ChaosZeroX
Banned
Can't they just relocate them somewhere?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Washington authorizes the killing of an entire wolf pack.
- Thread starter Forerunner
- Start date
- Status
Rest
All these years later I still chuckle at what a fucking moron that guy is.
There is no record of any wolf attacking a human in the entire history of the USA, and I would imagine the same would be true elsewhere as well. We're not in their food chain, we're too dangerous for them to hunt.
There are issues there of the capture and moving of the animals putting them into shock, the results of which can't be known. They also might just make their way back.
Ardenyal
Member
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wolf_attacks_in_North_America
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wolf_attacks
They attack children and the elderly.
Rest
All these years later I still chuckle at what a fucking moron that guy is.
I take it back then. Everything I've read before has said the opposite.
NoblesseOblige
Banned
Most those fatal reports are pre-1900 which I'm going to call sketchy at best. Especially with descriptions like:
http://www.seattletimes.com/seattle...source=facebook.com&utm_campaign=owned_buffer
This article is basically saying there is some evidence hte rancher let his cattle (That got killed) loose right on top of the wolves' den.
This changes my opinion entirely. Fuck that rancher... it sounds like he is tryign to manipulate it so they kill the wolves just cause he doesn't like them, not because they are causing a problem. Sounds like he is trying to make sure they do cause a problem so he can have an argument to get them killed.
Do you realize how spaced out those attacks are? Years apart. Years! That's like saying Washington has a huge rabies problem cause some one got rabies a few years back.
Sure, they are animals and carnivores, they aren't always going to be peaceful. But that doesn't show they are some super menace we need to worry about. You probably have a lot more chances of being attacked by a bison if you are in bison territory (vs. wolf territory) or Moose if they are in a bad mood. But I don't see people advocating exterminating them.
This article is basically saying there is some evidence hte rancher let his cattle (That got killed) loose right on top of the wolves' den.
This changes my opinion entirely. Fuck that rancher... it sounds like he is tryign to manipulate it so they kill the wolves just cause he doesn't like them, not because they are causing a problem. Sounds like he is trying to make sure they do cause a problem so he can have an argument to get them killed.
Do you realize how spaced out those attacks are? Years apart. Years! That's like saying Washington has a huge rabies problem cause some one got rabies a few years back.
Sure, they are animals and carnivores, they aren't always going to be peaceful. But that doesn't show they are some super menace we need to worry about. You probably have a lot more chances of being attacked by a bison if you are in bison territory (vs. wolf territory) or Moose if they are in a bad mood. But I don't see people advocating exterminating them.
Rellik
Member
I heard the song in my head as I read this post. Including the howl.
SlickWilly223
Time ta STEP IT UP
Can't we just pay ranchers for any cattle eaten by wolves?
And if we need to convince ranchers to stop killing wolves just maker that an illegal act?
So annoying.
And if we need to convince ranchers to stop killing wolves just maker that an illegal act?
So annoying.
I mean, a lot of animals attack humans such as moose, bears, and mountain lions, but we don't usually call for the extermination of them all like you seem to be doing. The fact that the wolf attacks on cattle appear to have been intentionally provoked is rather troubling, seems like this is an opportunity for ranchers to exploit by just throwing one of their problem cows in front of a wolf pack and then calling for their complete extermination.
Ardenyal
Member
Oh yeah its a conspiracy!
And you know its BS saying that aggressive bears and mountain lions dont get culled.
Dubbedinenglish
Banned
They are feeding on cattle, a far easier prey to hunt than deer or elk or anything else in the wild. Where ever you put them they are going to seek out cattle which in turn puts them closer to humans and raises the chance of attack.
It's not a conspiracy, there's clear evidence the wolf attacks on cattle here were intentionally provoked by the ranchers.
Also, what I'm trying to say about the moose, bears, and mountain lions is that compared to those animals, wolves seem to be declared as exceptionally more dangerous than any of those even though its more likely someone will be attacked by one of those 3 kinds of animals, like what you seem to be implying with your continual mentions of wolf attacks on humans.
AyaisMUsikWhore
Member
This is what I'm saying?? Like did we have to kill them? Why not just capture their asses and ship them to some deep desert or something? It's insane to just kill them off..
theepicoftyler
Member
I think everyone should stop and think before just asking if a simple answer is really a solution at all. Things like wolf reintroduction are complicated on every single front: politically, ecologically, logistically, ethically... Its very difficult to wade into a topic like this and look at it in black and white.
One of the wildlife biologists I work with gave a talk on this very issue recently and I was blown away at how complex it all was.
One of the wildlife biologists I work with gave a talk on this very issue recently and I was blown away at how complex it all was.
TheStruggler
Report me for trolling ND/TLoU2 threads
The rancher set some of their cows up to be intentionally killed by the pack so that this authorization could happen. They are more interested in getting the wolves killed as opposed to investing in protection.
Horsemama1956
Member
How about spending a few bucks and better secure your product.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked