Well
there hasnt been a finale that depressing since Book 2: Earth.
I was going to make an analysis of the episode in general, but Ill save that for a later post, because I started writing about Korras journey, the primary thing that matters, and before I knew it, I reached 1500 words. And there is more to cover. The mechanics of the final battle, JInora and kai, Bolin and Mako
.but for now, for the sake of brevity, such as it is, lets just look at Korra.
I think we all have made it very clear that we had issues with her from the start, issues that only grew as her arrogance and bullying did. My greatest problem with Book 1 is that at the end of it, Korra had learned nothing of what it means to truly be the avatar except that she gets to beat the bad guy. In Book 2, she grew even more angry and temperamental, wanting to solve all problems with violence. Her solutions were handed to her on a silver platter from the gods on high known as the writers, and she never actually had to improve to win in the eyes of herself and the cast at large. She didnt learn Air and Spirit, as the titles of the books suggested she would. She was given them.
So here we are at change, and has she learned change? Because this was, by far, the most competently written season. And yet
.I have to say, no, she didnt. The first episode of the season is the first one that has her actually learn and develop her character, where she encountered the first problem she didnt solve with violence, and when she was ousted from the city, she rolled with the punches on the for once wise advise from Tenzin. She didnt take it as an affront, but merely a change, and remained optimistic about the next step in her journey.
After that, she didnt do too much of anything. She tried recruiting some airbenders, with her means of violence, which was typical of her, but at the same time understandable in her situation and
well, rome wasnt built in a day. Other than that, she just chilled around while they went on their mission, visited the metal city, until Zaheer tried (and failed to capture her). After that, she made the decision to go after him herself. While not rash as she had good reasoning for it, I feel this is her falling into her old patterns again
until she spoke to Zaheer.
He told her about his philosophy of anarchy, and for the first time, she couldnt simply categorize her enemy as simple The bad guy. He was not after personal power, nor a hypocrite, nor did he try to excuse his actions with some sob story of injustice. He owned
his actions because he lived his ideals, and thought that he was making the world a better place for them. Shades of grey erupted in Korras previously black and white mindset, and did not have much of a response except to attempt to weakly reason with Zaheer.
She told him that he was wrong in his belief that chaos is the true order of things, but didnt offer any reasons as to why that is. So poorly rehearsed in her arguments was she that she didnt seem to realize that just telling a zealot he is wrong without so much as a counter argument is not going to work.
Unfortunately, thats where their interaction ended. After that, they only communicated under terms of aggression and hostage negociation. Zaheer calls her to threaten the lives of her airbending family. Korra and Zaheer argue over the hostage exchange. And then Korra threatens to kill him as he poisons her.
There is no more communication between them than that, and therein lies the series greatest flaw. They build up this glorious villain. Finally, an antagonist that can truly challenge Korras fundamental beliefs on what an avatar is, and they dont use him as much except an airbender on steroids.
Which is still better than how things ended with Amon and Unalaq, as far as Im concerned. Unalaq was lol levels of awful, this is known. People can defend Amon on the basis that he atleast had an interesting premise, but he didnt end up doing anything with it. Zaheer, however, took what he had and did something that no other villain before him has done: He has humbled Korra.
As I said, Korras world view before was that she was essentially a superhero. She comes in, kicks whatever ass needs to be kicked, saves the day, the rest works itself out, happy ending. Zaheer first shatters this world view by stating his (in his eyes) altruistic goals, which prompts Korra to stop trying to provoke him into a fight and instead make peace with him. But this finale broke something even more fundamental about Korra. Her belief that the good guys win. Or rather, that she wins. Her being the avatar has been the bedrock of her confidence as a person. Book 1 tried to undermine this by taking her away her powers, but instead it reinforced it by giving them back when she decided she was a worthless person if she couldnt throw around fire or rocks when she wanted.
Zaheer, for lack of a better word, beat her. Not even through physical might, because anyone with eyes could see Korra was the superior fighter in the avatar state, though he did hold his own. No, he first beat her by drugging her in the Metal City, then by holding a knife to the throats of children before chaining her, and then he poisoned her. She brought down on him all her strength, the full reach of the power of the avatar, and she won because she had good friends watching her back.
The season ends with her in a wheelchair, still in recovery, 2 weeks after the event. Everyone is kind and appreciate of her, but she finds the words hollow and comforts empty, genuine as they might be. It brings back to mind her earlier lesson from tenzin: Change doesnt have to be bad. Take it as it comes. Roll with the punches. But human beings simply arent capable of internalizing things quick and easy after living a life doing the opposite. It may be wise and correct, but we simply dont work that way.
In the end, I feel like the writers went back and redid the book 1 ending, except right. The philosophical extremist had an understandable position where he was coming from, but he wasnt wrong because he was actually a hypocrite or just plain evil, but because he took his beliefs beyond the brinks of compassion. This is where an avatars understanding should shine through: any peace that is achieved by murdering children is one not worth having. The writing merely faltered in that the writers just sort of assumed the audience would intuitively go with that and perhaps they were correct in that assumption, but the audience isnt the important part here: Its Korra. She should have been the one to call Zaheer out on his bullshit as he accomplished his atrocities. She should have given him counter arguments to his philosophy. I suppose its in character that Korra wouldnt be good at it, but she should have had more than one opportunity to try. Otherwise, Zaheer was a fine antagonist. But the other way in which this reminds me of season 1 is that we leave with Korra at her lowest point. The power of the Avatar, upon which she has placed her value all her life, failed her. Neither the 4 bending arts nor the avatar state itself could avail her, even though she was the stronger of the two. It was her family, Jinora and the air bending nation she brought into the world that saved her in the end. Victory was not achieved through power, but by the compassion they had for Korra as a person and the balance that was brought by Korra as the Avatar. If there is any lesson on what it means to be the avatar that is successfully delivered, it is here. I can only imagine she thinks back to that moment, at that cliff, and laughs at her past self, thinking losing air was the lowest point she could reach. And this time, there is no magical deus ex machine to save her from it. No, having truly hit bottom, now it is up to her to crawl back up. And if there is anything to look forward to in season 4, its Korra finally becoming the avatar she was meant to be, and bringing herself back from the brink.
Edit: Goddammit, I really need to look at the count on a page before I make my posts :/