KO Traveling Hobo
Member
They're middle school students withYou're quite the dedicated fan!
The problem is, none of the points you mentioned in your first paragraph actually mean School Days is good. A bad show can accomplish all those things. (and indeed one did, it's called School days!) Furthermore, the character themselves are bad. Not just in the sense that they're unlikeable, that's the whole point of School days, (although that does add to the problem), but they're weak cardboard characters who do illogical stuff simply to get that emotional reaction you spoke so highly of.
mild-to-severe mental/emotional problems
I'm not saying that Evangelion and School Days are of comparable quality, but you might as well be complaining that Shinji was a bad character for not manning up and beating the shit out of the Angels.