The lobby sucks. I am sorry but it does.
I wouldn't say it sucks, its hit or miss for me, based on who is on the couch with Danny & Chris. Like both those guys, Mary Kish seems cool... but a lot of the rest of the GS crew are kind of ... boring to me... thats my only real problem with it, maybe if I was more invested in the GS community I would feel differently but I usually tune into the Lobby based on the non GS guests, like when Jeff or Greg Miller were on.
I am happy with Dan getting hired, people can wish that it was "not another white dude" but in this case I dont know of anyone I think fits the site better than him, even if I could pick from anyone in the games industry... I get the validity of diversity, not denying its something that the industry needs more of, its just a tough discussion to have when the one thing people seemed to not want (another white dude) is so perfect for the job.
I wonder how many women even applied for the position, I kind of wonder how many women would want to get the treatment that the GB crew gets, the members of the site are pretty open with their lives, I could see that being a turn off for a lot of women... the amount of attention that Robyn got after being in like 5 seconds of the GB East video is kind of weird...
Every female member of a podcast that I have really liked now works in PR/Community management... Abbie Heppe, Anne Lewis, Lizzie Cuevas to name a few, so the number of female games journalists is small to begin with and then if any of them show a good personality that people like some company seems to scoop them up really fast, which probably makes it even harder to find good female candidates for a position like the one they just hired for...
at the end of the day it's Jeff's site really, he can hire who he wants and if people are turned off there are other sites out there with other voices, these sites are more entertainment than journalism, gotta do whats best for business which means putting out a product that people will visit the site to see, so going with an easy fit like Dan makes good business sense too.