Interesting to look at. Some launches were actually better than I had remembered. Some of these games are within the first two weeks of launch.
N64 Launch:
9.8 - Super Mario 64
8.2 - Pilotwings 64
1 of 2 titles 8.5 or above
1 of 2 titles 9.0 or above
1 of 2 titles 9.5 or above
Overall a pathetic launch, but it shows the power of one must-have game. I played the ever-lovin' hell out of Mario 64.
Dreamcast Launch:
8.0 - AeroWings
8.1 - AirForce Delta
8.4 - Blue Stinger
7.3 - Expendable
8.2 - Flag to Flag
8.7 - House of the Dead 2
8.7 - Hydro Thunder
7.6 - Monaco Grand Prix
6.3 - Mortal Kombat Gold
8.3 - NFL Blitz 2000
9.7 - NFL 2K
6.6 - Pen Pen Tri-Icelon
8.7 - Power Stone
9.1 - Ready 2 Rumble
10.0 - Soul Calibur
8.6 - Sonic Adventure
6.0 - TNN Motorsports
8.8 - Tokyo Xtreme Racer
8.8 - Trickstyle
9 of 19 titles above 8.5
3 of 19 titles above 9.0
2 of 19 titles above 9.5
The gold standard of launches including a 9.7 and a perfect 10. More than just the scores, so many genres were ready right off the bat. Most consider this the best launch.
PS2 Launch
8.0 - Armored Core 2
8.7 - Dead or Alive 2: Hardcore
7.9 - Dynasty Warriors 2
8.0 - ESPN Winter X Games Snowboarding
6.5 - Eternal Ring
7.2 - Evergrace
6.5 - FantaVision
8.4 - Gungriffon Blaze
8.1 - Kessen
8.6 - Midnight Club: Street Racing
7.3 - MotoGP
9.0 - Madden NFL 2001
7.8 - NHL 2001
4.5 - Orphen: Scion of Sorcery
5.0 - Q-Ball: Billiards Master
6.2 - Ready 2 Rumble Boxing: Round 2
8.0 - Ridge Racer V
9.3 - SSX
6.4 - Silent Scope
7.9 - Smuggler's Run
5.0 - Street Fighter EX3
7.3 - Swing Away Golf
8.6 - TimeSplitters
8.7 - Tekken Tag Tournament
8.4 - Unreal Tournament
7.8 - Wild Wild Racing
6.8 - X-Squad
6 of 27 titles above 8.5
2 of 27 titles above 9.0
0 of 27 titles above 9.5
This wasn't actually as bad as I thought it was, but I think the fact that there were SOOOOO many sub-par games hurt them. If it was 6 of 16 above 8.5, it would've looked better. Still 2 9.0+ games ain't shabby.
Xbox Launch
6.2 - AirForce Delta Storm
8.5 - Amped: Freestyle Snowboarding
6.5 - Cel Damage
6.9 - Dave Mirra Freestyle BMX 2
9.4 - Dead or Alive 3
9.7 - Halo
7.7 - Mad Dash Racing
8.6 - Madden NFL 2002
8.5 - NASCAR Thunder 2002
7.9 - NFL Fever 2002
8.0 - NHL Hitz 20-02
7.8 - NBA Live 2002
7.4 - Oddworld: Munch's Oddysee
8.8 - Project Gotham Racing
7.0 - Test Drive Off-Road -- Wide Open
7.5 - Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2x
6 of 16 titles above 8.5
2 of 16 titles above 9.0
1 of 16 titles above 9.5
Great launch. Many can argue that these games were overrated as Xbox-IGN tended to do that in 2001, but you could have a fun launch day with several titles.
GameCube Launch
8.1 - Batman Vengeance
6.9 - Crazy Taxi
8.0 - Dave Mirra Freestyle BMX 2
8.6 - FIFA Soccer 2002
7.0 - Luigi's Mansion
8.7 - Madden 2002
9.1 - Pikmin
9.1 - Star Wars Rogue Squadron II: Rogue Leader
8.5 - Super Monkey Ball
7.9 - SSX Tricky
9.6 - Super Smash Bros. Melee
9.1 - Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3
9.2 - Wave Race: Blue Storm
8.5 - XG3 Extreme G Racing
9 of 14 titles above 8.5
5 of 14 titles above 9.0
1 of 14 titles above 9.5
Wow. I loved the GameCube launch but it's gotten slammed in recent memory. Some very, very, very good games - 5 above 9.0+. Hell some could argue this as better than Dreamcast! Although Dreamcast's biggest advantage was having EVERY genre covered well, something GameCube has never been good at.
Nintendo DS Launch
5.5 - Asphalt: Urban GT
7.8 - Feel the Magic: XY/XX
7.0 - Madden NFL 2005
6.5 - Mr. Driller Drill Spirits
7.5 - Ridge Racer DS
7.5 - Spider-Man 2
8.9 - Super Mario DS
7.0 - The Urbz: Sims in the City
1 of 8 titles above 8.5
0 of 8 titles above 9.0
0 of 8 titles above 9.5
Ouch. Ouch again.
Sony PSP Launch
7.0 - Ape Escape: On the Loose
7.0 - Darkstalkers Chronicle: The Chaos Tower
6.0 - Dynasty Warriors
7.5 - Gretzky NHL
8.6 - Lumines
6.5 - Metal Gear Acid
6.0 - NBA
7.9 - Need for Speed Underground Rivals
7.8 - NFL Street 2: Unleashed
9.1 - Ridge Racer
7.0 - Spider-Man 2
8.0 - Twisted Metal: Head-On
8.7 - Tony Hawk's Underground 2 Remix
7.6 - Tiger Woods PGA Tour
7.6 - Untold Legends: Brotherhood of the Blade
9.3 - WipEout Pure
7.4 - World Tour Soccer
4 of 17 titles above 8.5
2 of 17 titles above 9.0
0 of 17 titles above 9.5
Good launch, not great. For many however, one look at that screen and they didn't care. Still, 4 of those titles I still play - and kept me busy for months. (How did Lumines get under 9.0?!!?)
Xbox 360 Launch
8.8 - Project Gotham Racing 3
7.8 - NBA 2K6
8.0 - Madden NFL 06
8.4 - Kameo: Elements of Power
What we have so far. Really not as bad as everyone's making it out to be...but I believe many thought Kameo and PGR would be 9.0+. I believe only Condemned will get above 9.0 for the launch. We'll see.
Now I know you can argue specific scores for specific games, but it's really a great picture of how launches have been in the past 10 years.