• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Why do foreign language degrees always require a 2nd language!?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bebpo

Banned
When I was doing my Japanese undergrad degree, besides English + Japanese classes you had to take a literature (non-language) class on another East Asian language. That wasn't too bad although I personally did a Chinese literature class and found it not so useful towards my greater learning.

So now I'm looking into the requirements of doing a Ph.D. in Japanese and besides the requirements suggesting the length of study at being six years @_@ It says that to meet the requirements you must "Have demonstrated reading knowledge in another appropriate language." Which sounds to me like you have to be able to read a 3rd language? Or do they just mean read about a 3rd language through english translations? Hmm, I find the wording kinda vague.

Then it says "In addition, students emphasizing classical Japanese will be required to take one year of classical Chinese". Now I was thinking about doing classical because I find classical Japanese really fun but ummmm considering I can't read any Chinese it seems like trying to spend a year learning classical Chinese will be insane. I understand the idea behind this is because much of the classical Japanese style is lifted straight from classical Chinese but they are still 2 very different languages.

Maybe it's just me but if you're going to devote 10 years of your life to learning everything you possibly can about a culture and getting a degree in that language in order to become a professor of it...why do you have to have knowledge of a completely different 3rd language that you will never use and you have no real interest in learning and it's just a huge waste of time and effort for yourself? Arghh...

Although I dunno my chances for even getting into a Ph.D. program. I'm horrible at tests so I fear for the GRE and you need to give samples of written work (videogame reviews? :p) and I have nothing written that I can just use for the application.

It's like "well you can go get a job now and start making money for life", or "you can work your ass off to get into the program, then not really making any money for 6 years while working your ass off even more, and then finally if you actually make it out you'll have to hope to get lucky to find a job, and then maybe at this point you'll make a little more money than you would've if you have opted out 6 years ago". It doesn't seem worth it from a common sense level. But I really really like learning about Japanese history, literature, and language and want to continue taking classes (as well as wanting to take a bunch of English writing classes so I can learn to write decently) so it seems like the most fun path but the most stupid path.

Meh, life is too confusing at times. I wish you could just go to a road sign and follow the path that seems fun and everything will work itself out along the way.
 

Shouta

Member
How about headbutting the head of the program into submission?

Oh yeah, what university is this =P.
 

Bebpo

Banned
UCI. I did my undergrad there and I know most of the Japanese department and they're mainly great people so I wanna try to do the graduate program there.

Although I just noticed that Chinese majors have it even worse:

Four years of modern Chinese;
Two years of classical Chinese;
Three years of modern Japanese; and
Have demonstrated reading proficiency in another appropriate language

Holy shit! They not only have to become fluent in Chinese but also basically semi-fluent in Japanese even if they have no use for Japanese at all in their Chinese teaching job. This cross-language requirement stuff is DUMB >_<
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom