• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Promise starring Christian Bale and Oscar Isaac is set to Y-Bomba

Status
Not open for further replies.

Trojita

Rapid Response Threadmaker
https://www.yahoo.com/movies/christian-bale-oscar-isaacs-promise-headed-epic-box-office-meltdown-forecasters-170019203.html

A historical epic starring Christian Bale and Oscar Isaac, helmed by a critically respected director like Terry George (Hotel Rwanda), would seem like a decent bet with mainstream moviegoers. And yet this Friday’s debut of The Promise is shaping up to be a big loser on the balance sheet, at least according to this weekend’s box office preview at The Hollywood Reporter.

In her forecast, THR’s Pamela McClintock writes that things are looking exceedingly bleak for the Bale-Isaac romantic drama, which is set against the backdrop of Armenian genocide. Produced for $100 million by the late Kirk Kerkorian via his Survival Pictures, The Promise is predicted to net only about $4 million domestically, which — considering what that means for its prospects in subsequent weeks — is a doomsday scenario. While producers are downplaying such a situation, claiming that what’s really important is that all theatrical receipts go toward funding nonprofits (including Elton John’s AIDS foundation), there’s no way to truly sugarcoat its expected box-office crash and burn.

Eric Esrailian, now in charge at Survival, told THR where he places the blame: “It became clear that the government of Turkey was going to have an influence on this movie. One of the most insidious realities of our existence in the United States is that foreign governments can control art. I would say at the highest levels from different studios, we were just basically told that no matter how good the film would be, it was never going be released by certain companies. I think that that’s truly shameful, but it’s just a reality that we had to deal with.”

That ratio on estimated opening weekend gross in comparison to production costs.
 

jtb

Banned
Not surprising.

I'm surprised someone even greenlighted it in the first place. Looks like a passion project for one of the producers?
 

DMczaf

Member
People are going to trivialize this to "lol bomba" when it's the first mainstream film to tackle the Armenian genocide in a long ass time. :/
 

MutFox

Banned
I love movies where people who aren't supposed to speak English,
All speak English in some broken accent.

Feels authentic.
 

Ogodei

Member
Could make it back on video if it's really that good, although that takes time.

Some stories just need to be told, especially with Turkey getting as shitty as it is, someone needs to remind them that their modern nation was founded in blood.
 
Historical epics just don't work anymore. And it's a damn shame because they're my favorite movie genre.

A big budget film tackling the Armenian genocide should be heralded and succeed and I'm bummed it won't.
 

Kinyou

Member
People are going to trivialize this to "lol bomba" when it's the first mainstream film to tackle the Armenian genocide in a long ass time. :/
Yeah, all the genocide deniers are unfortunately going to be way too happy about this.
 

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
The marketing for this has been a bit weird.

Not sure why the trailer got released so far off the actual premier of the movie, I totally forgot the movie even existed. Few weeks ago it popped back in my head randomly and I googled it t see when it had released, since it had been so long since the trailer came out, and how surprised to see it still hadn't been released.
 

Ridley327

Member
While this film has been dogged by the issue of being astroturfed on user-driven sites like IMDB, I can't help but feel that spending $100 million was just too damn wasteful. It doesn't help that the reviews have been rather middling, which is a death sentence for any drama aiming for an older audience.

In any event, it's a real shame that the genocide deniers will have something of a last laugh at the expense of this film, no matter how underwhelming it might be.
 

FiggyCal

Banned
Historical epics just don't work anymore. And it's a damn shame because they're my favorite movie genre.

A big budget film tackling the Armenian genocide should be heralded and succeed and I'm bummed it won't.

This didn't need a 100 million budget. It should have gone small like Hotel Rwanda.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
you dont make this movie for a $100 million and blaming your problems on Turkey seems ridiculous.

They wanted this to be their English patient but that movie was apparently made for just $27 million.
 

DMczaf

Member
I saw the film last night and what really ruins it is their attempt to "Titanic" the storyline.

The main storyline is about a love triangle between Chris Myers, an American reporter who risks his life to make sure the Armenian people and the genocide are recorded for history, his Armenian girlfriend and an Armenian medical school student who cheats on his future/present wife with Myers' girlfriend.

Theater was full of Armenians, clapping at the end. Probably more about their story being told on a big screen than the actual film. :/
 

Enduin

No bald cap? Lies!
Unfortunate. From reviews it looks like the love triangle dragged the film down and that budget is just crazy unnecessary. Movies can and have done very well just telling compelling stories about real life events. You don't need to make it some grand sprawling epic of love and split loyalties.

At least it looks like it's better than The Ottoman Lieutenant.
 
I first heard of this movie yesterday so I'm not sure the marketing has exactly been aggressive. But that is probably because they identified it as a sunk cost and didn't want to keep on throwing money at it. I saw the commercial and was like Bale? Oscar Isaac? Why haven't I heard of this? But an April release for something like this seems like they decided a long time ago to just dismiss it for whatever reason.
 

Ridley327

Member
I saw the film last night and what really ruins it is their attempt to "Titanic" the storyline.

The main storyline is about a love triangle between Chris Myers, an American reporter who risks his life to make sure the Armenian people and the genocide are recorded for history, his Armenian girlfriend and an Armenian medical school student who cheats on his future/present wife with Myers' girlfriend.

Theater was full of Armenians, clapping at the end. Probably more about their story being told on a big screen than the actual film. :/

That's a really misguided approach to take with this material. That's a real shame to hear about it piling on the clichés when it should have been more concerned with the actual story.
 

DMczaf

Member
That's a really misguided approach to take with this material. That's a real shame to hear about it piling on the clichés when it should have been more concerned with the actual story.

Yup.

If they would have just stuck as close as possible to the actual story of the genocide, with these actors, they would have had something.

Instead we get Titanic: Armenian Edition.

Everything doesn't need a love story :/
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom