WWE All Stars (PS3/X360) was pretty solid as an all out arcade game that had no sense of "realism" to it. Shame that Take Two doesn't have any plans to shake the current formula up and do a WWE arcade style game since there's still a ton of potential within that sub-genre.
If they could partner with Netherrealm to make a fully featured console version of WWE Immortals...that would be my dream WWE game.