• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Fellowship of the Ring is ten years old

Status
Not open for further replies.
Man just watching that trailer gave me goosebumps.
Am I crazy or did his speech not sound a whole lot different from the one in the film? The emotion, and inflection in his voice all sound pretty similar.

Nevermind the pausing is definitely better and more drawn out in the trailer.

The take they used in the film for his speech was horrible. The trailer one is infinitely better.
 

apana

Member
I don't see a huge difference between the two speeches honestly. I think I prefer the one in the film, something about the one in the trailer feels a bit forced.
 

mjc

Member
One thing that always bugged me was the change from the ROTK trailer to the final movie in delivery for the line: "Not for ourselves, but we can give Frodo a chance." It was so much better than the one they used for the film....ugh. Still bothers me today.
 

Drinkel

Member
I remember loving everything about LOTR when they came out and thought ROTK was the highlight of the trilogy. But when rewatching the EE versions recently something happened much of the cg looked bad (wolves especially), some of the scenes felt campy and the ending builds up with doom and gloom only to end with a superconvinient everything's fine ending, all of the movies seemed to drag on and even the music somehow became tiring despite being great. ROTK left a sour feeling but at least found a new appreciation for the other two movies. I don't think I want to rewatch them to avoid souring my fond memories. It feels weird since rewatching the original star wars only made me like them more while LOTR had the opposite effect. I don't want to be all down on the movies but they weren't as timeless as I'd hope they would be.

Still really excited about the hobbit!
 

Helmholtz

Member
I remember loving everything about LOTR when they came out and thought ROTK was the highlight of the trilogy. But when rewatching the EE versions recently something happened much of the cg looked bad (wolves especially), some of the scenes felt campy and the ending builds up with doom and gloom only to end with a superconvinient everything's fine ending, all of the movies seemed to drag on and even the music somehow became tiring despite being great. ROTK left a sour feeling but at least found a new appreciation for the other two movies. I don't think I want to rewatch them to avoid souring my fond memories. It feels weird since rewatching the original star wars only made me like them more while LOTR had the opposite effect. I don't want to be all down on the movies but they weren't as timeless as I'd hope they would be.

Still really excited about the hobbit!
You're just realizing that FOTR is the true best film of the trilogy :).
 

apana

Member
I think Fellowship holds up better than the other two, but the experience of watching Two Towers and Return of the King in theaters with all the grand battles was exciting for everyone so I can see why for a moment people liked those better.
 
Just had a thought.

Christopher Lee was 23 years old when World War II ended. He has seen so much in his life. I'm 23 at the moment and that has really made me think about just how much the world can change over the course of a lifetime.
 
Watched TTT yesterday, will watch ROTK today.

The movies continue to hold up extraordinarily well, even with CGI Andy Serkis in almost every frame. They did a good job of making Gollum look strange enough that there isn't any Uncanny Valley to fall into, because Gollum isn't meant to look humanoid anymore.

I doubt we'll see a remake of the trilogy in our lifetimes, simply because the current trilogy continues to make money hand-over-fist. The Hobbit should continue that moneymaking trend. I actually wonder how they would film The Silmarillion.
 

Monocle

Member
The take they used in the film for his speech was horrible. The trailer one is infinitely better.
I thought this the very first time I saw the movie, and I've thought it ever since. I can't watch that scene without getting annoyed. How was it not obvious during the editing process that the take in the film is garbage?

I don't see a huge difference between the two speeches honestly. I think I prefer the one in the film, something about the one in the trailer feels a bit forced.
Nope. Aragorn sounds wrong in the movie's version of the speech.

"I see in your eyes...the same FEER that would take the heart of MEE."

His accent is off. The stressed syllables sound weird and he emphasizes words unnaturally. It's atrocious. Very distracting. Kills the scene for me, I have to say.
 
I thought this the very first time I saw the movie, and I've thought it ever since. I can't watch that scene without getting annoyed. How was it not obvious during the editing process that the take in the film is garbage?


Nope. Aragorn sounds wrong in the movie's version of the speech.

"I see in your eyes...the same FEER that would take the heart of MEE."

His accent is off. The stressed syllables sound weird and he emphasizes words unnaturally. It's atrocious. Very distracting. Kills the scene for me, I have to say.

Yup. And further makes Theoden's speech better.
 

Revoh

Member
I'm going to watch FotR and TT EE tomorrow after maybe 8 years, I'm so excited. Can't think of another awesome way to start the year.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
Edmond Dantès;33877015 said:
Another instance of a different take been used in the final cut of the film.

The 'you cannot wield it, none of us can' dialogue in the trailer is said with so much more verve than the one in the film.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPT6B9X-Wsg#t=1m09s

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqbcaxJxeBo&feature=related#t=2m24s

Ugh, it's noticeable throughout the series that at times he was trying to do some type of accent with Aragorn. But the entire Council of Elrond scene is the biggest offender.

"It has no other master"

sound like he's just inhaled some helium....
 

Esch

Banned
I fucking love these movies. They came out at the perfect time for me, I was entering junior high and leaving elementary and i had been fiending out over the books so hard. I was so worried they were going to be shit. The Fellowship dispelled all my doubts. These are the three best fantasy movies ever made, bar none.


Sam: I know. It's all wrong. By rights we shouldn't even be here. But we are. It's like in the great stories, Mr. Frodo. The ones that really mattered. Full of darkness and danger, they were. And sometimes you didn't want to know the end. Because how could the end be happy? How could the world go back to the way it was when so much bad had happened? But in the end, it's only a passing thing, this shadow. Even darkness must pass. A new day will come. And when the sun shines it will shine out the clearer. Those were the stories that stayed with you. That meant something, even if you were too small to understand why. But I think, Mr. Frodo, I do understand. I know now. Folk in those stories had lots of chances of turning back, only they didn't. They kept going. Because they were holding on to something.

What are we holding onto, Sam?
That there's some good in this world, Mr. Frodo... and it's worth fighting for.
 

apana

Member
Well they were on a dangerous mission, they were thinking they had to go through Mordor without a guide. Aragorn probably knew there was a high probability that neither of them would ever get to see their home agian.
 

Freshmaker

I am Korean.
Edmond Dantès;33939637 said:
Aragorn was quite stoic in this scene, almost like he knew what was to follow.
Balancing between the ranger and the undeclared king of Gondor must've been a tough row to hoe. Especially when he knew he'd eventually have to step forward and he was still conflicted about doing so.
 

Snake

Member
Yeah, my father (a huge Tolkien fan) always used to complain about the rotoscoping in Bakshi's LotR, but as a kid it seemed really striking and unique.

The Moria scenes in particular were fairly tense as a child.
 

Sibylus

Banned
Finished Return of the King, the trilogy winter rewatch is complete! Anyone else constantly on the cusp of crying so much with this movie? The friendship and the parting of ways between Frodo and Sam in particular get me really misty.
 

Quick

Banned
Finished Return of the King, the trilogy winter rewatch is complete! Anyone else constantly on the cusp of crying so much with this movie? The friendship and the parting of ways between Frodo and Sam in particular get me really misty.

For Frodo.

*dust fills the room*
 
Reading The Hobbit now. Tolkien is great.

Peter Jackson was the right man for the job, and it was the right time in technology.

The LotR movies are incredible. Just about perfect i'd even say.

And this is coming from a guy that isn't that much into fantasy at all.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom