Soo... while we're waiting for the sequel, can anyone recommend a game that'll fill the gaping hole left after completing the original?
Preferably a challenging platformer/metroidvania. I tried Spelunky, but it did nothing for me. Aquaria doesn't look very exciting either. Man even with all it's flaws, La Mulana really did scratch quite the itch for me.
I can't think of anything
quite like La Mulana. From a pure mechanical POV, the Dizzy games are sort of in the same ballpark, but they have nothing like the scale (but more of a focus on adventure game puzzles, for the most part). Chuckie Egg 2 has the scale, but is fairly simple in presentation.
Mind you, one game I've never played is the game La Mulana is inspired by, Maze of Galious. That might fit the bill. Also possible are Falcom's
Xanadu games, of which a few can be found in English (and I keep trying to make doe eyes at XSeed and/or Carpe Fulgur about the PC versions)
Edit: I've just thought of Ricochet on the BBC, which is similar
ish, but has a level-based structure and a more puzzly means of getting around (You have to rebound off the floor to move); There's another platform puzzler with a lot of unique setpieces in the form of Imogen on the BBC, with a remake
here. There's a few BBC games, actually. Possibly Citadel, possibly Palace of Magic, possibly Quest.
I think that's the most distinctive aspect of La Mulana, and therefore the thing that makes it hardest to find comparisons to: Ordinarily with a platform puzzler you learn basic mechanics that might get more advanced over time but everything boils down to the base mechanics of the game in the end. La Mulana, on the other hand, is full of unique setpiece encounters and puzzles that don't share mechanics with anything else; it doesn't conform to a rulebook.