• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Fellowship of the Ring is ten years old

Status
Not open for further replies.

Edmond Dantès

Dantès the White
It's been just about ten years since we journeyed into Middle-Earth for the first time on the big screen, so I thought I'd make a thread celebrating our various experiences with the film.

But first a brief recap of the film.


What is it?

An adaptation of the first chapter of the trilogy of best selling books written by J.R.R Tolkien (he originally envisaged a different method of release with different titles reflecting the narrative in a more suitable manner, the titles would have been; The Return of the Shadow, The Treason of Isengard, The War of the Ring, Sauron Defeated).

L5GUe.jpg



The film itself

The Lord of the Rings was described as unfilmable, an adaptation that would never capture the beauty or the essence of Tolkien's most celebrated work, but The Fellowship laid many of these doubts to rest in awe-inspiring fashion.

Released on Wednesday, December 19, 2001 and directed by Peter Jackson, with a hefty runtime of 178 minutes. The film details the adventures and hardships of the members of the "Fellowship of the Ring". The screenplay was written by Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens and Peter Jackson. It was produced as the first of three films based on the famous story filmed simultaneously on location in New Zealand, with a budget of U.S. $180 million. Principal photography took 14 months and finished around the end of 1999 and post-production continued long after that.


Posters

sDkk3.jpg
8EpLN.jpg



Principle Cast

Frodo Baggins - Elijah Wood
Gandalf the Grey - Sir Ian McKellen
Aragorn - Viggo Mortensen
Samwise - Gamgee Sean Astin
Galadriel - Cate Blanchett
Boromir - Sean Bean
Arwen Evenstar - Liv Tyler
Gimli son of Glóin - John Rhys-Davies
Meriadoc Brandybuck - Dominic Monaghan
Peregrin Took - Billy Boyd
Legolas - Orlando Bloom
Saruman the White - Sir Christopher Lee
Lord of the Nazgûl - Shane Rangi & Brent McIntyre (voiced by Andy Serkis)
Elrond - Hugo Weaving
Bilbo Baggins - Ian Holm
Rosie Cotton - Sarah McLeod
Celeborn - Marton Csokas
Haldir of Lórien -Craig Parker

The casting decisions were spot on and the dismissal of Stuart Townsend ended up being an inspired decision. Viggo came into the role with little prep time after been convinced by his son to take the role. The production members needn't have worried as he integrated himself into the project with ease and made the role of Aragorn and Strider his own.

Veteran actors Ian Holm, Ian Mckellan and Christopher Lee were perfectly cast, with Christopher finally realising his life long ambition. The Hobbits were cast in an appropriate manner with Sean Astin gaining many plaudits playing Sam.

Liv Tyler was a controversial choice for Arwen, her previous roles gave no indication of her ability to act in such an ethereal manner, but she certainly proved her doubters wrong.

John Rhys-Davies was the perfect Gimli and Orlando Bloom in his debut role gave one of his better performances to date.

The wonderful Cate Blanchett put in a sterling performance as Galadriel, she really stole the show in every scene she was in. A shining light indeed. And Hugo Weaving gave a very accomplished performance as Elrond, although slightly harsh in some people's eyes. That may have been the script rather than his performance though as he did come across as quite critical of the race of men, certainly in comparison to the book.


The look of the film

Peter and co truly captured the feel of the story with a fantastic blend of CG, miniatures, bigatures, and paintings. With truly phenomenal practical costume design and props.


fCY5q.jpg

ornhl.jpg

7CpZt.jpg

nNKX4.jpg

7vW50.jpg

Mf89e.jpg

rjOWs.jpg

TdVXa.jpg

voBjp.jpg

TRt2U.jpg

c3tE3.jpg

mIQCD.jpg



The Score

uwuZ3.png


Howard provided the score as well as his life for a good few years. It really does show as the score was one of the greatest elements throughout the film as well as the sequels. From the heart pounding Khazad-Dum theme to the bombastic and lively Fellowship hero theme, to the beautiful, ethereal and enchanting Lothlórien theme. The songs from Enya also added to the magical quality of the film. And who can forget the Concerning Hobbits theme; wonderful and encapsulates everything about Hobbits. The complete recordings featuring more of the film's music is a must have for any fan.

The Prophecy
Concerning Hobbits
The Shadow of the Past
The Treason of Isengard
The Black Rider
At the Sign of the Prancing Pony
A Knife in the Dark
Flight to the Ford
Many meetings
The Council of Elrond
The Ring Goes South
A Journey in the Dark
The Bridge of Khazad Dum
Lothlorien
The Great River
Amon Hen
The End[/B]
 
Great thread. Best movie of its decade. Boom.

All you have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to you.

*Music swells*
*Frodo pockets the ring and moves toward the boat*
*Sculli cries*
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Ian McKellen was so boss. He's always boss but he was especially boss in the trilogy.
 
I remember how I came to know they were making the Lord of the Rings movies. There was an easter egg preview on, of all things the LITTLE NICKY DVD, and I watched it. Nice and nostalgic.
 

GSR

Member
The three LOTR films have always been very important to me simply due to when they came out in my life. The Hobbit may very well be the first midnight release I ever attend.
 

Xena

Member
I just got the Extended Version last week at amazon's deal. Can't wait to watch it this weekend.
 

Spire

Subconscious Brolonging
You wouldn't believe how hyped for this I was. These films were my life in high school. I still remember failing all of my mid-terms on opening day because I was so excited.
 

Escape Goat

Member
Edmond Dantès;33116491 said:
A mix of very tall people, small people, forced perspectives, and ingenious filming methods, as well as clever post production editing.


Also, Ian McKellan is not a wizard. He knows what to say because its in the script, but in order to become a wizard...he first pretends what it would be like to be a wizard. And he pretends, or acts, if you will, as a wizard would.
 

DemiMatt

Member
This past weekend on Encore they had a marathon of all 6 movies! 1st the regular trilogy back to back (which I planned on watching), then they announced the extended trilogy (which I didn't plan on watching but did). It was the greatest 20 hours in my life. My friend made me a bachelor frog meme that said:

"WATCHES LOTR MARATHON"

"BUYS SKYRIM"
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
I read LOTR after watching the movies.

It was kind of a disappointment although the subtext between Gimli and Legolas made me smile.

The Silmarillion was much more interesting.
 
I have to say the movies were somewhat disappointing (in the way that something incredible fails unreasonably high expectations) but my mind was legitimately blown after watching the extended versions this past weekend.
 

Angry Fork

Member
For some reason I can't remember much from Two Towers except the tree walking which was god awful. But when I rewatched all 3 a couple months ago I remember being most satisfied by Two Towers. I don't understand why. I want to re-watch them again now and see if it has the same effect.

Fellowship was great but 2 main parts dragged it down for me. 1. The greener pastures introduction party 'oh gandolf hahaha' running around jump for joy etc. shit which felt like it took forever, and 2. the scenes where they get to that elf castle or whatever race they are and they have behind the scenes chit chat. Particularly any scenes with Agent Smith or his daughter.

Aragorn is a boss. I wish Legolas got more screen time in terms of combat. I love bow and arrow shit and I always pick that kind of character in RPGs.
 

Grakl

Member
The books were excellent (though The Hobbit remains my favorite), and the movies do them a great service.
 
For some reason I can't remember much from Two Towers except the tree walking which was god awful. But when I rewatched all 3 a couple months ago I remember being most satisfied by Two Towers. I don't understand why. I want to re-watch them again now and see if it has the same effect.

Fellowship was great but 2 main parts dragged it down for me. 1. The greener pastures introduction party 'oh gandolf hahaha' running around jump for joy etc. shit which felt like it took forever, and 2. the scenes where they get to that elf castle or whatever race they are and they have behind the scenes chit chat. Particularly any scenes with Agent Smith or his daughter.

Aragorn is a boss. I wish Legolas got more screen time in terms of combat. I love bow and arrow shit and I always pick that kind of character in RPGs.

Two Towers is simply the best. It feels complete and never gets boring.
 

Kastrioti

Persecution Complex
The Silmarillion was much more interesting.

How is The Silmarillion? The Hobbit is my favorite book of all time (can't effin wait for the movies) and of course I love both the LOTR movies and books.

But for some reason I haven't read or heard much about TS. How does it compare to say The Hobbit or FOTR?
 

Evlar

Banned
How is The Silmarillion? The Hobbit is my favorite book of all time (can't effin wait for the movies) and of course I love both the LOTR movies and books.

But for some reason I haven't read or heard much about TS. How does it compare to say The Hobbit or FOTR?

The Hobbit is like a beloved children's television series.

The Lord of the Rings is like a long, complex television drama spanning a dozen seasons.

The Silmarillion is like the BBC nature documentary series (Planet Earth).
 
I remember sitting in Environmental science, 9th grade, listening to what can only be described as two nerds talking about this movie. They were excited as fuck, I never thought it would end up being this massive, culturally significant thing but boy did they prove me wrong.

I agree that the first was the best, the first feels magical akin to Zelda or something. Second and Third felt too "sword and sandals". Although I do enjoy specific things about all three, the green ghost guys deux ex crap is kind of unforgivable.
 

Angry Fork

Member
Two Towers is simply the best. It feels complete and never gets boring.

I think I would agree even though I don't like the hobbit tree talking parts. I just felt at odds about it because Two Towers doesn't seem to be talked about much compared to the others.
 
Surprised by the number of people saying it was the best. I always assumed people thought ROTK was the best. Good films, although they aren't my favorites of the 2000's.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom