I find as a guy online dating is harder than just talking to girls in real life.
Sending a message to a girl who gets hundreds of messages from guys a day, waiting to see if she sees your profile or replies, and even if she does chatting long enough to organize a date.. a long process.
To me thats the equivalent of say you walking up to a girl surrounded by too many guys to even get close enough to say hi, but that never really happens. So, you've got a bit more of an intimate encounter and an advantage since you're not talking online, it looks like you've got confidence - and you will increase your confidence.
I'd say these days as a guy, statistically, you have a better chance of talking to random girls irl than you do than talking to girls online. Plus it will benefit you.