This, EDGE did...
I really don't understand why people are taken so aback by the title...sure they got their favorites BUT that's just EDGE's opinion. And besides they do have a strong case claiming that - and they'll not be alone in the media saying that.
EDGE calls it the biggest game of the year.
Wins GAF Most Anticipated Game of 2015
Comes from the studio that in a matter of 6 years puts out 2 Undisputed media GOTY's and another critically acclaimed game.
U2: 96 MC - GOTY
U3: 92 MC
TLOU: 95 MC - GOTY
The latest 2 selling like hotcakes...
And people get upset at some press calling it that....
It's climbed a lot since Uncharted 1.