-speech-lgbt-rights/tennessee-high-school-student-principal-assaulted-me-wearing-t-shirt

MADISONVILLE, Tenn. – A 17-year-old senior at Sequoyah High School was reportedly shoved, bumped in the chest and verbally harassed by his principal last week for wearing a T-shirt in support of efforts to establish a gay-straight alliance (GSA) club on campus. In response, the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU of Tennessee sent a letter to the school district today demanding that students’ rights to free speech be protected in the classroom.

The ACLU has been assisting the student, Chris Sigler, in his and other students’ efforts to overcome resistance from school officials to establish a GSA. Principal Maurice Moser had previously threatened to punish students who circulated petitions about the club.

“It is totally unacceptable that a young man who was peacefully exercising his First Amendment rights would have his speech shut down by the public school principal,” said Hedy Weinberg, executive director of the ACLU of Tennessee. “Last week’s incident clearly illustrates the hostile environment LGBT students face at Sequoyah High School. Given this context, it’s especially important that supportive voices like Sigler’s can be heard in order to overcome the school’s resistance to a GSA.”

Sigler wore a homemade T-shirt to school last Tuesday that said “GSA: We’ve Got Your Back.” A teacher ordered Sigler to cover up the shirt in the future. Sigler, knowing he had a right to wear the shirt, wore it again Friday, and resisted an order to remove the shirt. Sigler says that Moser then ordered all students out of the classroom, except for Sigler’s sister Jessica, who refused to leave. According to both students, Moser then grabbed Sigler’s arm, shoved him, and chest-bumped him repeatedly while asking “Who’s the big man now?” Sigler’s mother reported that when she arrived at the school, she saw her son seated in a desk with Moser leaning over him and shouting in Sigler’s face. The Siglers filed a report about the incident that afternoon with the Monroe County Sheriff’s Department.

“All I want is to have a GSA at my school to help stop the bullying against gays and lesbians and their friends who support them,” Sigler said. “The shirt was a way to use my voice and show my support for the club. The way I was treated shows even more why we need a GSA here.”

“All students deserve a safe and respectful learning environment. Harassment, abuse or censorship of any student – regardless of sexual orientation – is absolutely reprehensible as well as illegal,” said Amanda Goad, staff attorney with the ACLU Lesbian Gay Bisexual and Transgender Project. “We expect the police to investigate this quickly and fairly, and take statements from all witnesses who were present.”

I say throw the principal in general population. The men in there will take care of him.
 

Gaborn

Member
dream said:
What's a Gay-Straight Alliance?

a club where students can get together in a safe environment and talk about GLBT issues as well as work at raising awareness of those issues within a school.
 

ivysaur12

Banned
To be fair, the government does define this kid's relationships as unrecognizable. What more could we expect from him? He's just upholding community standards.
 
Having a sexually suggestive phrase like "We got your back" sounds like it would break some school rule or another. Civil liberties don't really exist for kids who wear sniggery shirts to school. Principal sounds like a dick, though. Obviously a homophobe who should lose his job.

Lessons learned:

  • If you're a student, consult the wardrobe guidelines before dressing in the morning. You may learn something new.
  • If you're employed by a school system, don't abuse the kids. It's really as simple as "don't abuse them". No loopholes, no nothing. Chest bumping a kid like an alpha-male dick would be a really pathetic sight to behold. Guy probably has alot of problems outside of workl.
 

Gaborn

Member
Deified Data said:
Having a sexually suggestive phrase like "We got your back" sounds like it would break some school rule or another. Civil liberties don't really exist for kids who wear sniggery shirts to school. Principal sounds like a dick, though. Obviously a homophobe who should lose his job.

Lessons learned:

  • If you're a student, consult the wardrobe guidelines before dressing in the morning. You may learn something new.
  • If you're employed by a school system, don't abuse the kids. It's really as simple as "don't abuse them". No loopholes, no nothing. Chest bumping a kid like an alpha-male dick would be a really pathetic sight to behold. Guy probably has alot of problems outside of workl.

I... really don't think they meant it that way.
 

Delio

Member
Deified Data said:
Having a sexually suggestive phrase like "We got your back" sounds like it would break some school rule or another. Civil liberties don't really exist for kids who wear sniggery shirts to school. Principal sounds like a dick, though. Obviously a homophobe who should lose his job.

Lessons learned:

  • If you're a student, consult the wardrobe guidelines before dressing in the morning. You may learn something new.
  • If you're employed by a school system, don't abuse the kids. It's really as simple as "don't abuse them". No loopholes, no nothing. Chest bumping a kid like an alpha-male dick would be a really pathetic sight to behold. Guy probably has alot of problems outside of workl.

Um how does "We got your back" break rules..?
 

Mollymauk

Member
Local news story:
http://www.wbir.com/news/article/186681/2/ACLU-involved-with-East-TN-students-fight-to-start-gay-straight-alliance

Further information:
http://talkaboutequality.wordpress.com/category/maurice-moser/

Local NBC affiliate, WBIR has more on the alleged assault including a statement from Tim Blankenship, Ass’t Director of Schools for Monroe County:

“The Monroe County School System is aware of the alleged accusations. We have received written statements from all eyewitnesses. Our documentation clearly indicates that there are always two sides to every story. We’ll gladly provide more information when it becomes available.”

The problem with this claim is that according to Linda Sigler, no statement was taken by the school from her daughter Jessica – the only eyewitness to the assault. I called Tim Blankenship directly and when I attempted to ask him about the discrepancy in his statement and the truth, he hung up on me.

It’s become very clear that the school district is trying to protect Principal Moser to the point that they are silencing students and reporting untruths to the media about what is actually happening in Sequoya High School’s halls. When the bullying of LGBT students is literally coming from the top-down, something needs to change.
 
Gaborn said:
I... really don't think they meant it that way.
Probably doesn't matter - if the school sees it that way, it is. My school banned Billabong gear because it had the word "bong" in it. Not saying it isn't stupid, but rules are rules.

Personally, while well-meaning in his intent to spread aceptance of the LBGT community, the shirt was obviously meant to illicit laughs. It's a good joke, really. Just not school appropriate.
 

Gaborn

Member
Deified Data said:
Probably doesn't matter - if the school sees it that way, it is. My school banned Billabong gear because it had the word "bong" in it. Not saying it isn't stupid, but rules are rules.

Personally, while well-meaning in his intent to spread aceptance of the LBGT community, the shirt was obviously meant to illicit laughs. It's a good joke, really. Just not school appropriate.

Laughs? No. It's meant to be supportive. I mean, seriously, you are reading WAYYYYYYYYYY too much into that.
 
Gaborn said:
Laughs? No. It's meant to be supportive. I mean, seriously, you are reading WAYYYYYYYYYY too much into that.
Well, I think the school is. That's the problem. You'd have to be a fool to say there's not a joke in there, intentional or not. If the school thinks immature kids will view it in a specific way, they're liable to do something about it. Right or wrong, that's how it is.

But you're getting no argument from me. I'm just playing devil's advocate.
 

Delio

Member
Deified Data said:
Probably doesn't matter - if the school sees it that way, it is. My school banned Billabong gear because it had the word "bong" in it. Not saying it isn't stupid, but rules are rules.

Personally, while well-meaning in his intent to spread aceptance of the LBGT community, the shirt was obviously meant to illicit laughs. It's a good joke, really. Just not school appropriate.

Laughs? Really?
 
Karsticles said:
Not to back the principal, but "assault" seems a big strong.

The definition of assault isn't hurting someone, it's giving someone a reason to be afraid of being hurt.

Being shoved, pushed, verbally attacked, etc. are all more than enough evidence for assault.
 

Piecake

Member
Deified Data said:
Do you think it could be interpreted in such a way, regardless of intent? The school seems to think so. I'm not saying the school's right, but there you have it.

No, I dont, and I don't get where you think that the school thinks that the shirt was sexually suggestive.
 
I got pushed into a bunch of lockers on the way back from lunch by a substitute teacher. I laughed at him and told him he was stupid to do that in front of witnesses. Granted I was an asshole to him in every class I ever had with him so I probably had it coming. I didn't do anything about the "incident" though cause it wasn't anything over the top.

Shit, my gym teacher knocked a kid down for running 4 feet into the girls section of the gym when we were doing laps.
 
Deified Data said:
Do you think it could be interpreted in such a way, regardless of intent? The school seems to think so. I'm not saying the school's right, but there you have it.
The principal is most likely a homophobic asshole, which is why he had a problem with the shirt, not because it could (by a LONG stretch) be interpreted as sexual.
 

Takao

Banned
You know, before I clicked this thread I pondered what kind of gang GSA would be to illicit such a response. A group which stands for acceptance wasn't one of them.
 

Piecake

Member
Deified Data said:
Sorry. It may refer to anal sex. The school seems to think so, anyway.

Oh, I know what you think it is, but I really have no idea where you get that the school seems to think that the shirt was making that sort of suggestive comment.
 
Brian Griffin said:
The principal is most likely a homophobic asshole, which is why he had a problem with the shirt, not because it could (by a LONG stretch) be interpreted as sexual.
Story makes it sound like a teacher had an issue with it first, for what reason we do not know. Then the principal was called in.

Gonaria said:
Oh, I know what you think it is, but I really have no idea where you get that the school seems to think that the shirt was making that sort of suggestive comment.
A school would never come out and say you can't wear something because it's "gay". They may be homophobic, but public institutions like that fear law suits like the plague. They'd have an overt reason for banning the shirt, like the example provided: it could be interpreted as a dirty joke.

But this discussion is muddying the waters. I don't care what the victim was wearing - it was wrong what the principal did to him, end of story.
 

Piecake

Member
Deified Data said:
Story makes it sound like a teacher had an issue with it first, for what reason we do not know. Then the principal was called in.

No, he tried to get the club established well before he wore the shirt, but was repeatedly rejected. He wore the shirt because he wanted to bring attention to the fact that the school didnt let him establish that club and wanted to get support from the student body.

The principle and the teacher had a problem with the shirt because they are a bunch of homophobes who already rejected the club and didnt want that sort of thing in there school
 

Mudkips

Banned
Deified Data said:
Civil liberties don't really exist for kids who wear sniggery shirts to school. Principal sounds like a dick, though.

In the US, civil liberties absolutely do exist for kids who wear sniggery shirts to school.
Your right to free speech is inalienable.

The fact that courts, schools, police, governments, etc. act like minors don't have rights, or that certain speech isn't protected, is a flaw.
 

Koomaster

Member
Totally sickening. That principal really needs to be removed if that's the attitude he is bringing to the school. You really need to get him out to send a message to the students that not even adults can get away with bullying someone.
 

Arment

Member
Deified Data said:
Sorry. It may refer to anal sex. The school seems to think so, anyway.

No. It may not.

If the shirt said "We support you" would it mean he was supporting someones balls in the palm of his hand? What a stretch. By that I mean stretch of the imagination, if you're confused.
 

okno

Member
Deified Data said:
Do you think it could be interpreted in such a way, regardless of intent? The school seems to think so. I'm not saying the school's right, but there you have it.

The t-shirt was, in no way, meant to be a joke. It's silly to think so. It's a SUPPORT group. "I/we've got your back" is a well-known and commonly used SUPPORTIVE phrase. To say the kid was trying to make a joke out of it is just awful. The kid is enrolled in a socially oppressive school and is trying to bring peace to a group of kids who have no voice. He's speaking up for those who can't, out of fear or whatever, speak up for themselves, by taking the heat from others and saying, "we are out there, and we are here for each other." That's what his t-shirt was saying. It's not some heinous joke about anal sex. He was bullied about the t-shirt for openly and proudly exclaiming is dissatisfaction with his peers and his school's handling of the matter. It's extremely difficult for many kids to create a GSA in their high schools. In my high school, it took several years for it to even be brought up to the school board to be voted on, and I'm proud to say I was there, and part of the group effort to get it passed, when the board finally allowed my school to have a GSA. It's a tough fucking world out there for gay high school kids, and this kid did a tremendous job standing up for equal rights.
 

Pollux

Member
jamesinclair said:
Sounds like battery actually.

Do you have any clue what assault actually means?
Assault is the fear of the touching, whereas battery is the actual touching?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom