Support NeoGAF

[StoOgE]

Riddick.

 

[Stryder]

Half Life 2

closely followed by Halo 2 and Paper Mario 2 and Pikmin 2.. I have a feeling Metroid Prime 2 will be joining these second-place comer's once I get that.

 

[Master Z]

I never thought I'd be saying this a week ago but... MGS3: Snake Eater! Sorry CJ.

 

[nitewulf]

so far gradius v. havent played halo 2, ninja gaiden, mgs 3 or hl2 yet though. but if i did, NG would likely be GOTY, as its more my kind of a game than the rest.
katamari makes me dizzy, any way to reduce that?

 

[Solid]

Riddick is my runner-up. Awesome gameplay. I hope Perfect Dark Zero has something similar

 

[Trasher]

Halo 2, but there are just so many other good ones.

 

[montanha]

Xbox-Ninja Gaiden

PS2-MGS3 or PoPWW

PC-Half Life 2

Gamecube-Metroid Prime 2

Gameboy-Metroid Zero Mission

 

[captainbiotch]

Xbox-Ninja Gaiden

PS2-MGS3 or PoPWW

PC-Half Life 2

Gamecube-Metroid Prime 2

Gameboy-Metroid Zero Mission

Why would you get PoP on PS2 may I ask?

 

[Ninja Scooter]

GTA San Andreas

followed by Burnout 3

followed by Halo 2

 

[Dilbert]

As much as I'm incredibly impressed with Half-Life 2 so far (haven't finished it yet), I don't see how I can vote for anything BUT UT2k4. With the hours I've spent playing that game...crap, I could have finished my book.

 

[JasoNsider]

This has been one hell of a year. I'm really hard pressed to choose a single game that stands head-and-shoulders above the rest so far, but here are my picks in no particular order:

-Katamari Damacy
-Metroid Prime 2
-Pikmin 2
-Ninja Gaiden
-Metal Gear Solid 3

That's five absolutely fantastic games right there. What a hell of a year.

 

[zylo]

for me it's a tie between

and

 

[montanha]

Why would you get PoP on PS2 may I ask?

played it on both systems. yeah, xbox looks bootyful and has the Live features. but at home I dont have live. but the main reason is that I like the gritty look of it on the PS2. and also, compared to Ninja Gaiden, I can't put PoPWW over it..

thanx for asking..

 

[seismologist]

Probably Final Fantasy XI

 

[Slo]

Ask me in June 2005 when I've had a chance to play all of the game that have been released in the last month.

 

[Teddman]

Another vote for Halo 2.

Runner-Up: Metroid: Zero Mission.

 

[Jumpman Jr.]

Katamari Damacy and Burnout 3.

 

[Gattsu25]

I can understand people choosing HALO 2 over HL2 simply because the AI in Halo 2 is so much more advanced that it offers the game MUCH more replayability.

Which is better boils down to what you are looking for...both games are definately worth owning so that's all I really care about

 

[fse]

Halo2

 

[Scrow]

Year isn't finished yet... I still need to get Metroid Prime 2, Paper Mario 2, Tales of Symphonia, TLOZ: Minish Cap, and Donkey Konga (damn Australian release dates). But currently Half-Life 2 is my GOTY and probably my favourite game to date. I've never played a more engaging game before.

 

[open_mouth_]

It's so damn close for Half-life 2 and Halo 2... I'll give the edge to Halo 2, though.

 

[Pedigree Chum]

I'm way more riveted by MGS3 than any game this year. So I'll go with that, for now.

 

[Baron Aloha]

Tough call. Either UT2004, San Andreas, or Metroid Prime 2.

 

[Bauer Action Hour]

So far, it's between GTA: SA and SMT: N.

Fable, Splinter Cell: PT, Fight Night 2004, NFL 2k5 are great fun as well.

Once I get my hands on R&C: UYA and Kotor 2, it's very likely that they'll move into my GOTY contenders list.

 

[disabledHeliocentric]

Ninja Gaiden...? No wait... Metroid Prime: Echoes...or, dude... MGS3...or...Halo 2, or wait I forgot about...(a list of games practically into infinity....)

 

[Gantz]

Action: Ninja Gaiden

Driving: Burnout 3

FPS: Half Life 2

Puzzle: Katamari Damacy

RPG: I didn't play any this year.

Sports: ESPN 2k5.

 

[Falch]

Half-Life 2, with San Andreas in second place.

 

[thomaser]

Animal Crossing It was released here in Europe only a couple of months ago, and I've been playing it constantly. Every single day. It's mundane, but it keeps reeling me in.

I've got sealed copies of Paper Mario 2, Metroid Prime 2, Tales Of Symphonia and Zelda - The Minish Cap waiting, along with barely played Pikmin 2 and Fire Emblem, so I just might change my opinion when I have time for them starting this Thursday night!

 

[Alex]

I skipped a shit load of games this fall, so I just list what stuck out in my mind as the most fun/played this year. I really need to pick up Halo 2 next. Nocturne and Druaga too. Looking at the list, all that sticks out for me is "holy shit, Final Fantasy didnt' suck this year".

 

[lordmrw]

Metroid Prime 2. The game has completely owned me for the last week. I put every other game I was playing on hold because i knew I would probably be disgusted by them for taking time away from Prime 2.

 

[Pjero]

 

[Leguna]

Game Of The Year:

Second place:

Third place: