Super Smash Bros. for 3DS & Wii U Thread 10: Against the Odds, We Choose to Hype!

Status
Not open for further replies.
The only outlandish thing he's been right about so far was WFT, the rest were all commonly suggested characters.

I think, like someone said earlier, he saw a bit of info pre-E3 and has been bullshitting to keep his 15 seconds of internet fame ever since.

Right before E3 this year, didn't he also get Mii Fighter by that exact name? That's a point in his favor. But yeah, he's done a good bit of BSing. He probably saw "character from Awakening" and just assumed it was Chrom, and the whole "enjoy my good friend shulk!!" thing was totally made up because he thought he was safe.

That said, I still think he's right that Shulk and Chorus Men (or perhaps Marshal) will be on the roster.

Only if you're in denial. Chrom was never planned, and he was named specifically in the leak. What people also like to brush over is the fact that the day before Robin and Lucina were revealed, he claimed that it would be Shulk.

If he comes around and says that the next Nintendo Direct will reveal Chorus Men, are you just going to take him at his word? You'd have to be extremely gullible.

That doesn't mean the leak is totally dead and buried; it doesn't have to be an all-or-nothing deal. All it means is he had a little bit of info and then made some stuff up on top of it.
 
Listen, the fact that Gematsu was right about of lot of crazy things is a thing. But it was also incredibly wrong about some things that should've been a home run considering how confident the leaker had become.

So yes, I believe an RH rep will be in, as well as Shulk. But I believe there will be more.

Edit: Seems like I agree that Gematsu had insider info, but not comprehensive info.

There are multiple leaks, 4 if I'm not mistaken right? Maybe 5?

So far Gematsu was wrong about Chrom and Shulk reveal. Thats two things. And I wouldn't use the qualifier incredibly.

Chrom does have a model in the game.
He was considered at early stages.
A reveal trailer can be easily swapped for another assuming they are both completed.

None of the leakers wrong predictions hinder his other predictions null and void. The leaker has been right about 8+ things right?
 
There is a reason why I have a feeling that DLC characters wouldn't happens because I'm pretty sure that Nintendo and Bandai-Namco might be done with Smash at once the game went gold, but I couldn't foresee that they would postpone BN's games any longer to focus on Smash DLC characters. Colored me surprise if it happened.
 
Sakurai said they are running out of reveal videos..

But they did reveal Lucina and Robin in the same video. Maybe they have like 2 or 3 videos left, but 4~6 newcomers to show
 
why are we putting stock into the trophy direct theory

Because we live and feed off speculation, theories, ideas, and something to think about.

We're bored because we're not currently playing smash bros. :)

I love crazy out-there theories. Very fun to think about.

We want the clouds.

clouds2ho4.jpg


We want to look for some hint and then be able to go back later and say, see, the hints were there ALL ALONG.
 
The Smash sub-reddit was actually discussing this earlier today. The picture is a bit nicer though.

Nwgp6Yk.jpg


Someone brought up an interesting point. Not sure if its been discussed. Just throwing it out there to see what you guys think.

Interesting! Thanks for the link

For Tiki: the theme was from Fire Emblem Awakening.

For Pseudo-Palutena: The theme was from Kid Icarus UpRising.

For FI: The theme was from Zelda Skyward Sword.

For King KIhunter: the theme was from Metroid Other M.

So if there is a logical, the metroid character will come from other m and the zelda one will be from Skyward sword.
 
There are multiple leaks, 4 if I'm not mistaken right? Maybe 5?

So far Gematsu was wrong about Chrom and Shulk reveal. Thats two things. And I wouldn't use the qualifier incredibly.

Chrom does have a model in the game.
He was considered at early stages.
A reveal trailer can be easily swapped for another assuming they are both completed.

None of the leakers wrong predictions hinder his other predictions null and void. The leaker has been right about 8+ things right?

Here's the thing about leakers, if you say something is going to for sure happen, you kind of implicitly stake that on everything you've been right about before.

Chrom wasn't planned. Sakurai said he was looking at Awakening characters and thought Chrom would be boring.

The leaker was right about some things and wrong about others. That means he or she has no longer been completely right. So that casts a shadow of doubt on any past predictions that have still not been verified.
 
Because we live and feed off speculation, theories, ideas, and something to think about.

We're bored because we're not currently playing smash bros. :)

I love crazy out-there theories. Very fun to think about.

We want the clouds.

clouds2ho4.jpg


We want to look for some hint and then be able to go back later and say, see, the hints were there ALL ALONG.


Someday...
 
Only if you're in denial. Chrom was never planned, and he was named specifically in the leak. What people also like to brush over is the fact that the day before Robin and Lucina were revealed, he claimed that it would be Shulk.

If he comes around and says that the next Nintendo Direct will reveal Chorus Men, are you just going to take him at his word? You'd have to be extremely gullible.

You have to be kidding. You think he has no insider information what-so-ever and is just 'lucky'?

I take everything in the Gematsu leak with a grain of salt. None of it is confirmed, but its a strong prediction with insider knowledge, imo. A reveal trailer could be switched at the drop of a hat if both are complete. Perhaps Sakurai saw the leak and changed his mind to pull one over on us and the leaker. That could be a bit of a stretch, but it is possible.
 
There is a reason why I have a feeling that DLC characters wouldn't happens because I'm pretty sure that Nintendo and Bandai-Namco might be done with Smash at once the game went gold, but I couldn't foresee that they would postpone BN's games any longer to focus on Smash DLC characters. Colored me surprise if it happened.

Well, it sounds like they're 'done' with the game now and are just in the 'debugging' phase, according to sakurai at E3.

This means that they have 2 choices:

  1. Move the artists/new feature team onto other projects or end their contracts (or fire them :( ).
  2. Have them work on DLC for smash.

4-6ish months is probably enough for a dlc character or two
 
By the way, if anyone is feeling generous and wants to fix my avatar so that it's the same style as the other sprite characters, I would be most appreciative!

I know I'm super late, but I wanted to do something to thank you for the translation. How's this?
Mac%20Navy%20Blue.png
Mac%20Light%20Blue.png
Mac%20Dark%20Green.png
Mac%20Green.png
Mac%20Pink.png

As an extra, here's non-hoodie Mac with light blue. :)
Mac%20No%20Hoodie.png


Tell me if you want anything else changed too. Don't be shy!

Edit: Added pink shadow, which seems to be an important part of these avatars? :)
Edit 2: Used the original, sharper sprite, added color variants and non-hoodie mac.
 
remember when Sakurai said in the direct that he had to fulfill player expectations and give Lucario his mega evolution?
Well what about our expectations to have freaking RIDLEY?!
 
Here's the thing about leakers, if you say something is going it happen, you kind of implicitly stake that on everything you've been right about before.

Chrom wasn't planned. Sakurai said he was looking at Awakening characters and thought Chrom would be boring.

The leaker was right about some things and wrong about others. That means he or she has no longer been completely right. So that casts a shadow of doubt on any past predictions that have still not been verified.

I agree, but if both Shulk and a Rhythm Heaven rep make it into the game, what would you say then? Do you believe the leaker has genuine insider knowledge?
 
How cool would it be if Mewtwo appears in a Ridley/Demise newcomer trailer? Kinda like a villain reveal.
I can't help but think that there's something up with the villains.

Wario, Ganondorf, Meta Knight, Wolf, Mewtwo, (Ridley? Demise...?). There's an unrevealed villain for each of the most important series.
 
That doesn't mean the leak is totally dead and buried; it doesn't have to be an all-or-nothing deal. All it means is he had a little bit of info and then made some stuff up on top of it.

Sure, but either way it's not something we can really count on anymore.

I agree, but if both Shulk and a Rhythm Heaven rep make it into the game, what would you say then? Do you believe the leaker has genuine insider knowledge?

If I had to guess I'd say they had some access to PR materials from last year's E3 and then made some shit up on top of that.
 
I agree, but if both Shulk and a Rhythm Heaven rep make it into the game, what would you say then? Do you believe the leaker has genuine insider knowledge?

I know the leaker has inside knowledge; I believe that much is irrefutable. But I think his or her info is old. I think the leaker has no more ammo. I would bet money that those two characters are in the game. But Chrom is a profound mistake, that indicates the information the leaker has is old. Very old. Chrom, from the sound of Sakurai's column, didn't even make it into the development phase.

The leaker was right about things, but going forward I don't feel it's a valid way I thinking about things.
 
I can't help but think that there's something up with the villains.

Wario, Ganondorf, Meta Knight, Wolf, Mewtwo, (Ridley? Demise...?). There's an unrevealed villain for each of the most important series.

Yeah, good point. How sick would it be if there's some crazy villain trailer that includes all of them?
 
Only if you're in denial. Chrom was never planned, and he was named specifically in the leak. What people also like to brush over is the fact that the day before Robin and Lucina were revealed, he claimed that it would be Shulk.

If he comes around and says that the next Nintendo Direct will reveal Chorus Men, are you just going to take him at his word? You'd have to be extremely gullible.

When the second leak came out, my theory was that he had insider information on the roster that was not quite complete. After all, he didn't list "Greninja," he listed "Pokemon from X/Y." I was suggesting he saw that there was a Rhythm Heaven representative, found Chorus Kids on Google or something, and concluded that it was them. It could be the same for Chrom, he saw that there was a character from Fire Emblem Awakening, but incorrectly assumed that it was Chrom. He wouldn't have done this for Greninja because there were so many new Pokemon in X & Y that it was basically impossible to make any sort of educated guess.

I don't think it's gonna be Chorus Kids, it's probably someone else (since at this point, it's likely that there's a Rhythm Heaven rep anyway). I'm not gonna take those "this character will be revealed on this date" statements at face value, either, since this isn't the first time he's been wrong (he said Pac-Man, Little Mac, and Miis would be at last year's E3). However, I still think he has some credibility left, but significantly less.

By the way, if my theory is correct, then Shulk will be in. He's the protagonist of Xenoblade, he has potential for a unique moveset, and he'd be the first Xenoblade character in the series.
 
I agree, but if both Shulk and a Rhythm Heaven rep make it into the game, what would you say then? Do you believe the leaker has genuine insider knowledge?

It would have to be a character called chorus men, not just a rhythm heaven rep.

Also shulk is a pretty easy character to predict anyway.
 
I can't help but think that there's something up with the villains.

Wario, Ganondorf, Meta Knight, Wolf, Mewtwo, (Ridley? Demise...?). There's an unrevealed villain for each of the most important series.
Yea, it is odd. The only villains revealed are Bowser and Dedede. There is also who is a villain Donkey Kong in a sense.
 
Zelda gets Impa as a Sheik clone, Metriod gets Anthony Higgs as a Samus clone... then Kid Icarus gets Dark Pit as a Pit clone! Smash has four new clones!

The true meaning of the trophies...!
 
Because putting four innocent looking images in a Direct only for them to be secret character reveals is exactly Sakurai's style.

Palutena, Robin & Lucina playable. That's why.

Where's the reaching for the clouds picture when you need it?

Because we live and feed off speculation, theories, ideas, and something to think about.

We're bored because we're not currently playing smash bros. :)

I love crazy out-there theories. Very fun to think about.

We want the clouds.

clouds2ho4.jpg


We want to look for some hint and then be able to go back later and say, see, the hints were there ALL ALONG.

I guess this will do. Those clouds were already reaching back then and knowing that they didn't amount to anything makes it hilarious.

I typically don't like being a wet blanket, but come on now.
 
Yeah, good point. How sick would it be if there's some crazy villain trailer that includes all of them?

Oh my god. It makes perfect sense.


I guess this will do. Those clouds were already reaching back then and knowing that they didn't amount to anything makes it hilarious.

Except that they did, 100% amount to everything. All the villains in the cloud were all the villains from subspace.

modea01_070720j-l.jpg


Bowser, Ganondorf, Master Hand, and Ridley were all villains in subspace.
 
I can just see the post of the day now:

"Today's PoTD is Ridley! He joins the fray as a boss character on Pyrosphere.

'I'll do it! I'm doing it!'

He never says anything like that.

Sometimes you may wonder 'Ridley, aren't you too big for this?!' But that’s part of his charm."
 
I guess this will do. Those clouds were already reaching back then and knowing that they didn't amount to anything makes it hilarious.

I typically don't like being a wet blanket, but come on now.

Funnily enough, all the characters in those clouds in that image were all enemies in subspace emissary.

Not saying it makes it true, but it is a pretty funny coincidence.

I wouldn't mind the new final boss from tropical freeze.

No. Just... just no
 
Zelda gets Impa as a Sheik clone, Metriod gets Anthony Higgs as a Samus clone... then Kid Icarus gets Dark Pit as a Pit clone! Smash has four new clones!

The true meaning of the trophies...!

...That actually wouldn't be all that bad. The roster so far's been fantastic, having Impa / Toon Zelda, Dark Pit / Medusa etc. as clones on top of that would be fairly welcome.
 
No it doesn't. Chrom wasn't planned. He was hardly even considered.

.

Why are you so sure of this? That's saying it was an easy decision to pick Robin over him when in the article Sakurai says the exact opposite. Chrom was still the natural choice for an Awakening character and not being chosen does not equal not being considered
 
Given that we already know Rhythm Heaven stuff is in the new game, I think Chorus Men is really likely. Shulk remains to be seen, but I think something from Xenoblade will make it in given the popularity of the game.

As far as any other new characters, still betting on Donkey Kong getting a newcomer but that's about it given how we are approaching the end of the newcomer trailers. (unless some of them are kept secret)
 
Outdated argument in defense if that leak does not work because the leaker claimed 100% that Shulk would be shown on Monday. That implies they are still up to date, however, they were flat out wrong, and there was no last minute change because the magazine article was already set up to have Robin and Lucina to compliment the online reveal.
 
Well, it sounds like they're 'done' with the game now and are just in the 'debugging' phase, according to sakurai at E3.

This means that they have 2 choices:

  1. Move the artists/new feature team onto other projects or end their contracts (or fire them :( ).
  2. Have them work on DLC for smash.

4-6ish months is probably enough for a dlc character or two

Hmm, I'm not entirely sure about DLC characters since Gematsu finally got debunked so I don't think we will ever get DLC characters.
 
Does Meta Knight even count as a villain? Seems more like an anti-hero.

He's sketchy, but the only time he was a true antagonist was in Kirby Super Star. Everywhere else he's helping you out in his own way. He'd be a true good guy if he'd just get over his crippling shyness.

Dedede's kind of the same way, but he plays antagonist more often than not because he just wants to get that there Kirby.
 
Except that they did, 100% amount to everything. All the villains in the cloud were all the villains from subspace.

modea01_070720j-l.jpg


Bowser, Ganondorf, Master Hand, and Ridley were all villains in subspace.

Please point out to me Ganondorf and Master Hand. All I see are dubious depictions of Bowser and Ridley in a split-second screen capture.

Am I seriously arguing about this in 2014?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom