Manga News/Discussion |OTY| Creatively Bankrupt

Status
Not open for further replies.
Genos and Speed O Sound Sonic are stronger than both.

I know its usually DTL but i will pull a grimace here.

Cp1ZfD1.gif
 
Plunderer 02

Hey, this got interesting.

Naive girl is still naive to the point it hurts. Red Baron is super duper cool.

Where is this going to go now!
 
tell me when you find something i havent read

lol, that'll be a challenge. we've read most of the same things already. im just gonna re-read jitsu wa watashi wa again and enjoy it from the start and move on over to the pokemon manga, its surprisingly good.
 
lol, that'll be a challenge. we've read most of the same things already. im just gonna re-read jitsu wa watashi wa again and enjoy it from the start and move on over to the pokemon manga, its surprisingly good.

It's really fun seeing how the character models/drawing style for Jitsu changed over time. On Jitsu the scanlator of it will continue, but they might drop it since it's being licensed.
 
Prunus Girl
Finished reading this last night.
It was a fun read I guess.
But... pretty lacking in actual plot and character development though lol.
It would've been nice to have some drama or I dunno, something, between Maki and Aikawa. But they are pretty much the same throughout the whole series. The other characters around them seem to have more real 'relationships' going on, even though they never really go deep into them. But I guess it's just more gag manga than romance manga, so can't be helped.


As an aside, does any body know any decent manga set in Fukuoka, or featuring characters speaking that dialect?
 
shame obnoxious unfunny crap like jitsu wa gets licensed over good romcoms (inari konkon, ran, etc)

rOqKaL0.gif


Dresden please tell me we can ban Wonzo.

Edit:

I would add in dumbyugi but he didn't insult it like Wonzo did. Wonzo must pay for his crimes!
 
a comatose patient who's the main enemy's antagonist, being driven through a forest, with 3 minimally equipped guards, in a horse carriage.

HMMMM WHATEVER COULD GO WRONG!?
 
Momochi-san Chi no Ayakashi Ouji 07

Oh no, I don't want my new friends to know I live with three pretty boys!

So suddenly, I have three sisters instead!

Anyway, this arc is pretty interesting. I'm intrigued in finding out which one of the friends is already dead.
 
You're right, Inari isn't a good romcom. It's a great romcom.

Damn, I had Inari on my reading list, but I'm thinking of taking it off considering the tastes of the people who love it here.

Prunus Girl
Finished reading this last night.
It was a fun read I guess.
But... pretty lacking in actual plot and character development though lol.
It would've been nice to have some drama or I dunno, something, between Maki and Aikawa. But they are pretty much the same throughout the whole series. The other characters around them seem to have more real 'relationships' going on, even though they never really go deep into them. But I guess it's just more gag manga than romance manga, so can't be helped.


As an aside, does any body know any decent manga set in Fukuoka, or featuring characters speaking that dialect?

I don't really think they needed a ton of development. They were both compatible from the beginning, and the development was him admitting it to himself. We're just used to romcoms with soap opera-level twists, or stupid characters who refuse to admit anything for 150+ chapters.
 
I checked Fairy Tail after not reading it in forever and this new arc is actually... kinda not garbage. I guess i'll stick with it for the time being.
 
New Jump Vol Releases

Haikyuu!! Vol 15
k7AbMNO.jpg


Assassination Classroom Vol 13
s2LnE4d.jpg


Shokugeki No Soma Vol 11
W1SykGW.jpg


World Trigger Vol 10
lBTBbXU.jpg


Judos Vol 2
WkIoPuT.jpg


Hi-Fi Cluster Vol 2
KN3pHqm.jpg


E-Robot Vol 1
9kE6ecL.jpg

Holy shit at that Judos cover his hand seriously looks terrible. The Hi-Fi Cluster cover looks really bland and poor E-Robot. I have to say I'm really glad that the new Jump Start series are a lot better than these. I just hope they don't end up getting axed like these series did. I'm definitely setting myself up for disappointment ain't I.

Soma's, Haikyuu's, and Assassination Classroom's covers are looking nice.
 
If you hate yourself enough to read Urasawa, you might as well read Happy! too.

21st century boys and monster were really good, works of art i tell ya!

edit:

wtf is up with hi-fi cluster's hand?! did the mangaka really not ask other people to critique it?
 
Weekly Japanese Manga Sales 16-22

*1. 442,492 *,442,726 Nanatsu no Taizai Vol.13
*2. 311,755 *,311,755 Terra Formars Vol.12
*3. 209,995 *,209,995 JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Part 8: Jojolion Vol.9
*4. 139,486 *,243,999 Otoyomegatari Vol.7
*5. 128,519 *,128,519 Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun Vol.6
*6. 127,643 *,127,643 Tsubasa: WoRLD CHRoNiCLE - Nirai Kanai-hen Vol.1
*7. 106,429 *,106,429 Shijou Saikyou no Deshi Kenichi Vol.61
*8. 104,500 *,104,500 Orange Vol.4
*9. *91,855 *,*91,855 Seitokai Yakuindomo Vol.11
10. *72,149 *,*72,149 Destro 246 Vol.5

11. *70,676 *,*70,676 Dear Boys Act III Vol.18
12. *62,771 *,*62,771 Fuuka Vol.5
13. *58,081 *,278,005 Arslan Senki Vol.3
14. *57,311 *,*57,311 Mayoe! Nanatsu no Taizai Gakuen! Vol.1
15. *56,601 1,117,608 Naruto Vol.72
16. *56,089 *,107,683 Hana-kun to Koisuru Watashi Vol.10
17. *55,900 *,*55,900 Angel Heart 2nd Season Vol.10
18. *55,559 *,*55,559 Terra Formars Gaiden: Rain Hard
19. *54,973 *,*54,973 Nanatsu no Taizai Vol.13 Limited Edition
20. *49,901 *,*49,901 Days Vol.10

21. *49,783 *,*49,783 Domestic na Kanojo Vol.4
22. *45,826 *,*46,184 Nobunaga no Chef Vol.12
23. *41,327 *,*41,327 Tokiwa Kitareri!! Vol.1
24. *40,970 *,151,065 Yume no Shizuku Kin no Torikago Vol.6
25. *38,282 *,*38,282 Usogui Vol.36
26. *37,164 *,*37,164 Nanatsu no Taizai Official Fanbook: Kaitai Sin-sho
27. *37,003 *,181,764 Dungeon Meshi Vol.1
28. *36,593 *,726,912 Kimi ni Todoke Vol.23
29. *34,083 *,*34,083 Q.E.D. Shomei Shuryo Vol.50
30. *33,516 *,*33,516 Fantasista Stella Vol.10

31. *32,792 *,*32,792 87 Clockers Vol.6
32. *30,708 *,302,415 Nisekoi Vol.16
33. *28,962 *,*28,962 Golden Kamuy Vol.2
34. *28,073 *,705,611 Nanatsu no Taizai Vol.12
35. *27,551 *,*27,551 Boukyaku no Shirushi to Hime Vol.7
36. *26,439 *,*26,439 W-Juliet II Vol.4
37. *26,386 *,105,729 Shitsuren Chocolatier Vol.9
38. *24,837 *,210,952 Yowamushi Pedal Vol.38
39. *24,372 *,*45,395 Ao Natsu Vol.4
40. *24,317 *,*24,317 C.M.B. Shinra Hakubutsukan no Jiken Mokuroku Vol.28

41. *23,948 *,*23,948 Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun Vol.6 Special Limited Edition
42. *23,302 *,*23,565 Edo Nekoe Jubei Otogizoshi Vol.12
43. *23,183 *,*23,183 Puchi Puchi Tantan Puchi Tantan Vol.2
44. *22,987 *,*22,987 Imawa no Kuni no Alice Vol.14
45. *22,878 *,*22,878 AKB49: Renai Kinshi Jourei Vol.23
46. *22,490 *,800,539 Nanatsu no Taizai Vol.11
47. *21,251 *,*35,036 Ramen Daisuki Koizumi-san Vol.2
48. *20,703 *,797,083 Nanatsu no Taizai Vol.10
49. *20,601 *,927,405 Nanatsu no Taizai Vol.1
50. *20,157 *,*20,157 Yugami-kun ni wa Tomodachi ga Inai Vol.6
 
I don't really think they needed a ton of development. They were both compatible from the beginning, and the development was him admitting it to himself. We're just used to romcoms with soap opera-level twists, or stupid characters who refuse to admit anything for 150+ chapters.

Well, that's not really what I mean.
I think they were great from the beginning too.
But I have some problem with how they bring in new characters and... don't do anything with them.

Like in volume 3 or 4, the class president just suddenly appears and is a character even though I don't remember hearing about her ever before, and what's this? She confesses to the protagonist!? But... then it doesn't go any where. She immediately becomes a side character you don't see very much, and I kinda just get confused like, ok so why bring her in in the first place? Why have that confession scene?

It's not like I'm saying I like her and wanted to see more, because I don't, nor do I want it to be a manga where they keep introducing new girls vying for the protagonists interest to artificially keep it going. But... it just reads kind of poorly and doesn't seem well thought out.

Another point was when they introduce Kana. Now apparently this girl was the protagonists first love, so when she appears in the manga suddenly, I was thinking, well ok, maybe he still has feelings for her and this will make things awkward for Aikawa blah blah blah, but no. It's just a couple chapters of Maki and Aikawa reconciling Kana and what'sherface, and then again some side character.

It's not like I want crappy drama. Nor do I want some girl to show up claiming to be Maki's (non blood related) sister who is engaged to him. Also she is a dragon.
But it would be nice if they explored his relationship with Aikawa a bit more. One thing I really like is jealousy, but there is kind of none of that. Like it would be cool if maybe Maki, to convince himself he isn't interested in Aikawa because he is a dude, tries going out with some girl, but in the end still picks Aikawa. Or something.
I dunno, I'm not saying it was bad, just seemed kind of lacking.
 
Ore no Pantsu ga Nerawareteita 3

this linen-laden masterpiece finally returns

Junji Ito's Dog Diary

junjiitodogdiary.jpg


Those expecting a spiritual sequel to Ito's masterpiece can keep on looking elsewhere as this bittersweet little tale definitely isn't it. ;-;
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom