• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

We had to be sure: study finds no link between cat ownership & mental illness

Status
Not open for further replies.

DOWN

Banned
Though we must keep in mind other studies did see a correlation.

Cat ownership not linked to mental health problems, study says - CNN
https://apple.news/ARmLXwiJ2QK23RuPmsY8FyQ
Studies have suggested that cat ownership could be linked to certain mental disorders, such as schizophrenia, but researchers at University College London say they found no link between cat ownership and the development of psychotic symptoms.

Published in the medical journal Psychological Medicine, the new study is the first to prospectively look at childhood cat ownership and the infection of the parasite Toxoplasma gondii as a risk factor for psychosis.

House cats are known to be the primary host of T. gondii, which infects various warm-blooded animals (including humans) and causes a disease called toxoplasmosis.

According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, more than 60 million people in the United States may be infected with the parasite.

However, most individualswho develop toxoplasmosis experience few symptoms because their immune systems keep the parasite from causing illness.

But in pregnant women and thosewith compromised immune systems, the disease could cause serious health problems, includingdamage to the brain, eyes and other organs. Infants who are born to women infected with T. gondii during or just before their pregnancy are most at risk for developing severe toxoplasmosis.

Toxoplasmosis can be contracted through undercooked meat and contaminated water, but it can also be contracted through contact with feces containing the parasite.

Previous research intocat ownership and the development of mental health disorders has been limited, according to Francesca Solmi, the lead author of the study and a research associate in the Division of Psychiatry at University College London.

"Because cats are the primary host of Toxoplasma gondii, it had been suggested that they might put people at increased risk of mental illness, including schizophrenia, by exposing them to T. gondii infection," she said. "However, some of the studies that have looked at this association had methodologically limitations."

These limitations included studies in which researchers asked people with and without mental health problems to remember details about their childhood, which could have led to errors in recall.

The new study looked at nearly 5,000 people in the United Kingdom who were born between 1991 and 1992 and followed them until the age of 18.

The researchers used birth informationto determine whether households had cats when the mothers werepregnant and when the children were growing up. At ages 13 and 18 years, the children were brought into clinics to be evaluated for psychotic-like symptoms.

After controlling for potential confounding factors, the study concluded that cat ownership in pregnancy and childhood did not play a role in developing psychotic symptoms during adolescence.
 

enigmatic_alex44

Whenever a game uses "middleware," I expect mediocrity. Just see how poor TLOU looks.
First I've heard that cat owners have "mental issues".

Did a dog person perform the study?
 

DOWN

Banned
First I've heard that cat owners have "mental issues".

Did a dog person perform the study?
image.php
 
Time for another study.

I think the problem is potential bias among the researchers. Either controlled by the Cat Yakuza or by the Dog Syndicate

I think we need to look into hiring Dolphins to do the research. Their Aquatic existence should help insulate them from either faction's control.
 
I'm not sold given the hypothesis is vaguely like how chronic subacute reactivation of herpes is linked to Alzheimer's. Would take longer to see.
 
Also, for those questioning the reasoning behind the survey / who didn't read the OP:

the new study is the first to prospectively look at childhood cat ownership and the infection of the parasite Toxoplasma gondii as a risk factor for psychosis.

House cats are known to be the primary host of T. gondii, which infects various warm-blooded animals (including humans) and causes a disease called toxoplasmosis.

According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, more than 60 million people in the United States may be infected with the parasite.

However, most individualswho develop toxoplasmosis experience few symptoms because their immune systems keep the parasite from causing illness.

But in pregnant women and thosewith compromised immune systems, the disease could cause serious health problems, includingdamage to the brain, eyes and other organs. Infants who are born to women infected with T. gondii during or just before their pregnancy are most at risk for developing severe toxoplasmosis.
 

Wereroku

Member
Yeah this isn't about cats causing it. This is about a parasite causing it. Also I am pretty sure indoor only cats don't generally carry the parasite unless they are exposed to infected material.
 
Yeah, but all dog owners are douches.

Weird, people I know who are either cat owners or wish they had cats seem to be the douchey people. Dog owners I know are all really generous and outgoing. Cat owners I know seem to be more selfish. But you know, it's just anecdotal and a small sampling of people.
 

Steel

Banned
I think they need to redo the study. Something must be off here. I mean, they own cats, after all.

Also, the fact that cats have mind-eating parasites is rather disturbing.
 
There was no theory of a link between cats and mental illness. There is however proof of mind-altering parasites in cat feces. This is not schizophrenia or whatever mental illness, it is something else
 

Parahan

Member
Wish people stopped funding "studies" like this and spent more on stuff that matters. Maybe a accelerating vaccine for the said toxoplasmosis.

Sometimes scientific community seems no better than Kardashians, will do anything to put their "studies" on the news.
 

Pagusas

Elden Member
I've found that people who have various mental illnesses (including myself) tend to gravitate towards getting cats versus getting dogs. It might be a therapeutic thing.

Isn't that just because cats are more self sufficent/require less direct care.
 
Also, for those questioning the reasoning behind the survey / who didn't read the OP:
Clearly just a cover, because we all know the real reason was wanting to see if "crazy cat lady" was a real thing

Wish people stopped funding "studies" like this and spent more on stuff that matters. Maybe a accelerating vaccine for the said toxoplasmosis.

Sometimes scientific community seems no better than Kardashians, will do anything to put their "studies" on the news.
Who decides what matters and doesn't matter?
 
My girlfriend is in her third trimester, and we have three cats. She's pretty defensive about them in general when we talk about the baby.

Should I be worried? Can someone explain in some detail the truth about it? Right now there's this casual feeling of 'it'll be fine'. She seems to be under the impression that once you have it, you can't get it again, but that sounds more like a viral infection rather than a parasite.

Please help. Thanks!
 

sakipon

Member
Weird, people I know who are either cat owners or wish they had cats seem to be the douchey people. Dog owners I know are all really generous and outgoing. Cat owners I know seem to be more selfish. But you know, it's just anecdotal and a small sampling of people.

Are they selfish though? Introverts, shy people, people diagnosed with depression etc. are often wrongly thought to be selfish or arrogant. They might not express themselves well. And I could see those type of people rather getting a cat than a dog that you'd have to walk everyday.
 
Are they selfish though? Introverts, shy people, people diagnosed with depression etc. are often wrongly thought to be selfish or arrogant. They might not express themselves well. And I could see those type of people rather getting a cat than a dog that you'd have to walk everyday.

Yeah dude as an pretty introverted shy person with depression I can say with certainty that hanging out with my dog and going on a walk together is the absolute worst. Would definitely prefer having a cat or a rock or something that doesn't really want my attention unless it's hungry.

Have owned a cat. Think cats are great. Prefer dogs on a personal level but not drastically, and there's nothing better or worse about either species. Pet arguments are almost more pointless than console wars.

I do. But that's because I find cats more cute.

GAF's relentless hate boner against cats will never stop, it seems

Amusingly I've always felt that GAF has a relentless hate boner against dogs. Dog threads usually seem to go like "Wow dogs are cool!" and then the cat defense force shows up to put an end to any dog praise.
 

vonStirlitz

Unconfirmed Member
However, if you take a look at the cat drawing thread today, I think there is a clear correlation between cat artists and mental illness...
 

Magwik

Banned
Yeah dude as an pretty introverted shy person with depression I can say with certainty that hanging out with my dog and going on a walk together is the absolute worst. Would definitely prefer having a cat or a rock or something that doesn't really want my attention unless it's hungry.

Have owned a cat. Think cats are great. Prefer dogs on a personal level but not drastically, and there's nothing better or worse about either species. Pet arguments are almost more pointless than console wars.



Amusingly I've always felt that GAF has a relentless hate boner against dogs. Dog threads usually seem to go like "Wow dogs are cool!" and then the cat defense force shows up to put an end to any dog praise.
I don't understand why people get so worked up over cats or dogs. Just get both.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom